Matt H.
Yelp
Well, this was certainly the most expensive course I have ever played, and may be the one of the priciest course I ever play. I didn't pay rack rate, scoring a great discount on top of an already discounted web rate, but it is a pricy course. With the rate, the question is, is it worth the money. And the answer is a qualified no.
Don't get me wrong, it is a lovely course. I played the day after a rain, at the tail end of a wet month, so the course was a wee bit soggy. There were more than a few muddy lies, but on the whole I can overlook them. The fairways are fairly generous, and off the tee, the course does not qualify as target golf. where the target practice comes into play is in the approach. Most greens are well protected, so either have good control over your approach shots, or get some practice in with your sand wedge. On the plus side, the traps here are really nice (an advantage of being next to the beach), even with all the recent rain.
The greens themselves are fast, with multiple tiers and some really ugly pin placements. It is not that hard to put off the green. Again, even with the weather, these are some of the fastest greens I have played. And with the exception of some bird droppings, the greens are in fantastic shape.
There is a bit of water on the course, and it really comes in to play on two of the par 3s, but beyond that, it is manageable. Fairway traps are also sprinkled about, but they can be managed as well. I guess the key term here is course management. Since it is not overly long, shot placement is more important that length off the tee, and controlling your approach shots can mean the difference between an up and down and double bogey.
So, back to value, and what makes this course worthwhile. The views on a few holes are magnificent. Holes 3 and 4 are on the ocean side of PCH, so you are playing with the beach as a backdrop. No, you are not carrying a cliff onto a point overlooking the Pacific, but the is darn pretty. 18 is also beautiful, heading back in with the ocean as a distant backdrop. The course is very well maintained, but so are other like Talega, Tustin Ranch, Black Gold and Oak Creek. Toss in a few more if you are willing to drive to the IE. Customer care is nice here, with water in the carts (but no GPS) very friendly staff, and a complementary yardage book.
So give me a steep, steep discount, and I will play this course any time. At full rates, however, it isn't on my list.