Andy C.
Yelp
Forced to reconsider and calibrate expectations and ratings. It's a resort town but trying to consider location and pricing makes it even hard to assess.
Space is modern but comfortable. Service is kind and professional. Loved the tree in the center of the dining room, with the shadows projected on the ceiling. I understand it only opened a few months ago so everything is quite new.
Arrived a little early for a reservation for 3 and seated in the lounge area, offered water and had the chance to order and sip on drinks. Eventually seated at the counter in front of Chef Peter, and we were able to order sushi directly with the chef himself.
Ordered a good mix of rolls, a cooked miso cod plus 2 orders of the sashimi combo. Our added bites were sea perch (I almost always get this if it's available) and o-toro (noticed this was almost ice cold). The o-toro seems like a no brainer if you want tuna at all, as the lean tuna was $10, chu-toro at $11 and o-toro at $12. Sashimi cuts were very generous, in terms of thickness. However, this seemed to highlight one noticeable flaw, which was how watery the cuts were. Not sure if thinner slices would have saved it but was noticeable even in the toro roll. That said, you get your value in quantity, and the flavors were on point.
Otherwise, the rolls were pretty good, with many strong flavors which could be good or bad depending on preferences. The wagyu on the crypto roll (only on half of our order) was lost. It might have provided some richness but as with the other rolls there was a lot going on. Cod was cooked well. Chef Peter was quick to respond to sushi orders and kind enough to explain that dark sushi rice was colored from aged vinegar. It didn't have the texture of brown rice or taste like soy sauce so I was curious, but our rice were mostly in rolls so I assumed it could have been sauces. However, we did see a massive order of 11 toro hand rolls with caviar for another party and could clearly see the color of the rice, so we had to ask.
We ended with a black sesame vanilla ice cream, and was gifted an additional hojicha softy as well, apparently a personal favorite of the chef. Both were absolutely delicious, and that's coming from someone that doesn't normally care much for dessert.
For the price, the wateriness of the fish would normally get a harsher review from me. I understand that most fish need to be frozen to a certain extent but there's definitely a difference in the texture vs. examples elsewhere. Still, considering the location, the quality and comfort of the facilities, along with the friendly staff and service, it adds up to a strong experience overall and a warrants a solid recommendation.
It would be unfair to compare to omakase quality in Tokyo and New York even if the prices start climbing into the same territory. Considering the expected clientele there will definitely be customers with even more experience with sushi and I would be very curious about their opinions. For what it's worth, one dining companion was ready to replace a reservation at another spot in town with a repeat booking here.