Louie Angelo’s Pizza & Italian

Excellent thin crust pizza and yummy breadsticks as well. The crust was perfectly cooked and crispy. The toppings were fresh and plentiful. The sauce was tasty and was just right. Order was for take out and was 20 minutes from phone to pickup. Would highly recommend this place and it will be our go to going forward.

This was our first time at a Louie Angelo's. The staff were friendly and helpful. It was our first fast casual Italian experience. I think the food was a little on the pricey side for fast casual, but it was rather good; I've been to full service Italian restaurants that weren't as good. Of course, I've been to full service restaurants that were better, too, but those usually cost even more. I'd say the portions and food quality were commensurate for what you'd pay at an equivalent full service place, but more than you might expect, on all counts, for fast casual. We'll quite liekly be back, but not too frequently.

Wasn't a fan of the old pizza place that was here but I noticed they had changed owners and decided to give them a try. Grabbed a couple slices at lunch and everyone agreed they were better than any other "by the slice" places. Crust was nice a crisp. A week later I ordered a proper thin crust pizza and have to say that it's definitely my new favorite in the area.

Glad we gave it another try. Had some problems the first time we ordered. The owner was super friendly and reached out to fix all that went wrong. You can tell he is a great owner. The food was sooooo good. Pizza is probably the best we have had here in Batavia since we moved here 5 years ago.

Terrific pizza. Sausage is my favorite! Check out the daily specials. Kind, attentive service.

Doordasher here. Walked in at 5:25 and was told 10 mins for the customer order. While waiting the front desk associate tells the back end employee he will be back and leaves with a bag of food. Fast forward 20 min the employee comes back and only 1 pizza was given out. That was given to the person to show up after me. There was already one person waiting before me. Then after the third customer left, there was another 4 customers to show up. The 2nd of the 4 got his pizza and no one else had even been talked to yet. Person to show up before me, ended up canceling because the employee said his food was now in the oven when he was also told 10 min. I get being short staffed but they shouldn’t leave one employee left alone to fend for themselves. Hire more employees or at least train staff to acknowledge the people walking in, oh wait the employee left the building 🤦🏽‍♀️🤦🏽‍♀️ if it wasn’t someone else’s order I would’ve canceled it. Also, the customer ONLY ordered ravioli and breadsticks….. hopefully they’re not cold when they come out..

Solid pizza and food. Slices ready go. The vodka chicken pasta is 👌

First time ordering from here since new ownership took over of Chicago Pizza. They were very kind and polite and gave me $4 off my pizza which was cool of them. I figured I had to try since I’ve had most in our area. I got the pizza and at first glimpse looked not so amazing…looked like a lot of cheese for me. But trying it I was happily surprised how tasty and good it was! It really has a nice balance of flavor and just a tasty pizza….was much better than I was expecting! So possibly I would try next with a little less cheese maybe, but honestly it was super good so why bother. Better than most in Batavia taste wise. Better to me than Charlie Fox’s, Pal Joey’s, Acquaviva and for sure Riverside too. Happy I tried very professional and polite service which was refreshing too. Definitely worth checking them out.

Absolutely delicious pizza! hands-down one of the best pizza places I've had in a while. I love how creative and tasty their sandwiches are. The Alfredo was to die, for it reminded my family of our mother's homemade pasta. The kids loved their Mickey Mouse pizza, It was such a cute idea and a blast for them. The service was excellent! selection of drinks were great. Me and my wife will definitely be dining in soon for a date night vibe with some pizza and wine!

Louie Angelos is a fairly new pizza place on the east side of Geneva/Batavia that's carry out only. I've eaten almost everything on the menu and the food is really good. My personal favorites include (of coarse) the pizza. Delicious sauce, big pieces of sausage, and last week I had my first taste of artichoke pizza...outstanding! Other favorites include fettuccine in Alfredo sauce, rigatoni in vodka sauce, cheese ravioli also gets high marks. And really good lasagna. Not so good was the fried mushrooms. I think the problem with the shrooms is they don't travel well and were kind of soggy by the time I got them home. But they still tasted good. The meatball panini was good but one think I've never had in my 50 plus years of pizza eating was the giardiniera topping on the pizza. I've had it on beefs many times but never on pizza. A sweet taste with a nice little kick adds something nice to the pizza. There's still a hand full of other items I haven't tried yet but intend in the near future. I recommend this place because it's very clean, the people that work there are very nice, and the food is good with reasonable prices. See what you think...

Louie is the New Kid in Town... 'Thin, Crispy and Tasteless'...The epitome of generic pizza. Don't worry about taking flavorless pics of your pizza! 'I've done it for you'...

Just tried for the first time. Had the prosciutto salad with grilled chicken and Caesar dressing. Great fresh salad and definitely coming back to try the sandwiches Good and friendly service as well. Recommend to anyone in the area looking for a good lunch spot.

Stopped in a couple of times for the pizza by the slice, it was delicious. Took a to go menu, and decided today to order out. I ordered lasagna, $15 (NO layer of italian sausage, and not worth the money for the size), mozzarella sticks $9, garlic bread sticks $8, cheese ravioli (more dough than cheese in the ravioli,, smoothed in sauce, $14, small side salad $8 (worth $4) I get a huge salad at McCalister's for less than $10! I am not cheap, I will pay for good food, but I expect to get what I order and pay for... spent over $60 for take out, and was disappointed.

Good pizza and great spot for wings as well! I'm a big fan of the mac and cheese as well, and this is coming from someone who is typically very picky of their cheeses. Seems like they put a few different cheeses in them, I approve of this. Quality cheese, the best cheeses even. I would suggest ordering later in the week, maybe weekends. For some reason when I've picked up from them earlier or mid-week it just didn't hit. Can't put my finger on it, maybe those are slower days so the quality tends to dip it seems like...

I am the least pickiest person ever. I usually dont care either if one or two things in a whole meal are bad. But today, it was every single thing. The bread sticks went from moist(?) to stale somehow. My ravioli was AWFUL. oh my god, so awful. The cheese on the inside was like curdly but in like tiny bits. And when they put the ravioli bowl in the bag they put it on its side? So the sauce was spilled everywhere. The chicken in the salad was okay, but for some reason they decided to put a lot of pepper on the entire salad, which was the only flavor. We waited an extra like 12-15 minutes too, apparently cause the terrible ravioli took forever:( The pizza was mediocre too as told by everyone in my family who tried it, by the end of this experience i was too afraid to. I never do these, this is like my first yelp review, but i feel the need to warn the people. At least get bigger bags so the pasta sauce doesnt spill pls

The food is mediocre at best and really overpriced compared to other pizza places around.

Pickup counter very clean & nice. Good service on phone. The "buttery deep dish" crust was not great, but thin was SO good. Salad was ok.

The pizza is ridiculously expensive. Thought we would try this place for something different. Got 2 personal size pizzas and it was almost 40 bucks. Pizzas were only 8 inch and that is being generous. Will not be going back.

Excellent pizza good pasta and friendly staff. Ordered 6 pizzas for a party all arrived piping hot

We order this food frequently for work events. We are in nearby business and we are happy with their product.

We ordered the family size chicken parmesan. It was delicious and we got many servings from it.

We are tired of all the local pizza options and tried Louie Angelo's last night. We were pleasantly surprised. Our pizza was excellent! It was also a great value for the price. Will definitely order again soon.

$27 plus $5 tip for salad greens with a tiny bit of toppings and watery soup with maybe 4 noodles. Awkward ordering. This place looked so good, been wanting to try it for months. What a massive buzz kill. Wish I got an amazing prime rib dinner somewhere else instead for what I spent. Bummer.

All the food we ordered was delicious! But let me just say, the pizza had wonderful thin and crispy crust! So good!

So good! Awesome pizza! Super fast delivery! Our two go to pizzas are --Pineapple, pepperoni, jalapeño and --black olive, mushroom. Both are delicious!

The pizza is fantastic! Been looking in the area for a really good pie for a while, and when I tried this place that was it. My search is over!