Mariano
Google
We went in with high expectations after watching a couple of interviews with the owner of Lulla’s Brooklyn (@ivodiaznyc). It seemed like a great bakery with an interesting concept. I’m not Venezuelan, but my Venezuelan friends brought me to try some of their traditional food. There were six of us.
The space itself is nice, but unfortunately, our experience didn’t quite live up to what we expected. Service was a bit off, and the food had its highs and lows.
What we ordered:
We got two matchas, three coffees (Americano, one with milk, and a drip), and a toddy (which was very sweet but fine). For food, we had two fried arepas (beef and chicken), two grilled arepas, a cachapa, four ham and cheese cachitos, a canilla sandwich, a campesino sandwich, the Lulla’s Club, and French toast.
Service:
The ordering process could have been smoother. The staff seemed a bit disengaged, and at times, it felt like they weren’t really paying attention. It made things a little uncomfortable, but we still left 20% tip on a $187 bill, hoping the food would make up for it.
Food:
• The fried arepas arrived cold, which was disappointing. The grilled ones were much better, so I’d recommend those instead.
• The cachapa was way too salty, which overpowered everything else.
• The canilla sandwich lacked flavor, and the cheese inside was unevenly cut, which made it feel a bit carelessly prepared.
• The campesino sandwich had too much mustard, very little chicharrón, and barely any pineapple—so the mustard ended up being the dominant flavor.
• The cachitos were decent, nothing particularly special.
At this point, nothing really stood out, but then we had to wait 45 minutes for the French toast and the Lulla’s Club.
• The French toast was good, but honestly, waiting 45 minutes for it just didn’t make sense.
• The Lulla’s Club sandwich came with cold fries and was already dry when it got to the table. When we asked for it to be reheated, it was warmed up in a microwave, which unfortunately made the bread rubbery, the lettuce wilted, and the egg overcooked.
Final Thoughts:
We were really looking forward to trying this place, but the experience didn’t match the expectations. The flavors weren’t quite there, the timing of the dishes was off, and for the price, we expected a bit more. That being said, it’s a nice spot with potential, so hopefully, with some improvements in service and consistency, it can live up to its reputation.