Corinne G.
Yelp
I heard a lot about this place, so when my husband made reservations for a "make up" birthday dinner I was excited. First glance...ok, it's small, but I expected that.
We were seated promptly but noticed that there was a two-top available in a more private alcove by the window. We asked if we could be moved there once the table was cleaned, and the hostess "went to check." She indicated there was a party of four coming soon, so no, we couldn't have it. As it turned out, the party of four never materialized, nor did they ever SET the two tables there for a four-top, so that was disappointing.
Next, the prices...yes, I read they were expensive, but really -- $60 for Paella? What??
We started out with the mushrooms al ajillo for an app. THEY were phenomenal, I will admit. And, reasonably priced. Then, we shared a Caesar salad. It was no better or no worse than your run-of-the-mill Caesar. Then, we had decided to share the Ludvig's Linguini. We were charged $3 to share the plate (although we had asked no to have it split), the portions were huge, but...the pasta was dreadful. It sounded so good -- proscuitto, chorizo, harissa...-- but it turned out to be a brown, flavorless glop. And, for the price, it was a waste of money and calories.
We weren't aware that there was the wine/tapas bar upstairs, but we could tell from all the action of chefs/sous chef/waiters heading out the main restaurant that there was SOMETHING going on somewhere else. I guess if I'd read enough reviews, I would have been clued in to the upstairs scene. IF I ever go back, I'll try that because I was quite disappointed overall with what we got here in the main restaurant.
Ok, it may be the "best" fine dining in Sitka, but really, it's the ONLY "fine dining" in Sitka and it was NOT that fine. Especially not for the price.