Millport Dairy

Love that they opened. Also, I hope they keep the laundromat sign, I love the confusion. So far, mostly everything I’ve bought has been winners. Eggs rule. Three different prices, tbh- they all taste the same to me. The yolks are almost orange and there’s only slight difference in size from the $4 - $9 version. The strawberries are the best I’ve ever had in life. Dramatic, but true. Insanely expensive for $9, but highly addicting. Their jam is almost too sweet, but still great. Ditto their pickled anything. Best of all, are their jars are good quality. Aka- reusable for all you malakas out there who are into that, including me. Their breakfast meats are good quality. The country sausages are ok, lil dry for my taste but good. The bacon and ham are the move, Gina. I don’t regret any of the vegetables I’ve bought. The best value in the store. I’m big on small businesses and this seems like a family run spot. The gent at the register is straight out of central casting for an Amish movie. They seem to be located in a few hours away in Pennsylvania. That said, I’m getting poorer every week from this spot. 1st world problems, Brad.

Heaven packed into a tiny storefront. Always loved their products at the farmers markets, and now you can get their great homemade items four days a week in this spot on Broadway and 97th. I love all their pickled vegetables (silly beans, cauliflower, okra, pickles, etc) and their homemade breads. They’ve also got a small selection of fresh veggies, meats, and cheeses. I try to stop by once a week to stock up on snacking pickled vegetables, which are super popular and go fast in our apartment! Absolutely worth supporting this wonderful shop

John has fed us the freshest food for years. I am so glad he is willing to bring all this natural food to Manhattan. I cannot imagine life withoutt it. My favorites are the eggs, butter, and above all the magnificent beef.

Finally found time to stop by and so glad I did. Their Gold Rush Apples are unbelievably good. Maybe the best apples I’ve ever had. Great sausages too.

I was beyond giddy when I learned that Millport Dairy was going to open a storefront in my neighborhood! I have been a longtime customer of theirs at NYC greenmarkets. They have now been open almost two months (opened May 1, 2024) and each visit there are more offerings. The cheese! The eggs! The produce! And so much more (Pickles, Meats, Jam, Maple Syrup, Bread, Milk, Butter (salted and sweet), Cream ... a new surprise every week!). The produce is fantastic (seasonal, so grab it while you can!). Run, don't walk, to visit John, the owner, at his new store! The prices are also the best in town for items of this quality. There are so many more offerings at this storefront than were ever offered at his booth at the greenmarket.

Millport Dairy was originally part of the Greenmarket vendors but have since opened their own brick and mortar location on the UWS, steps from the 96 St (1/2/3) station. The new space is small, but packs a ton of goodies like fresh eggs from both hens and ducks, loads of cheeses, butter, meats, pickled greens, baked goods, and soon produce (the shop currently has asparagus for $6/bunch but strawberries are coming next week)! You'll also find some of the best and freshest eggs in NYC here. For $6/dozen, you get eggs with an incredible deep orange color, which speaks to the quality and care of the hens that produce them. There are several egg options, from regular hens to pullet hens ($4/dz) to Ameraucana hens ($9/dz) to ducks ($12/dz) as well. The shop is run by Farmer John who is extremely knowledgable about all the products he sells. On my most recent visit, I also picked up a dozen pullet eggs, which he explained, are the first eggs laid by young hens so they are on the smaller side but contain more nutrients. He also recommended that I cook them lightly to retain said nutrients, preferably sunny side up. I'm very excited that there is now a brick and mortar location for Millport Dairy in the city, and highly encourage you to stop by during their opening hours (Wed-Sat, 7a-4p) for excellent quality goods from a family-run Amish farm.

Love this place at the farmers market so I’m glad they have this new home! Great eggs, butter (the butter…🤤), bread, pickles, and today I had some superlative asparagus. I will be back often!

Living near this little shop is such a luxury! Great prices on farm fresh produce and goods, and in the summer the fruits are to die for. Can’t recommend the cheeses enough. The fiber balls are also a lovely treat in the morning. Friendly staff a plus.

So worth making the trek to the UWS for Millport Dairy - I love their eggs and butter and the fresh produce. The whoopie pies are also worth a try!

It is a cute little storefront with a lot of good items. The cheese was delicious and so was the whoopie pie. I was a little disappointed with the pickles and picked cauliflower. The pickles were VERY soft and mushy I personally couldn't eat them. The cauliflower was alright but still a little on the softer side.

This is the best eggs in the city! Hands down. They use to be in the union square food market, but have since located to the upper west side. I now make the trek to come visit my favorite farmers (John) and purchase their eggs, cheese, rolls, bread, jams. The eggs are $6 a dozen. The Ameraucana eggs are $9 a dozen. I went down the research rabbit hole and concluded that this is how I should purchase my eggs from now on. I'm so confident in their eggs that I tell my friends if you don't like their eggs, I will buy it from them. The eggs/some items do run out so make sure to come early in the week.

If you want the best eggs ever had... you absolutely need to get them from here! I been going to them at the USQ farmers market forever and it's definitely worth schlep up to the UWS for their eggs. The cheese, pickled veggies, pies, jerkies, and meats are also amazing. All of it is farmer market quality but in a store front. The owner he is wonderful to chat with and so happy he was able to get such an accesible spot but I just wish it was closer to Union Square haha.

Millport Dairy was originally part of the Greenmarket vendors but have since opened their own brick and mortar location on the UWS, steps from the 96 St (1/2/3) station. The new space is small, but packs a ton of goodies like fresh eggs from both hens and ducks, loads of cheeses, butter, meats, pickled greens, baked goods, and soon produce (the shop currently has asparagus for $6/bunch but strawberries are coming next week)! You'll also find some of the best and freshest eggs in NYC here. For $6/dozen, you get eggs with an incredible deep orange color, which speaks to the quality and care of the hens that produce them. There are several egg options, from regular hens to pullet hens ($4/dz) to Ameraucana hens ($9/dz) to ducks ($12/dz) as well. The shop is run by Farmer John who is extremely knowledgable about all the products he sells. On my most recent visit, I also picked up a dozen pullet eggs, which he explained, are the first eggs laid by young hens so they are on the smaller side but contain more nutrients. He also recommended that I cook them lightly to retain said nutrients, preferably sunny side up. I'm very excited that there is now a brick and mortar location for Millport Dairy in the city, and highly encourage you to stop by during their opening hours (Wed-Sat, 7a-4p) for excellent quality goods from a family-run Amish farm.

I used to drive from Brooklyn to shop their eggs and butter when they were at union square farmers market. Now I'm driving even farther to the upper west side....that speaks volumes.

John the owner is so nice. This store is open We'd-Saturday mornings and afternoons. John travels from Lancaster County PA four days a week to run the shop. I only buy my eggs from him now. He has great produce, meat, and dairy products. His baked goods are great. Get a woopie pie when you stop in.

Exceptional, kind and farm fresh. I stop by every week for their high quality produce and smiles. Eggs, butter (awesome), baked goodies, vegetables.

I only buy a few items here, mainly eggs for my family. The eggs are fresh and good quality - not expensive.

The freshest and most delicious food you can buy. I used to visit their farm stand at Union Squares Green Market. Very happy that they got their own space. It's very close to the subway and easy to get to from Penn Station. Highly recommend the cheeses and ground beef; you'll never want to eat store-bought again! The owner is such a kind person. Will definitely be visiting again!

Real food. Best eggs. Milk. Raw cheddar. Adding in vegetables now. Tomatoes, peaches, slightly better priced than Greenmarket. Regular hours at the retail location, which is tiny but good enough. Love the Ginger Molasses cookies and ... er ... whoopie pies, ha ha.

Wonderful veggies, fruit, cheese, butter, eggs, pickles, and OMG, the bacon -- It's the best I've ever had. Plus it's totally charming and friendly, cute as a button, and quite reasonably priced. Worth going out of your way for.

Incredible peaches, some of the best I've had, and at a good price. Good to support a very small business.

Great tasting and fresh food, the smoked pork chop, gardienera and pickles are the winners!

I am SO happy our neighborhood has this gem. Best milk, eggs, and butter in the city. Fresh farm to table and a better price than grocery stores!! Amazing!

The best milk, eggs and butter I've ever had. Very helpful service. Just go; it's great.

Location Information above isn't correct Millport is on the West Side of Broadway, between 97th and 98th.

Improbable and delightful to have an honest to goodness farm stand off the corner of 97th and Broadway. A great addition to the neighborhood.

Great eggs but don't buy the cider! He sold me bad cider & have to return it. The other items seem ok but always check the dates on items!

Would rate this place 6 stars if I could, and thats coming from a person that's very particular about food/produce. Came here Saturday morning for some eggs, but also got some corn, cherries, sausage, and pickles. The eggs were so orange and creamy, and very reasonably priced. The corn was quite literally the best corn I've had in my life. I savored every kernel and I'm ready to get more this upcoming weekend. The cherries were so big, plump, and juicy, also the best I've had in my life and I'm a cherry lover. I haven't tried the sausage or pickles yet but I'm sure they taste amazing as well. Millport Dairy will be our new regular go-to for produce!

The best produce in town. Followed them up from the farmer's market in union square. Will continue to go for a long time

I'm converted best zucchini, bread and eggs in the city . I now go every few days . The hype is real

The best eggs I ever had, not just in NY. The best eggs period, including eggs I ate in farms in Tuscany. John Stoltzfoos, who is always in the store, and drives back and forth (6 hours commute) the 4 days the store is open, is very nice and friendly. We tried the zucchini's, the bacon and the home made bread: amazing. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED. It's so great that they have a brick and mortar now!