Joe's Rotisseria

Stopped here after an excursion to the DMV in Elizabeth. First timers, so we just ordered a cheese pie. The owner was friendly as soon as we walked in and told us it would be about 8 minutes for the pizza- super fast! I would be surprised if he even crossed the minute mark before it was in the oven. Great conversation with the owner while we waited, and learned he had a spot near Asbury Park before moving here and opening this location. They do some cool things like “2 foot slices” (for those days you only want a slice lol). Countless specialty pies if you are in the mood for unique offerings. A large cheese pie is less than what you would pay at a chain- that’s a huge win win- support local! After getting our hot pizza, my wife and I knew 2 bites in that we would be coming back. Great flavor on the sauce and quality cheese. They cook their pies half in the pan and half on the stone and the crust is almost airy with just the right amount of crunch at the end. We loved talking to Joe about his fav spots in NJ and NY- and he is a pretty humble owner that gives flowers to the spots that he thinks are doing it right. Will definitely be back! Pro tip: Don’t be embarrassed when Joe asks if you need a box for leftovers and you realize there are no leftovers! 😃

Delicious! First time having pizza from here. I read reviews and ordered the Sicilian pie with fries on the side, garlic bread, and rice balls… all is AMAZINGLY DELICIOUS! Must try if you are in town. Highly recommend this place. The people in here are very nice as well. Update: second time ordering to go… beat expectations. Delicious grandmas pie, half pepperoni. Met the owner as well, his kids, and his mom. They made me feel like part of the family. This is now my only place for pizza. See pictures attached.

I’ve now ordered from this place 3 times in last month. The Big Mac pizza is insane with the garlic knot crust. This pizza is top tier. I love a thin crispy crust as the baseline pizza and theirs was great so I ordered the Big Mac pizza and I fell in love. Somehow the pizza stays crispy with all the ground beef and cheese on top. The fries I could do without but it’s so good I don’t even care. I am literally eating 3 day old leftover Big Mac pizza and it still tastes amazing so I had to come leave this review.

The food itself is good. What I will say is that it is over priced but whatever, I get it. These are speciality pizzas so that’s to be expected. However, the lady that’s answering the phone and working at the counter is why I’m writing this review. That is the worst customer service I’ve received in a long time. I used to work in the food business for years so I very rarely write bad reviews about someone’s attitude but this lady honestly should not be working there. She had the nastiest and most condescending attitude over the phone all because I asked her to repeat the order back to me and repeat the pick up time. I arrive last night (Thanksgiving eve) for my 7:45 pickup time at 7:42. When I get to the store and identify my order the lady says under her breath “oh yea this is the one that couldn’t hear me” … excuse me? And to top it off my order wasn’t even ready. She had the nerve to basically tell me that I came too early. Lady I’m here 3 mins early. Normally I wouldn’t even care about that but I rushed to be on time because of her bad attitude over the phone. I wanted to pick up at 8 & she told me I could only do 7:45 so I was trying to be courteous TO HER. Overrall I will never be back here again. I’m seeing other bad reviews about the same lady and clearly the business doesn’t care and won’t do anything about it’s no point in complaining. I can buy $50 pizza elsewhere.

The pizza bread is the best. Def ge5 the garlic bread (crowd fave and my bro is hella picky)... it was my niece's birthday (7) and she luuuuuved it... oh! Also got 20 wings and the boy recommended i do 10 bbq and 10 another flavor i forget, and im so grateful for that recommendation!! this is right off thr train station in roselle. We got a whole hawaiian and a half chees4 and half pep and boy was it a hiiiit (ppl kept asking for more hawaiian)!!! We eating the leftovers (heat them up in the lil oven) now and them so tastyyy!! Toss ur dominos/ Ceasars/ papa apps and buy from local places like these. I don't have to tell you, you'll see the difference. Thank you guys I know i sounded a lil sketchy on the phone but thank you for your patience -very sweet ppl working here 🐔🐔🐔

Super amazing food was great The people was amazing and great definitely dope chill spot joe is amazing with his staff he puts a lot of love into every meal my opinion best pizza in New Jersey keep up the great work

After 2 years of following on IG our family was COMPLETELY blown away, Amazed and happily FULL!!! Joanne took great care of us and walked us thru their incredible and overwhelming choices. We knew for sure we wanted buffalo chicken something.....dear God it did NOT disappoint. Then we got a TRIPLE THREAT😱😱😱 and thunder-sticks 😱. This place is just the best kept home-town best pizza and at this point the 1-hour drive is A piece of cake and we will be back. Hat's off to Joe!!!

First time visiting Joe’s Rosteria in Roselle Park and it was absolutely delicious! The food was fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care. The lady at the register was incredibly friendly, welcoming, and very hardworking — she really made the experience even better. I’ll definitely be coming back and highly recommend stopping by if you’re in the area.