Left Hand Coffee

Coffee shop · Montauk

Left Hand Coffee

Coffee shop · Montauk
83 S Elmwood Ave, Montauk, NY 11954

Photos

Left Hand Coffee by null
Left Hand Coffee by null
Left Hand Coffee by null
Left Hand Coffee by null
Left Hand Coffee by null
Left Hand Coffee by null
Left Hand Coffee by null
Left Hand Coffee by null
Left Hand Coffee by null
Left Hand Coffee by null
Left Hand Coffee by null
Left Hand Coffee by null
Left Hand Coffee by null
Left Hand Coffee by null
Left Hand Coffee by null
Left Hand Coffee by null
Left Hand Coffee by null
Left Hand Coffee by null
Left Hand Coffee by null
Left Hand Coffee by null

Highlights

Rustic-chic coffee shop with chill vibe, great coffee, donuts  

Placeholder
Placeholder
Placeholder

83 S Elmwood Ave, Montauk, NY 11954 Get directions

lefthandcoffee.com
@lefthandcoffee

$1–10 · Menu

Information

Static Map

83 S Elmwood Ave, Montauk, NY 11954 Get directions

+1 631 238 5434
lefthandcoffee.com
@lefthandcoffee

$1–10 · Menu

Features

payment credit card
Tap to pay
reservations

Last updated

Oct 10, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.

carlos borges

Google
This spot serves great coffee with a super chill vibe. The couches are a fantastic touch, making it a cozy place to relax. Their Vietnamese coffee? Absolutely top-notch. That said, the setup for milk and sugar could use a little tweaking. When the shop gets busy, the corner station creates a bit of a bottleneck. It’s a little awkward standing around with a hot, open coffee while waiting for others to finish prepping their drinks. Still, the quality of the coffee and the overall atmosphere more than make up for it. Highly recommend stopping by!

A Miniwheats

Google
Around a corner- hard to find but soooo worth it! Great coffee and the donuts best I have ever had! Jelly and black and white! Texture and flavor was original! I live in Chicago and have had my tries of donuts! My new fav for when I come out next time!

Andrew Schneider

Google
Pretty decent coffee, probably the best in the area. Hip vibe.

Alicelyfee

Google
Cute shop and long line but move quickly. I tried the nutella latte and it was very watery, i didn’t taste any coffee at all. I wish it was more strong in coffee but i guess they put too much ice and milk. Very limited seating as well.

Jack J

Google
Stopped in Saturday for a quick cup of coffee- holiday weekend so it was nuts but the service was great! I was greeted with a big smile by the beautiful girl with the long dark hair, she was so patient and positive despite the large crowd. the gentleman who made my drink was awesome- so upbeat, made it feel like a true old-school coffee shop. Excellent service and excellent staff!

Charlotte Arsenault

Google
Really good matcha!!!! Also their coffee was good but way too hot!

Chrysalis Steele

Google
I ordered two shots of espresso and politely asked for a cup of ice. The woman behind the counter responded with unnecessary attitude, saying she should charge me for the ice and that I “might as well have ordered an ice latte.” Her tone was rude and unprofessional. I’ve never been spoken to like that as a paying customer. This was my first visit, and unfortunately, it will be my last. I spend time in Montauk every week during the summer with friends and family, and it’s disappointing to be treated this way in a place we were looking forward to trying. A little kindness and professionalism go a long way—especially when dealing with first-time customers. I also sent an email to the company and never received a response, which only adds to the frustration. I hope the staff receives some guidance on customer service going forward.

BERTRAND Thomas

Google
Wonderful coffee shop! A very welcoming place with a cozy atmosphere and excellent products. The coffee is top quality, and the pastries are delicious. The staff are friendly and make you feel right at home. Definitely a great spot to relax and enjoy a break!