Robert B.
Yelp
I have stayed here a couple of times, and even in my recent stay, which was miserable, the staff is friendly and efficient, and the hotel itself is beautiful. BUT...
While the person at the front desk was cordial, as she handed me a key to my room she pointed to the room number...004. She said "you take the elevator right behind me down one floor."
I thought she was joking. I said, "You're not seriously giving me a room in the basement?!" She responded, "it's our lower level." Well, the elevator as a big "B" in it which I suspect stands for "basement", because that's exactly what it is....a low-ceilinged, bare linoleum (?) floor that you wind your way around until you find your cell. Mine was a small underground room (I don't mind the small rooms at this hotel, incidentally) with a window that looked out onto a concrete wall. It reminded me of what I might expect from a Motel 6 that was underground.
I live in Manhattan. I KNOW what to expect from hotel rooms. But after enduring the room for about 6 hours, I was just too depressed. I walked out of the Lex Hotel, and hope to never see it, or its dungeon rooms, again.
Let me say again that the staff was entirely courteous, it has a great atmosphere in the lobby, offers continental breakfast, etc. I loved it when I was there several months ago. But if your room is underground with a view of a concrete wall, nothing that happens in the rest of the hotel really matters.
Oh, I guess there is one good thing. There was an ice machine just outside my door....none of the real "guest" floors have an ice machine, you have to call the front desk and they bring it. But apparently, the basement is quite suitable for one.
I expressed my unhappiness with Hotel Tonight, through which I had booked the reservation. They contacted the hotel, which refused to make any adjustment, and claimed that the room is like all the other rooms in the hotel. That, technically, is true. But to be underground, in a room with a window that looks out at a concrete wall, 2 feet away, is NOT the same as being in a small nice room, even two stories up! And for this I paid $200. To Hotel Tonight's credit (and I think they are AWESOME), they refunded me $75 of the cost as a goodwill gesture. Clearly they know something about customer relations. Imagine how many people I will tell about my awful experience at this hotel; surely it will cost them more than they received for the one night stay.
You can tell I am really really disappointed with this entire experience. No hotel should carve out underground recreation-room type rooms, call them bedrooms, and charge $200 for them. The "lower level" is an unfinished basement. Don't let them persuade you otherwise.