Abad M.
Yelp
I haven't left a review in years, but this place was so bad food-wise. 100% absolutely using thawed, leftover bagels that are soggy/wet on the outside, zero crispiness, and no fluffiness on the inside. Service was great, but not enough to make up for the food quality.
Food: Went on a Tuesday morning and ordered an everything bagel with lox spread, scallion cream cheese, and onions. The sandwich comes out and is toasted, despite not asking for it toasted. No respectable bagel place is going to toast your bagel unless you ask for it, and nearly all of them ask if you want it toasted or not these days.
I ask for a not-toasted bagel and they are kind enough to replace it, and the bagel is among the worst I've had in NY, comparable to the bagels a food cart serves in the morning. Soggy, wet on the outside (you can feel the dampness) and no crispiness or fluffiness. If you've ever left bagels in your fridge for a few days and taken them out, it was exactly that.
Northern Williamsburg close to the park is lacking in a great quality bagel spot, but there are much, much better options nearby. They are toasting their bagels by default because they are using leftover and/or thawed bagels, and charging $15 for it anyway. Not worth it.
Service: The lady taking orders was very kind, didn't hesitate to replace my bagel, and my replaced order came out lightning quick. Great service.