Elaine S.
Yelp
Good: Ambience, the staff, the baskets of bread, the soup, chocolate brownie desert.
Bad: Main course.
Let me start by saying that the setting and the staff of La Peniche were wonderful. The starter of potato soup was very nice and the chocolate brownie desert was also decent. I'd have starved without the basket of bread at our table though as the main course left much to be desired.
I want to preface my comments with the fact that I'm a vegetarian so my choice was limited to one, suspect-sounding option, "Roast vegetables with couscous and feta cheese". Now, any food-lovers reading this will probably be scratching their heads at that sentence and claiming that none of the three elements would seem to go together, and they'd be spot on. They don't, especially not cooked the way these were. Limp vegetables with a side-dish of couscous and 4 or 5 lumps of feta on top. I made an effort to eat though as I hate to waste food, but eventually I had to give up and fill myself with the basket of bread. My companion who ordered the pork main was similarly disappointed with her dish, but when I've heard that everything's reheated on board, it's probably silly to expect culinary excellence.
Obviously I rate a restaurant based on its ability to cater to me because even a half-way decent chef will be able to dream up something edible for the veggie option, so I won't be returning to La Peniche. It shows a lack of being bothered to produce quality food, in my experience, to slap three uncomplimentary elements together and try to pass the result off as a meal.
In La Peniche you pay for the experience and once was quite enough for me. Myself and my partner don't often spend upwards of €120 eating out but, when we do, we expect to enjoy what we're eating.