Kristi M.
Yelp
Okay - seriously! How did I not know this place existed prior to my annual pilgrimage to MDI this summer. Really? I'm asking.
This is the second honor system bakery that I have discovered in the area and it will now also be a yearly stop for me - just like the other!
While this place is a little off the beaten path, it wasn't at all hard to find. Instead of turning down the busy main street of Ellsworth - just go the other way. Just a couple of miles up the road on the right there will be a little house with a flag outside (I forgot to take a photo - darn it).
In the garage, which is apparently open 24/7, there are coolers just filled with slices of cheesecake! The whole place is on the honor system (part of the reason it is 24/7). There is a cash box and you just leave $5.50 per slice you take. Really - only in Maine will you find honor system bakeries. And I love it!
And flavors galore. In one cooler, I found the traditional flavors - strawberry, cherry, blueberry, and even a lone strawberry ruhbarb (which I snatched right up). The other - was filled with more unique flavors - many inspired by candy bars like kit-kat, almond joy, andes candies, heath bar, butterfinger, and more. There were also flavors like Turtle, Lemon, Raspberry Lemon, Cookie Dough - seriously I can just keep going.
As I said, I ultimately landed on the Strawberry Rhubarb. It was perfect. The compote was just the right amount of sweet and tart and it was over the perfect denseness and richness cheesecake I've had in quite some time.
Again - this place will be a mandatory stop for me every time I visit the area from now on. Go - you won't regret it.