Ted C.
Yelp
I don't regret spending the holidays at the Grand Canyon. HOWEVER, if I could go back and redo the trip I would DEFINITELY have paid more to stay at another lodging option, literally any other lodge would have been better for some many reasons.
1) Location: Maswik is the 'furthest' of the lodges from the South Rim, maybe this isn't an issue during the warmer months but when I went it meant a 15 minute trudge back to the room when it was cold, snowy, and the wind is blowing hard. 1A) also, when it's dark which is season immaterial, but that could be fixed with more lighting, it's not like I was too worried about getting mugged or anything but walking from the food court to the room was harrowing.
2) Facilities: It's old-that's the best way I can sum it up. The rooms definitely could use an upgrade/facelift/renovation. You name it, it needs it. The newest item besides the tv was the heating system which was probably redone 20 years ago at the latest. I wasn't expecting the Ritz, but I wasn't expecting to time travel every time I stepped in the door either.
3) Service: their 'front desk' is actually co-located in the food court. We arrived via the train and part of the package was that our bags would go directly to the room but we had carry-ons but we figured like any hotel they could hold our bags for us before our rooms were ready.
We went to the lodge desk and there was a woman there who saw us, retreated to the back room-made eye contact with me as she was about to come back out and retreated again. I finally called out and asked for a bag check. She said, bags go directly to your room, and rooms aren't ready until later. I asked about holding our bags and she repeated her statement like a mantra. Until she relented and took our bags-I had to ask for a claim ticket. I wish I knew her name but she conspicuously didn't wear a name tag unlike all the other staff members.
TLDR: pay the extra money to be closer, better housed and (hopefully) better served.