Mary's Mountain Cookies

This place is a staple in Cheyenne if you want cookies. I know about them from 4 states away. Service is pleasant and engaging. Down home down to earth vibe. Lots to choose from..made daily. Ice cream cookie sandwiches and of course their large cookies are great.

Special ordered some sugar cookies. I was assured that they would have colored frosting as requested. When I arrived to pick them up, they decided to put sprinkles on them instead and then informed me that they can no longer color the frosting. Lady that fulfilled my order was dishonest, rude and unprofessional.

We drove by a couple of days ago and seen the cookies in the display cases from the road. They looked so inviting. So we stopped in today. Boy, are they Big. They had a couple of samples also, which was a nice touch. We got the Oreo cookie to split. It was delicious. Definitely recommend stopping in and supporting local businesses and enjoying their delicious cookies.

I was gratefully able to experience Mary's Mountain cookies this evening!! Oh my goodness, literally the best cookies I've had in Cheyenne Crumbl cookie does not have anything on Mary's Mountain cookies! Customer service was amazing and the cookies are just phenomenal. Thank you Mary's Mountain cookies.!!!

So many selection and choices!! You will find something for everyone. They look great and they taste great!! 😃 I also love their buy 6 get 2 free deal for a big family like ours!! I especially loved their brownie - highly recommend. Will try their ice cream next time!

Have gotten their cookies for years now and a serious decline in quality the almond cookies are like a piece of cake not a cookie very little almond flavor spent 70 dollars for Valentine’s Day for a school function today and just poor quality. Never the same recipe won’t ever go back after all these years Christmas cookies the trees were awful this year as well. Total fail.

I've been here twice with my grandkids. They have the best Huckleberry ice cream I've ever had. My grandkids love it and we will definitely be back. I might eventually have to try something other than Huckleberry

They always have a great selection of cookies and treats. Everything we bought was tasty.

Located in the heart of downtown Cheyenne, this is a great place to stop for something sweet after dinner. Tons of cookie choices, ice cream, and cookie variations. They even have a cookie dough cookie sandwich. I'm a big fan of marshmallow and the S'mores cookie is a must try. Friendly quick service and everything you would expect from a cookie shop. 5 stars for filling the city's cookie needs.

Unfortunately cannot give a great review. The cookies were fairly good, but we could not enjoy them because of the packaging method. Rather than use a box like other cookie establishments, they stack your cookies four to a thin plastic bag. Even iced cookies are just stacked inside these flimsy plastic bags. Everything dried out and smashed into one another. Will not go back if getting more than one.

The last few times I've purchased these cookies they are not fresh. Spent 30 yesterday for NOT day old cookies. The peanut butter cookies tasted like they were a cinnamon cookie. The coffee cake cookies were hard and the frosted sugar cookie even worse. Crumble in town step it up. Your cookies have gone downhill fast.

Oh my goodness most delicious cookies!! We just wish we could have have taken some home with us but they wouldn't have made the week! We tried i believe the Smores & triple chocolate kind and so yummy!

Get a cookie ice cream sandwich, you won't be disappointed. Go nuts and get sugar cookies and strawberry ice cream. Live life like a kid.

Yum! Mary's is a wonderful little shop in Cheyenne's downtown, we were so pleased to find it open so late in the evening. The oversize cookies and wonderful display make it hard to choose. The cookies are moist, flavorful, and remind you a little bit of what you would get from your grandmother, a little bit of love and comfort rolled into one! Highly recommend that you save room for a delight from this wonderful shop.

We were in Cheyenne three days & we went here TWICE. I am so jealous of the citizens of Cheyenne because they get to enjoy these cookies whenever they want! We tried: Oreo avalanche Choc chip avalanche Frosted Oreo Twix Iced sugar Lemon blueberry (forgot the actual name) The lemon blueberry is not to be passed over. One of the BEST cookies I've ever eaten in my 34 years. DON'T SLEEP ON MARY'S!!

Every cookie I have ever had here, has been absolutely amazing! I didn't kn they had ice cream! Do they at the Loveland, CO store?

Great cookies! Loved my peanut butter cookie. The smell in the place was mouthwatering. Want to go back to try more flavors.

Cute little homemade cookie shop. I stopped in with my parents while strolling through Cheyenne. I had the chocolate chip cookie which was fresh and yummy! There were several other flavors that I wanted to try but I wasn't going to over do it =) The employees were super friendly and welcoming.

They had NO KETO cookies, and the cookies we did buy were not worth the price tag. No one really like them. Would not recommend

Service was awesome! Super friendly. Reasonably priced, but 6 get 2 free. The overall quality of the cookies was just average thought

I asked to get my cookies warmed up and was told that I couldn't. Within the next 5 to 6 mins the same lady who told me I couldn't get mines warmed up asked my teammate if she wanted hers warmed up. I feel as though it was personal and racial. I won't be back.

I dropped into Mary's Mountain Cookies because I love a good cookie to satisfy my sweet tooth. I must say that I was very impressed with the selection of cookies they had. They also sell ice cream and you can purchase edible cookie dough to enjoy at your leisure. The young lady at the register was very friendly. When I walked into the establishment she greeted instantly. That's a good quality for any owner who owns a business. As I took the pics of all the cookies it was difficult for me to decide which cookie to purchase. After my eni meni mine' no. I chose the snickerdoodle with an orange glaze, that cookie cost me $3.25, that's a bit expensive. But they aren't all that price. I just had a taste of my cookie. Omg!! As I broke off a piece of my cookie it was so soft and you could taste the snickerdoodle and the orange glaze it's a great combo. When your in the great state of Cheyenne, Wyoming drop into there downtown to enjoy dinner at the great restaurants and don't forget to step into Mary's Mountain for a delicious selection of cookies. Until my next foodie adventure. Let's continue to eat our way through the country. # FOODIE4LIFE!!

Great customer service. They even gave me some great suggestions of thing to check out while visiting. Cookies were good. I appreciate that they are overly sweet and undercooked like you find at many other cookie shops

I just want to start out by saying that the aroma that hits you when you walk through these doors are enough to tell you whatever inside is good. Took a breather to take in all the goodies before deciding. Nice gal stopped her cookie forming to help us. Grabbed some lemon poppyseed & sugar cookies with Oreo frosting. They do not have coffee or espresso drinks, but was recommended the Crooked Cup right across the street. I thought this was a family store but learned they are a chain & are in different states. I've had Crumbl cookies before & I will say I WAY prefer this place!

Cookies are great, would love to give this place 5 stars. Last time, the service was also great. However, we walked in tonight and the two girls working didn't acknowledge us whatsoever. One girl came out to the front and walked past us without saying a word. I was honestly just stunned by the lack of acknowledgement that we ended up leaving without buying anything.

These are hands and cookies down the best in Cheyenne! If you are looking for something awesome and you are using an app out there on one of the interstates you will miss out on a road trip life experience if you don't exit and come in for a cookie.

I enjoyed the huge keto cookies. I got the peanut butter and chocolate chip. The chocolate chip was my favorite. I wish the peanut butter had more peanut butter in it. Very good though.

My family has had the best service and dessert from Mary's Mountain Cookies! The cookies have absolutely perfect texture, chew, and flavor. The ice cream is surprisingly the best we've had in town. Also, I have to eat gluten free, and I'm always prepared to be disappointed by gluten free treats when I go out. Their gluten free cookies are just as good as the regular, and the best gluten free cookies I've ever had! The orange doodle is to die for!

I would say average. I bake and cook myself, but when we go on vacations, I like to stop at local bakeries and try someone else's. We pretty much bought 1 of everything and somethings 2, because the rest of my family wanted to try some. Nothing was really special or stand out. I felt most of what we bought I could make better at home. I'd say their cookies are just ok

Excellent cookies and customer service! Love the pay it forward board, what a great idea!

So I've been on a bit of a quest to find the best edible cookie dough and can I just say that I am SO grateful Mountain Mary's is not in my state because I would die of cookie dough overdose. Perfect texture, extra chocolate chips, staff was amazing in helping me choose something without nuts, honestly 10/10. I'll be back for one of the actual cookies, but you bet I stood in the TSA line and finished all of my cookie dough because they wouldn't let me take it past security

Embarrassing confession: I literally jumped up and down, and then sent a friend a video of these cookies. Literally the BEST COOKIES on Earth!! I've got celiac so I'm used to being underwhelmed by gluten free desserts. And even when the box of cookies (tied up with beautiful pink and white ribbons!) arrived... I wasn't expecting much. But oh.my.goodness. They're like heaven.

Yes. Just so much yes. From the moment you get close to the door you can smell baking cookies. Behind the glass they have a selection of cookies that seem change often. I've been twice and had very different cookies and I didn't know cookies could have such crazy flavors. They even let you build your own cookie ice cream sandwich. AND. AND. They sell cookie dough to go with a spoon!!!! Heaven.

I drive past this cute little shop everytime I'm in Cheyenne for work! I stopped in for the first time and bought a few different things to try. They are all so good!!! The ice cream is delicious, the cookies are yummy, and the brownies are sooo gooey and sweet! It all tastes home made! The Smore's cookie was my favorite. If you're in Cheyenne, stop and give this cute little cookie shop a try!! You won't be disappointed!

Very good cookies, so glad they come to Johnstown. Wish they opened earlier to grab a cinnamon roll. My opinion they are better than crumbl.

Wow, these were some delicious cookies-big, soft, quality ingredients. Just everything you want in a cookie. We tried quite a few since we were traveling. My favorite was the orange frosted cookie-buttery with a perfect amount of orange flavor and lightly glazed. So good! The chocolate chip was soft without being cakey and lots of semisweet chips-yum! The M n M cookie was great-lots of M n M's and chocolate chips! Also tried the oatmeal raisin, Oreo, almond, and frosted sugar cookies-all winners. Mary's is a cookie rockstar!

Delicious cookies! Definitely try them on your next visit to Cheyenne! I believe it is a locally owned shop and they definitely contribute to the community. They serve a variety of cookies - hard to choose which one I enjoyed more.

Just had our first experience at Mary's here in Cheyenne and let me tell you what...SOOOO AWESOME! The cookies were phenomenal and the service was outstanding, the lady there struck up a pleasant conversation while we picked out our cookies and treated my family so nice. We'll be going back again very soon! she let us in on a little secret...they're gonna make a mint cookie featuring Andes mints I can't wait! Thanks again ladies

Super yummy !!!!!!!!!! Got some cookies and a Oreo shake they have cookie trays to go, gluten free cookies, cookie ice cream sandwiches, some beverages (milk)

We have eaten these scrumptious cookies a couple of times on visits to Cheyenne to see family. So good. This time we had them delivered to our home in Las Vegas. Amazing. Fast shipping and the product was just as fresh and good as if I walked into their little store. Great work. Each cookie was wrapped and sealed in a bag. I'm impressed and will order again. Thanks MMC Cheyenne!

Forget calories... way too delicious to pass up! The staff is beyond friendly and helpful. The smells just walking past are enough to keep you from walking past.. just go in already! So much to choose from! Everything is delicious

I love this place!! My family is visiting from out of state, and we automatically fell in love with this shop! The service is amazing and there's a ton of option. Their pay it forward board is amazing and i'm loving their initiative

Amazing- fresh and delicious cookies! I loved the Oreo cookie dipped in chocolate with the gummyworm as well as the "everything" cookie. The young girl working the counter was very kind.

most definitely my favorite cookie place in cheyenne! cookies are so soft and delicious. also, customer service is amazing each and every time. the staff is very friendly.

Tasty and delicious! Try the snickers or the s'mores cookies. You won't be disappointed.

Delicious cookies and amazing staff! They have all sorts of flavors, but the snickerdoodles are the best. You can purchase frozen dough or large cookies to feed a group too. There's a military discount and loyalty program you can join.

It has arrived!!! Cookies, ice cream, and more! This is just the place that our 'Magic City of the Plains' needed! The aroma of cookies and sweet ice-cream wafts down the historic strip of the Capital City and invites everyone into this little shop. The professional service was outstanding and the extensive cookie and ice cream options are tasty and delicious. Definitely a great experience and a perfect place for all. I 100% recommend Mary's Mountain Cookies in Downtown Cheyenne to all living here and anyone visiting town for Frontier Days!

If you would like a sweet dessert or treat this is the place to go! Mary's Mountain Cookies are all baked in the store, and they are soft in the center. My favorite cookie is the Salted Caramel, or if you really want a treat you can get the avalanche with frosting in the middle. The cookies are the perfect size to split or, if you want, to enjoy all for yourself!

First of all I'm not a big sweets guy but we had heard about the cookies and my kid really wanted to try them. We grabbed 8 kinds (hard to decide which ones). Not sure how you can go wrong because there wasn't a bad one. Can't go wrong with the root beer or smores but we all thought the best was the Avalanche. Try em, you'll never think of cookies the same

I was so excited to have a Mary Mountain cookie here. Especially downtown, But the first time I was in was not a friendly experience. I figured they are new, just busy trying to open up and operate. My second time I took my family there from out of town we spent quite a bit of money, it just seemed like we were an absolute nuisance to them... my family's very friendly,kind, extremely patient. Again I gave them a third chance. really want to support our downtown development.. Went into today, no hello, no welcome, no what can I get you?? Just made me feel again like I was bothering them. So I left. I will be going to the fort Collins store or crumble cookie from now on. Very friendly helpful staff there the kind of cookie shop you feel welcome/ at home at. Super bummed.

Awesome cookies and very friendly staff, oatmeal raisin and the monster cookies were excellent

I ordered a special treat for my parents for Christmas in Cheyenne, I live in Arizona. The owner arrived with cheer and Joy when delivering the packages to my parents. My mother was so excited that she raved about how wonderful and kind she was. Also, the boxes had beautiful Christmas Ribbons and were so festive.It felt very nice and extremely great to know Mary's mountain cookies could be there for me/us during these difficult times when we can't ourselves. Mary's Mountain cookies went above and beyond. This place is truly amazing!!! I definitely recommend, just wonderful all around. Thank so much again, Happy Holidays.

Got the monster cookie. Think it was undercooked. My boyfriend got sick and it was the last thing he ate. I thought the gooey ness was just butter. But it was undercooked.