Wells L.
Yelp
TL:DR - Not just about the experience, the food is legitimately above average. This is a great great great place to celebrate birthdays, they really go above and beyond to make you feel special. The extra cost for a window table isn't really worth it. DJ was terrible.
Wow, I was honestly not expecting much, but this place really impressed. My partner and I came on for a dinner cruise to celebrate her birthday. It just happened to also fall during restaurant week, and so we saved a good chunk of change there. But from the moment we got on the boat, we were continuously surprised and impressed by their service and attention to detail.
When making our reservation, I did indicate it was her birthday, and each staff person knew it. The individual at the ticket booth even said happy birthday. Once we got in the boat, we were impressed by the interior dining room. It resembled a higher end wedding venue, equipped with a light up dance floor and a back lit Odyssey sign. The tables was also set up well. Off the restaurant week menu, my partner and I got the lobster bisque, Caesar salad, short rib, mushroom ravioli, and the dessert bar. When I first reserved the cruise, I was assuming the food would be subpar, and had resigned to the fact that you were really just paying for the experience, not the food. But the food was delicious and rivaled some of the restaurants that don't cruise Lake Michigan. The lobster bisque was super light and delicious. Creamy with a perfect hint of lobster. The Caesar salad was also good, my only gripe is that the romaine came whole vs. chopped up. While it looks nice in terms of presentation, it's much more annoying to eat. I didn't try the ravioli, but my partner said it tasted cooked, but a little hard/chewy (undercooked?). The short rib was the star of the night, however. Super meaty and savory sauce that coated a perfectly cooked short rib. Fall off the bone that included a good amount of fat. The dessert part had a huge variety of desserts. Each being better than expected (I was expecting a continental breakfast quality type dessert), but nothing spectacular. They had carrot cake, lemon tart, salted caramel tart, coconut cream cake, and fruit.
The other thing that impressed me, beyond the food, was how much they make birthday people feel special. Once on board, there was a nice captain's hat for the birthday girl and a button that said "Captain's Crew" for their accompanying partner. They also gave each person an personally signed large gold birthday card (signed by the captain) that also invited them + a partner to the cockpit/steering room. They also gave each birthday person an individual 6 in/8 in birthday cake (I'm terrible at guessing size). We were so stuffed from dinner we didn't get a chance to try it, but they did pack it up for us.
A couple of other notes, the DJ on board was so bad. I only noticed 1 or 2 transitions, otherwise it felt like we just had an ipod playlist going. In addition, there was no logic behind any of the songs he choose and in what order. He'd play one 80's song, then a slow song, then a pop song, then another slow song. I had no idea what he was trying to do. In addition, his schpeel about thanking people for celebrating their birthdays with the boat, people from in and out of town, and in and out of country was so rehearsed and he said it so many times, that I knew it by heart by the end of the cruise. The DJ was just a bad experience the whole way around. Also, I don't think it's personally worthwhile to pay the extra $100 for a window seat. Many of the tables were within viewing distance of the window. In addition, at night, you don't really see much. And you honestly stop looking out the window so much about 30 min into the cruise.
All in all, this was a super surprising trip. It was more than worth it for the restaurant week price, and would totally be worth is for a special birthday.