Eric F.
Yelp
Wow! Absolutely loved this place and I still dream about it a month later.
A buddy and I were were traveling through the UK and were in Edinburgh for a couple days. Another review site that is not as detailed or as awesome as yelp! had this place listed as the best restaurant in town. Now, I do not know if that is true or not or just an anomoly of their weird rating system, but what I do know is that this was BY FAR the best restaurant we went to on our 3 dinner, 4 lunch stay in town. Also ate at Kyloe and Witchery...in hindsight, we should have just ate at Locanda de Gusti all 3 nights...only slightly kidding.
So we walk in...it was like being transported to another place. It was cold and kind of dreary outside and we walked into a warm coastal restaurant in Italy. It was amazing. The place was on the small, intimate side. The woman server/owner? instantly gave us a little Italian sass and it brought a smile to our faces as thats how friends and family I know treat each other. Our waiter/owner? (a little older guy, not that old, but a little older than a normal 20 yr old server) was very warm and friendly. So the crowd make-up was awesome. A couple tables of people on dates and several tables of girls on what appeared to be girls night out. I wish we had been closer to one of the several tables with groups of girls. Anyway...
We skipped the normal app and opted for a pizza (Margherita) as an appetizer, I mean, the pizza is from the Naples area afterall, so when in Rome, err, Naples....So my buddy is from an intalian family near Chicago. As we were eating the piza he said it was probably the best pizza hes had since being at his grandmas house, which is, drumroll please, near Naples. And this dude really isnt a food person and he loved the pizza. So did I, just backing up my opinion. Oh, and the bread was wonderful...a little chew, yumm....
Many italian restaurants Ive been to will have you get a pasta as a second course with yet a main course later. I asked the beautiful woman server (part owner?) and she didnt recommend it, but said order one and if your still hungry to order the other. Glad she was honest and didnt upsell as I got the fresh made pasta with rabbit ragu (forget the actual name). Not only was it plenty, it was absolutely delicious! I asked them to pair a wine for me as I dont know my Italian wines very well (what can I say, Im from California). They brought me a medium bodied, slightly dry red wine that paired wonderfully and wasnt too expensive. My buddy had a lobster with pasta that was on special I believe. He rather enjoyed it.
Finished off with a panna cotta. It was ok. It was nothing special, but it wasnt bad.
Oh, and how could I forget...at the end of the meal, they brought us a nice shot of limoncello! Wasnt the best Ive ever had, but the gesture was awesome and it was a perfect finish to a great meal.
We made or Thursday night reservation just a few days in advance, but the restaurant was full the entire time, so I would definitely suggest making a reservation.