Prana E.
Google
Next time, please involve Western cultural perspectives beyond Western whiteness, not as surface tokens, but as artistic and curatorial peers. Or don’t suggest an exhibition is a universal exploration when it isn’t. White girls are beautiful, but not the only kind of beauty.
I came to see 'Girls : Boredom, Rebellion and In Between' as a Sofia Coppola fan and was excited about the theme. If this exhibition had been framed more as an exploration of white girlhood, iconography and visual culture, I wouldn’t have been so disappointed.
While the artwork had diversity and a clear narrative, the film and photography sections felt painfully narrow. The selection largely centered white girls as the "face of girlhood," repeating a tired pattern where white cultural institutions decide who is allowed to be beautiful, iconic and seen.
The show borrows Coppola’s visual language (which itself draws from Japanese shōjo cinematic style and a wider Asian lineage of girlhood interiority), yet erases that genealogy, recenters white girls, and includes only token images of non-white subjects framed through poverty or assimilation- “Look, she wears barrettes too.”
The film lineup made this clear by being overwhelmingly white: German schoolgirls, French classics (shown twice), white American tomboys, white girls shopping, European aristocracy, blond girls undressing in nature. Meanwhile, non-white girls were shown either approximating western beauty ideals (shoplifting is implied) or reduced to street-child tropes and aestheticized suffering (a Senegalese movie). Each film is a work of art. Context is the issue.
If the intention was poetic beauty, dream, fashion and explorations of girlhood and rebellion in cinema, why not include iconic films like Daughters of the Dust (which inspired Beyoncé's "Lemonade"), Spirit of the Beehive, Papicha, or Blue Gate Crossing? There is a vast cinematic history of tender, interior girlhood made by rebellious filmmakers from Europe and around the world.
The interviews and voices of real girls were literally placed facing the exit doors.