Nyal F.
Yelp
We were here about 1.5 hours after landing in SJU. My daughter had given up 18 months of vegetarianism to have "the pig". And the fact that I hadn't been anywhere but Cunao in 30 years, but wanted to give something else a chance. First starting off with why no five stars. Despite some decent Spanish and knowing all the food since I was a kid, lechonaras without waitstaff can be challenging to order from. Like you don't know the system. But maybe that one star is on me, my family left Cayey years ago, give me a lot of knowledge, but not how to order in everyone of the 20 plus lechonara in a 10 mile stretch. Or of course that nothing is ever marked as to the price. Menus are just kinda lists.
But anyway, great food, I mean every thing was well seasoned and well cooked. Habichuelas, gandules, arroz blanco the bomb and of course my pescatarian wife has been to PR enough times to know she's going to find pork in the habichuelas and probably chicken broth in the rice at best. The lechon was perfect and ribs pretty damn good as well. On the not meat side, I thought i ordered yuca frita but got yuca guisada which was actually even better and maduros which were also outstanding. The service despite the misunderstanding was fantastic and everyone there is superfriendly and seemed super proud of their work. So here's the secret related to me by a kind cayeyano fellow customer, to the right hand side, there are styrofoam container, labeled 1 to 5, 1 is probably good for an individual or little people to taste, 5 is you are going to a party, when you figure that out, you have a 5 star experience. Oh and by the way, the prices are great, we had our entire lunch including soft drinks for 4 for 50 bucks.