Clark E.
Yelp
I am sad to say that we returned the next night and found the experience disturbing.
First, the water had a foul, sewerish smell. When we mentioned this to our waitress, she mentioned that the management was aware of the issue and they were working to correct it. I don't understand why bottled water wasn't brought in when management first noticed the problem and used until the problem was corrected..
Second, we found the entrée's very inconsistent. I was very satisfied with my New York strip steak, but unfortunately, my brother found the ravioli rather dry and worse yet, my sister-in-law found her dinner, although seemingly fine while she was consuming it, very disagreeable in the long run.
Third, there is no dessert menu in this restaurant, at least not a decent one! This beautiful and historic lodge screams out for a homemade dessert such as strawberry shortcake, but the best we could do was a crème brûlée for the three of us to share, but when it arrived, we found it surprisingly small, not only in stature, but taste.
Fourth , a very good restaurant will honor the principle of consistency. That principle was violated over the two nights that we ate there. The first night I found the restaurant deserving of a five star review, but the second night I found it deserving of only a one star review, although I will admit that if we had only gone the second night I might have given it a two or even possibly a three star review; however, the violation of the principle of consistency guaranteed a one star review.