Jersey Boys Pizzeria

I've been here twice. I tried the Animal pizza the first time and it was amazing. The second time I decided to try the Garbage Can and the Classic. They were also really tasty but the Animal is the one I'd recommend. It's very flavorful. I also tried the jersey rolls and the meatballs. I'd pass on those next time and stick to pizza or maybe a sandwich. I will definitely go back. The young girl waitressing could use some help so she doesn't have to juggle so much. The atmosphere is lacking cohesiveness and needs some more fun decor. Maybe ownership will keep investing in the dining area inside and out. The pizza is so good that I won't dock any stars for that so that others can find a yummy pizza too! Also, please fix the paper towel dispenser in the restroom.

Always double check for your pickup order. My pickup order was brought out to the warming oven, my name wasn’t added to the pick up list to view, and I ended up waiting an extra 20 minutes before anyone spoke up. The young man working the counter didn’t have a very nice response to my frustrations. I asked for a little compensation and I was called “rude” for suggesting. Very odd. My order wasn’t correct either. When I opened up the ‘za, no pepperoni. Complete bummer, but the staff took care of me and didn’t charge me for the mixup. The pizza was awesome itself - even without the pepperoni. Leftovers at breakfast were just as good if not better. The buffalo wings were very good too - flavor and meat. This place looked fun. I’ll be back for sure. A good place to have a small gathering. I bet this place can get pretty busy!

This was some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. We ordered the buffalo chicken pizza and the flavors were stellar! Matt, the GM, was very attentive and made sure we were happy with our order. Super personable guy! I didn’t get a picture of the buffalo wings but wow, wow!! I can’t say enough good things about this establishment. You guys are killing it!

Came here for some good pizza after reading good reviews for here. But it was a letdown. The atmosphere here is not great. Music was extremely loud, and it wasn't very good. The food was okay. I got the gluten-free pizza with dairy free cheese, and the pizza was burnt. The cheese they used was not very good. There were flies everywhere, too. Won't be back.

Ordered what I would call a lost generation combination off the menu for the children and a large cheese for the adult purists. Large cheese was perfect in terms of flavor. Matched any good NJ (or NY) pizza. Crust had a good amount of chew but could have been a little more crisp on the bottom. The kids loved their pizza.

Overall, good pizza for the area it’s in. Not the best, not the worst, but not comparable to NY style coming from someone that is from NYC. Available by the slice for a quick bite.

As parents adjusting to a kiddo with new food sensitivities, this was our first successful family meal out in six months — and it was such a relief. The person taking our order took the time to understand our needs and helped us order safely. Jersey Boys uses a verified gluten-free crust, a separate oven, careful prep, and truly makes the effort to get it right — something we haven’t found anywhere else. We had an 8-year old quite happy to feel “normal” - the board games and pinball was a bonus! We’re so grateful and will definitely be back!

Best pizza in the Flathead!!! Fellow New Yorker here…the sauce is perfection (I could drink it!), normally I’m a low carb girl and won’t eat the crust- good luck with that—it’s SO GOOD! Prices are fair and makes going out affordable!

Highly recommend Jersey Boys if you're visiting Whitefish! The pizza is excellent, the staff is friendly, and the prices are very reasonable! Most of the beer and wine is served in cans, but there is a great selection. The restaurant is set up where you order your food at the counter, then pick a table at the indoor and outdoor seating. This is also a great option if you're looking to pick up dinner!

Great flavor and service The best in glacier / flathead Montana I would say And their chicken wings are bomb We didn't find anything better

Very good pizza, with slices at reasonable prices. Flavor was NY, but the crust was too crackery. Decent rating for foldability. Also, no grease drippage, which is a staple of NY pizza. Taking off stars for the woman who asked no less than six times if we needed boxes or if there was anything she could clear away. This started right after we got our slices and continued throughout the meal. She did the same at other tables too. Poor guy near us had taken a bite from the first of two slices, and he's asked if he needs a box. He probably doesn't, but how should he know after one bite?!? Near the end of our meal, she apologized for being annoying and that she knew she asks a lot. Um, if you know you're annoying, stop being annoying. Four stars for food; two stars for the annoyance.

Terrible pizza!!!! We ordered pizza for our group on New Year's Eve. The pizza was so expensive and horrible. It was dry and tasteless. The toppings were sparse and felt like we were eating cardboard. Even the people in the group who will eat anything did not want to eat it.

Been here twice during our visit and really enjoyed what I had! Meatball pizza, pepperoni pizza, and the meatball sub were all good. Our second visit they accidentally lost our food ticket so they explained it and offered us free beer. That's how you do customer service! Totally made the wait better with free beer :)

This place is awesome the staff really makes it a great place they are all smiles! The food was good too. I got the spicy Philly cheese steak and it was great! I wish I lived here, this would be a regular spot for sure!

Good fried ravioli, and pizza, quick service, chill vibes......... (needed more characters)

On our way into Whitefish and needed a quick easy dinner after a long drive, this pizza hit the spot. Delicious crust coming from a non-crust lover. Great amount of cheese & toppings. After paying premium pricing living in the Seattle area, can also say $25ish for a large pizza felt like a total steal. Would absolutely recommend and will be back next time we're in town.

If you're craving pizza and you're around this area, this is a must try! My group of friends and I were visiting Montana for Glacier National Park. We were looking for places to eat, and saw this place had good reviews. Let me tell you that the pizza here is so good, that we had it 2 days in a row. We had to come back for a second time. The first time we tried this place, we dined in. They offer both indoor and outdoor seating areas. We ate outside because the weather was just so nice. Each table already had parmesan and chili pepper flakes to sprinkle on your pizza. Waters are self-served. They have a wide variety of tables outside, from large bench ones for larger groups like ours or smaller ones for smaller groups. The tables inside are smaller. When we ordered takeout for the second time, the pizzas were still very fresh when we got home to eat it. We got a classic pepperoni one and a white sauce with garlic and spinach pizza. Both pizzas were so delicious and fresh. I loved how crispy the crust was. I also like that you can order pizza by the slice too. The service here was also great. The people who took our orders were friendly. This is a very casual restaurant too.

I was raised on Chicago-style deep dish pizza so thin crust is outside of my wheelhouse. I can and do enjoy super thin pizza however. Jersey Boys was pretty busy when we came in and upfront they told us it would be 45 minutes for a pizza. They said it would be much faster if we ordered slices so we told them we wanted 4 slices of the sausage+pepperoni+onion+ pepper. It was about 10-15 minutes for our pizza (acceptable) and the slices were ENORMOUS. Two slices covered up just about the whole pizza pan they served it on. We could only each eat 1 slice. The crust was thin and very crispy. I found it somewhat spicy and we didn't order bacon but I think that was bacon on there too. The pizza was not what I'm used to, but tasty and crispy and maybe a little salty.

Great gluten free crust on the pizza. Family run joint. Liked it and they even had a ghost fish beer for me.

It was a busy busy evening, but all the servers were super friendly and we got our food much faster than expected. The huckleberry beer was a nice surprise, and the pizza was excellent. It's not a huge place, so when it's busy it is loud. They also have outdoor seating. Definitely a great place for pizza

Amazing food, even better customer service. Very quick service and accommodating. Caprese slice was great and they even threw in a second slice since they thought the slices were small.

Honestly was expecting a bit better pizza given how long of a wait it took to get it. They were VERY busy on a Thursday night, and we waited over an hour for our pizza and side salad. After we ordered, the woman working at the register was very transparent with how long of a wait we had, but I wish she would have told us BEFORE we ordered so we could have made a decision to go somewhere else. The veggie pizza was good, but not an hour and 15 minutes wait good. While we were eating outside, a man was walking around greeting tables & checking in (I'm assuming the manager) and he was very friendly and personable. I'd recommend ordering here far in advance of when you want to eat and placing your order to go!

Was in town for one night and hungry for Pizza, glad I went this route! I used their online ordering, super easy and it gave me a wait time of about 50 minutes. Went with the Animal, was very happy with it. Great crust and sauce that was flavorful, the crust wasn't too thick so it made for the perfect balanced slices in my eyes! When I got there they were really busy but the staff was friendly and they were doing a great job pumping out pizzas! Excited to try more from Jersey Boys! 9/10. Cheers!

Visiting from out of town. Ordered a combo pizza minus pepperoni and me and my husband both loved it! The best pizza we've had in a very long time. We went in around 4:45 pm on a Thursday and dined inside. We had our pizza within 15 mins.

Jersey boys was a very tasty (and fairly economical ) choice for dinner while visiting. Their pizza roll garlic things are incredible... those are a must order! The pizza was also tasty. Their prices were reasonable for the area. The only downside was that they were so busy (obviously not a problem for them) which meant a bit of a line to order and a bit of a wait, but overall it was very good!

Always friendly service and great pizza. Been coming here for years when I'm in town. Highly recommend.

Great staff, great pizza, great price! It was highly recommended, and didn't disappoint. We were staying in White Fish, so it was also very convenient after a long day of hiking. Sorry no pictures, we were starving, lol!

Someone recommended this place for us while vacationing in Whitefish. I am so glad we gave this place a try, the pizzas here were incredible good, service was pretty fast as well. I highly recommend this place.

Like I just said- I'm a food snob and I love pizza! Jersey Boys is one of the best in northwest Montana. Top three!

We ordered by phone a large meat and veggie pizza loaded with it all but olives. We picked it up in 2 hoursbut it was New Years Eve so we give them a freebie on that and they explained up front it would be a 2 hour wait. So all was good. This pizza was definitely worth the wait! It was hand tossed and all the ingredients were fresh with the perfect amount of sauce and cheese. Their pizza is on the thin side except for the crust. We ate the leftovers for lunch two days later and it was just as good! Sorry for no photos!

Hands down the best slice I have had in a long time! Nicely done on the Caprese, tomatoes added after...yummy!

We ordered 3 pizzas and they were absolutely amazing!!! We didn't actually go and sit in the restaurant as we ordered take out. I would absolutely come back for more pizza!

Ordered delivery while on Trafalgar tour to grouse mountain lodge and the delivery was on time, pizza and salads were excellent. Just what we needed!

We decided to stop here for dinner on a Saturday night. It took close to a hour to get our pizza, but that is expected for the summer and weekend. We ordered the jersey buns which were great, and a pepperoni pizza.

Killer Pizza! Wait can be long with all the Non-Locals in town - Put it in your face !

Phenomenal! We showed up 10 minutes before closing after a long day at Glacier National Park (we know.. bad form on us). We were prepared to just grab whatever they had leftover from the day, but they made new pizzas for us! The host was welcoming, funny and super gracious. Plus, the pizza was DELICIOUS! Couldn't say enough good things.

Chris and Dave and staff super friendly. Gave us great local recommendations while in town and the Pizza was very good, coming from a NY'er. Would def go back next time in town. Many toppings available.

Holy cow! Best customer service along with delicious pizza. Our order got lost in the rush and we had to come back later and they comped our dinner! Thanks Jersey Boys!!

This place was a great stop on Friday night in Whitefish. Service was super friendly and fast. We got the "Buffalo Chicken 18" Pizza" which was super tasty! Not overly spicy and well balanced with all the toppings. Their dough is crispy and delicious, definitely stop here for a good slice. Wish you were in Missoula!

I have only had slices and sandwiches from here and they were always great. Today I got a whole fresh pie, and I got to say it's even better that way. The pizza was so good. Fresh ingredients and a great dough. The service was great. Everyone was friendly and helpful. The location is kind of small, but does have a few indoor and outdoor tables. Right in downtown Whitefish. Worth a check for sure. 5/5 all the time!

Carry out barbecue chicken pizza and jersey buns. Both were fantastic! Busy...almost a 3 hour wait for carry out, so plan ahead! The food was hot and ready on time and was great!

We love Jersey boys to go, we get it often. There is also done in & a patio available. We appreciate the order ahead convenience and the food is great. As an aside, the pizza boxes are really fun!!

Some of the best pizza I've ever had in my life. So much creativity and quality being served at this place it's truly impressive. What a gem!

Every time we are in Whitefish we eat here 2-3 times. For our wedding after party we served Jersey Boys as a late night snack. We often salivate at the thought of our favorite items and contemplate a trip out to Montana from California for this spot alone. We are pleased every time we visit and now holds a special place in our memories along with our wedding day. So yeah, it do be good.

Solid pie. Got the combo for takeout. Filled me for dinner and breakfast. Loved the bite to the crust. Nice.

We had a great time at Jersey Boys! We were visiting from out of town, all the employees were very nice. The wait was a little long but they let us know when ordering and the atmosphere was great. Pizza is really good and they have a great drink selection. We would definitely go there again!

We happened upon this place while looking for a place to eat. You can't go wrong with pizza, so we decided to give it a try. Glad we did. We ordered 1/2 cheese and half pepperoni. It was so good. It was thin crust with enough of everything. I wish we could have taken the left overs to go, but were leaving town the next morning. They offer local beers and the staff is excellent at helping you find one you would like. They were fast with the pizza. There's inside and outside seating. The inside area is small, but there's enough seating Parking is street parking. Not difficult to come by in the evening

Whitefish, MT is by far one of the coolest little towns!! Jersey boys has that small town charm but also very hip. The people there are super nice and it's nicely located in downtown. Whitefish has plenty of downtown parking but we walked from our condo we rented. The entire downtown is walkable! The food was phenomenal! The pizza had a nice crispy crust, great sauce and a good combo of toppings and cheese. The star of the show was the jersey buns though!! Worth every single penny!!!!! It's like a cinnamon roll but with dough, garlic and cheese. You can't get any better than that!!! A huge mouthful of YUM! Price was good and they offer so many options including sandwiches, salads and gluten free crust!

Visiting Whitefish for the first time with my family and we were searching for good pizza. Jersey Boys Pizza had the best reviews so we went to check it out and I can confirm the reviews were spot on. Fresh, homemade and delicious. We got the animal pizza (meat lovers) and my parents got the monster pizza (supreme) and it was a 15/10. Highly recommend.

Delicious! And the service was fantastic in spite of the fact that our group and another large group came in within an hour of closing time. Loved it!

This place is phenomenal. I got a slice and then the jersey buns and I don't regret it at all. I was drooling just looking at the pics. Stop here if you are visiting.

Stopped by on the way through town and were blown away. Very good New York style pizza, great dough!! We got a calzone as well and it was delish. Service was awesome and super thoughtful. Helped us order, and checked in through the meal. Nice offering of drinks, and great prices. A little outside of the main town so of plenty of parking when we went. Outdoor tables were clean and nice to sit at. Would totally come again!

I went with my daughter to get myself a pizza to eat in and then getting a pizza for my wife to go. I got there abiut 45 min before closing. It took 20 min for my wife's gluten free pizza (which they could do all pizzas gluten free 10"). The music was great (90's alternative) and the staff was nice. If I had to do it all over again I would of ordered ahead and had the pizza ready, but it wasn't that long of a wait.

Ordered a large pizza, the place was busy but we were not informed of any unusually long wait times. After more than 45 minutes we asked how much longer it would be and were informed another hour. Nearly 2 hours total for 1 pizza with zero warning or apology when we asked to cancel the order.

Had sausages and mushrooms. Best pizza I have ever had. Recommend the pizzas to everyone. Definitely will be coming back

Amazing food not only way the pizza great but everything else was great to. We were so satisfied we went two nights during our vacation. The service was slow with hour waits for takeout and dine in but worth the wait(We reccomend bringing a card game). Loved this place.

This is the best pizza I have ever had. Fresh and homemade every day. Mark was very nice and asked how he could help any way. Small but home and very clean.