Mike F.
Yelp
Simply put, there is no place I would rather stay in all of Key West. This amazing antique house makes the perfect B&B, and it's priced to work with any budget.
I will start with this - don't let the shared bathrooms scare you away if all that's left is a room on the second floor. They're kept immaculately clean, and not once during our entire stay did my wife or myself find anyone else in them when we wanted to use them. Aside from being across the hall, they were just as good as a private bath.
This was our first visit to Key West, and as such, the staff was more than willing to be our concierge. EVERY SINGLE RECOMMENDATION THEY MADE WAS SPOT ON!!! I cannot stress enough how well they know what's good, what's bad, where to go, and what to do. If you want to plan an itinerary, I reviewed all their recommendations on Yelp, so check out my profile ;-) The staff, overall, were delightful, helpful, and cheerful... they made the stay that much better.
The house itself is a late 19th century building, meticulously cared for. The decor and furniture reflects this, and it all culminates as a warm, inviting, and comfortable place to stay. You feel more like you're staying at a friend's house than at a hotel... with free WiFi and your friend's making you breakfast. And a friend's house that's within walkable distance of everything downtown, with bikes to rent if you don't feel like walking!
The breakfast is a vast assortment of fruits, drinks, and breads... I describe it as the worlds best continental breakfast. There are no eggs or waffles, but the selection is fresh, delicious, and top quality. The antique OJ juicer they have convinced me to get one on eBay immediately!
To sum it up... if you stay anywhere else, you're either stubborn, foolish, or just don't know how to read. Stay at the Key West Bed & Breakfast, there aren't any better options in all of Key West!