Matthew L.
Yelp
While not quite as tasty as Solly's in Vancouver, Mount Royal produces a fairly good approximation of a Montreal bagel - smaller, denser, and sweeter than a New York bagel.
Mount Royal supplies a number of supermarkets in the region (Thrifty Foods, Market on Yates), but this location is their no frills factory, with only bagels, homemade (presumably) cream cheese, and a few different types of pop/soda/whatever for sale. The flavors tend to be more traditional - there are no blueberry bagels or pizza bagels, but they do have (not very good) whole wheat and multigrain offerings.
And at less than $7 per baker's dozen, Mount Royal offers some great value.