Bill S.
Yelp
We returned to Merriman's in Waimea for the fifth time last night for a birthday dinner. This time, there wasn't a line at the door when we arrived, but when we left at 7:30PM, there were 5 people waiting to be seated. The wait staff seemed attentive and a little intense. They waited efficiently, but we flagged down our server a few times. They asked about food quality but didn't stay long enough for me to complete my answer.
The bread was amazing, but the butter was over-salted. I had the Caesar salad, which had an overwhelming cumin taste and didn't taste like a traditional Caesar salad. We both had Duo combinations. We both had the catch of the day, which included gnocchi, a jumbo shrimp, and ono. The shrimp was great. The ono was dried out and not even hot. I also had the macadamia-encrusted Kanpachi. It was great. The accompanying spinach was extremely over-salted. My wife had the Kahua Ranch Lamb (meat balls) and liked it. I thought the meat balls were good, but not great. She had a Lilikoi Martini with basil, It was good, but it had an overwhelming basil flavor with just a touch of lilikoi.
We were served a complimentary chocolate tarte, which had a great flavor served chilled, but the flavor increased as we let it warm to room temperature. We also shared a French Press decaf coffee, which was good, but lacked depth.
Overall, the restaurant had good food, although the chefs were too heavy with Cumen in several of the dishes. I felt like they had production down, but service lacked a personal, caring touch.