Little Italy

This quaint authentic Italian restraint nestled in a hometown setting was so amazing. Our server was on point. We had a very large group there for my cousin's birthday. The staff was friendly, inviting and just so warm hearted. The food was fresh and delicious. This place is a must go to when visiting. Two thumbs up!!

My kids enjoyed their pasta with meatballs and cheese pizza. My sandwich was yummy. The fruit looked like canned ones, but my daughters finished them happily. The waitress was very nice and professional. The restaurant is clean and bright. They have restrooms but they are small. Fries were excellent because there was very little to no salt on them!!!

This is a GLUTEN FREE review: Amazing gluten free pizza! Dough was not crumby like most gluten free pizzas are, but was fluffy and rich. Great GF experience!

Our first time in Deposit, NY, we weren't sure where to eat dinner. We came across Little Italy during a Google search and saw it had a good rating. So glad we decided to stop because the food was delicious! I came here with my husband and we both ordered chicken parm dinners with ziti. It came with a salad and bread with butter. This was honestly one of the best chicken parm dinners I have ever had. They give great portions and are reasonably priced. We also ordered the fried pickles...yum! The place was smaller than we thought. Definitely looked like more of a takeout place, but there was seating inside and it was clean. We will definitely come back to this place if we are ever in the area again.

Loved the Egg Plant Parmigiana. Friendly staff was very helpful. Looked like they sell a lot of pizza.

The best food and the nicest people. My kids love the chicken tenders. The fries are always so fresh and the pizza sauce is perfect! Not acidic or spicy!

Amazing Food!! The staff was extremely friendly! 100% recommended

Great little place on the main road, quick service and great food, definitely coming back

Ok for starters the service is excellent. Our waitress Sidney was great. She didn't stop the entire time checking on us, asking if things were ok, offering new plates. And cleaning up everywhere else constanly The lasagna was good. A little sweet and maybe missing something minor it good The pizza was good too. Ask for it wee I'm giving 4 starts because of exceptional service and great food.

The one in Hancock is great. The one in deposit wouldn't take my debit card. That's bad.

The food was very tasty. The service was very friendly. We did takeout so we didn't eat in the restaurant, but we truly enjoyed our meal.

Little Italy is a hidden gem in the Catskills. The food is delicious, the service is great, and the overall experience is excellent. I highly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for a great Italian meal. The pizza is the star of the show at Little Italy. The crust is light and perfectly crispy, and the sauce and cheese are authentic and delicious. We shared a slice of margherita pizza and a tomato/arugula pizza. Delicioso The service at Little Italy is top-notch. The staff is friendly and attentive, and they always go above and beyond to make sure you have a great dining experience. The atmosphere at Little Italy is warm and inviting. The restaurant is clean and roomy. Overall, Little Italy is a great restaurant that I highly recommend. The food is delicious, the service is great, and the overall experience is excellent. If you're ever in the town of Deposit, this is an amazing place to eat!

Wonderful people, food and atmosphere. Family friendly, and we absolutely love the food and tremendous service.

Little Italy Pizzeria has delicious American-Italian food. Every time I come to this area I must make a stop here for pizza or eggplant parma! Never disappointed with anything I've ordered. The restaurant has been newly renovated and looks bright and welcoming. Outdoor picnic tables with umbrellas make for a outdoor seating area during this time for physical distancing. However you may sit indoors as well. Mask requires. Service is always friendly. Family owned business. Always Support local!

Very good, little pricey, but worth it very good flavoring to the garlic knots and pizza.

I've always enjoyed little Italy, I can only speak for their pizza as that's all I've ordered but it's good, they've had consistent quality from when I was a child. Their crust is crispy, the sizes are good, service is fast and their takeout has always been efficient.

Authentic Italian Food served by first generation Italians! Amazing food, great staff! Servers on point! Great location and prices. Nothing more to say!

The food was incredibly delicious, and the portions were LARGE. The service was fast and the ambience was laid back. I have no complaints. We were nearby Deposit and were looking for a place to eat and I'm glad we found this place.

Okay so my family and I order weekly. No competition when it comes to there pizza. WOW! Your pasta sauce... I wish I had the recipe. You should bottle it and sell it for real!!

By far the best pizza I've had in a long time. The staff were super friendly, the place was nice and clean. It felt homey. The menu- I wanted to order everything and try it all! I would definitely drive the 40 miles back to get more. Definitely coming back!!

Absolutely LOVE this place. Everything is always great no matter what I get. Everyone is always so friendly whether you're taking out or eating in.

This was a must stop for us on road trips from Maryland to Schenectady NY. Deposit is a quaint little town and since our dog was with us, we could get our food and weather permitting eat outside with our dog at the adjacent picnic tables. I highly recommend the food. One day, I hope to eat it inside the restaurant though. :-)

For a place in the middle of nowhere...AMAZING PIZZA!! Everytime I go to Deposit, NY, I think about the pizza here. It's cheap, delicious, and big. Thin crust, sweet savory tomato sauce, and the perfect amount of cheese. One big slice is just $1.75! Good pizza for that price is rare nowadays.

We drove down to Deposit to eat at another restaurant. It was closed, so we went to Little Italy to dine. the atmosphere was pure laid-back, & easy going. We had a meatball parmesian sandwich, fish sticks, & the cheese steak sandwich. All 3 of us enjoyed our choices, and had excellent meals. The staff was wonderful, and we were well cared for. I will recommend it to everyone.

Great family restaurant. Pizza is wonderful so were all the sides. They are very family oriented. The place to go for a good home cooked dinner.

We always enjoy the food we get from here, it is a good price for a small town and nice to be able to get some Italian food without having to drive too far. We are lucky to have a business that is family owned and gives back to the community!

Great (I mean surprising excellent) Italian food near the Delaware River. Have gone here a few times, once each season when I fish in the area. Friendly service and huge menu. The homemade eggplant Parmesan is my favorite. Thin slices covered with a wonderful red sauce and just the right amount of cheese. Side of pasta with red sauce comes with, along with crusty, hot bread and butter. The Italian salad dressing is home made too. My buddies ordered lasagna, ate every bit, and pasta with meatballs, too big a portion to finish. How perfect is it to find wonderful food in a tiny town (that has seen busier and better days), after a full day on the river? Absolutely a go to if you are any where near the area. Simple inside decor. Clean.

I basically agree with all the comments so far. I finally decided to stop in Deposit, and I was very impressed with this pizzeria, especially considering it's in a very rural area. Like everyone else is saying, for "the middle of nowhere", it's great!

The Wedges....oh my God, the wedges. I would drive an hour to get one of these bad boys. Decor is kinda tacky, lots of brass, but who cares when you're munching down on some pretty bad ass wedgie goodness.

The food here is excellent. My favorite thing to order is the eggplant hoagie and the garlic knots are really good, too. I've only ever had take out from here but it is always really good no matter what I've ordered.

Great italian food, reasonable prices. Menu has a good variety of choices. Relaxed and friendly environment. Best choice for dinner in Deposit.

This place is pretty darn good for being on the middle if nowhere. Reasonably priced and tasty "red-sauce" Italian. Didn't have the pizza but it looked very good in the case. If you are staying at one of the local lakes and have a hankering for Italian or pizza, this is a good choice!