Dan B.
Yelp
During an afternoon hike nearby, my buddy and I chatted with a friendly hiker who raved about an old-school burger joint in town she had just tried. It was called Milton's....or Mike's...or something. My friend and I had no idea where this was, so we looked it up after our return to town. It turned out that Milt's was the oldest restaurant in town, having been open since 1954. It's not part of chain either; it's the only one.
Being reasonably close to our hotel, we hoofed it over here after a shower and a change of clothes. (Also it turns out that after spending $$ out-the-nose for several days, we were ready for some fast, cheap eats).
I absolutely loved the place, for multiple reasons: 1) It was a bit like walking into an old snapshot; 2) They offered decent food at great prices; 3) There was a large variety of folks here for some quality people-watching, such as: tourists (like us); local regulars (who seemed to know the staff by name); truckers passing through town; a small group of youth baseball players after a game; and even folks who seemed to be coming from formal events; 4) Customers ate at various picnic tables setup outside under an enormous sycamore tree. Plus it didn't hurt that it was a beautiful, cooling evening.
Milt's itself was shaped like a box, with staff inside and patrons outside. No drive through here; Ordering was via a walk-up front window. The line moved pretty fast, since the menu was straightforward, and a lot of people knew what they wanted. I opted for a fish sandwich, a side of onion rings, and a vanilla shake. $15 before tax.
My food was just what I wanted. It was of surprisingly good quality and filling; and it tasted like a gourmet meal after our hike. Sadly, with only one more full day here, we didn't get a chance to return to Milt's, but it is definitely bookmarked for a future trip to Moab.