Damien S.
Yelp
A wee bit of overcompensation, as Menemsha is getting dinged for odd things in other reviews (it's too far from Edgartown? Really?) and it's quite a soft, communal and ultra scenic beach.
Amenities abound, with active police patrols in the smaller parking lot, lifeguards on duty, and loads of retail options for clothing, sundries and snacks.
I'm not going to say you can crack a Lawson's on the pillowy sand, but I'm also not going to say there weren't a ton of coolers, cans and non-glass containers getting raided as the sun fell.
And oh, the sunset! Completely unobstructed views of the daylight's journey into dusk that culminated in raucous applause from the beachgoers.
Young and old, shy and bold, Menemsha is a welcoming stretch for worshippers of the sun, and those who don't mind polished stones to climb on, or weigh down your blanket corners.
Seriously though, parking is crazy competitive. Daytrippers leave en masse between 6-7p, so if you're there for the sunset, you may bet lucky with a spot in that window.