My Tomato Pie

Italian restaurant · Erie County

My Tomato Pie

Italian restaurant · Erie County

1

3055 Niagara Fls Blvd, Amherst, NY 14228

Photos

My Tomato Pie by null
My Tomato Pie by null
My Tomato Pie by null
My Tomato Pie by null
My Tomato Pie by null
My Tomato Pie by null
My Tomato Pie by null
My Tomato Pie by null
My Tomato Pie by null
My Tomato Pie by null
My Tomato Pie by null
My Tomato Pie by null
My Tomato Pie by null
My Tomato Pie by null
My Tomato Pie by null
My Tomato Pie by null
My Tomato Pie by null
My Tomato Pie by null
My Tomato Pie by null
My Tomato Pie by null

Highlights

Specialty pizzas, custom calzones & fried green tomatoes.  

Placeholder
Placeholder

3055 Niagara Fls Blvd, Amherst, NY 14228 Get directions

mytomatopie.com
@mytomatopie

$20–30 · Menu

Information

Static Map

3055 Niagara Fls Blvd, Amherst, NY 14228 Get directions

+1 716 838 0969
mytomatopie.com
@mytomatopie
𝕏
@mytomatopie

$20–30 · Menu

Features

wifi
payment credit card
Tap to pay
reservations

Last updated

Oct 27, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@grubstreet

Comedian Broti Gupta’s Grub Street Diet

"A local Italian spot used for takeout that nails comfort pasta — the baked ziti is a winning combination of pasta, six cheeses, and tomato sauce." - Alan Sytsma, Adam Mazur

https://www.grubstreet.com/2022/10/broti-gupta-grub-street-diet.html
View Postcard for My Tomato Pie

Suparna Banerjee

Google
Ordered take out from her while visiting Niagara . It was very close to our Airbnb. Viagarro Pizza-5/5 ( nice veg fresh, dough was fresh and so was the cheese) would have loved more veggies on them. Carissa Pizza- 4/5.Chicken Pizza dough was also very fresh and the cheese was really good. Chicken protein was good. Would had loved more veggies. Definitely worth visiting.

Jessica Bushhammer

Google
My tomato pie is the place to go for food and drinks. We had Carri for our bartender and she is the absolute best. I requested a strawberry margarita (with my friend) and she made an excellent one, she even crushed up strawberries in it. It was delicious! Her great drink making ability but mainly her kind spirit and on point service on making sure you’re well taken care of is one of the reasons I will keep coming back. The food was also very good as well!

NY Explorer

Google
Their personal pizzas are the best deal here and affordably priced to create your own combination. Service was fast. You can make a reservation online but I don't think it's really needed. I have been getting marketing emails twice a day now since making a reservation. Maybe calling them and not giving your email would be better. They do have a rewards program too which is nice.

Mehak Laharwal

Google
Ordered takeout via DoorDash: cranberry walnut chicken salad sandwich and tomato basil soup. Will not be trying anything else again. Tomato basil soup was super salty and not tasty at all, I couldn’t even finish it. Chicken salad sandwich came on a dry tasteless croissant. It had a side of pasta salad which wasn’t that good either. I just ended up eating the chicken salad and throwing the croissant + side salad away.

Bella Menza

Google
I enjoyed an array of sandwiches and salads from this establishment at a bridal shower recently and I was blown away by the taste and quality. We had turkey sandwiches and Cajun chicken sandwiches on focaccia along with pasta salad and green salad. The dressings were fresh and there was a variety of toppings and home made condiments. I would definitely recommend and look forward to having their food again!

Valerie Graff

Google
A seminar brought us to the restaurant. Not quite sure what to expect of the facility, being in a Top's mall. However, upon entry we were quite pleased. Nice and clean, big entryway. A counter with host to greet and seat. The first room was the banquet room where our seminar was. It was beautifully set up with white table clothes, stem water glasses, cloth napkin wrapped silverware. We were give a choice of three entree items; a chicken salad sandwich, 1/2# cheeseburger, or personal pizza. Here is a review for the two we enjoyed. The 1/2# cheeseburger adorned by a couple nice slices of tomato, lettuce, special sauce on the side. A wonderful spiral pasta mayo salad. The personal pizza, dough was cooked perfectly with a nice crisp on the bottom; yet, soft and enjoyably tender as crust. Just the right amount of tomato sauce, quite deliciously somewhere between sweet and standard. The cheese was just the right quantity, filling dips in the dough for a delicious gooey chew in some places and not others. The pepperoni was charred ever so slightly around the edges, similar to a cup and char, but the slices were larger in diameter and the taste remarkable. A few green olives sprinkled about. Another topping was included if desired. Overall, the meals were very good. The staff was very friendly and polite. Boxes for leftovers brought without needing to ask but not being rushed. The room was quite suited for a small seminar with a nice television for display show. Being the dining room was on the sidewalk side of the building, pull shades made for nice privacy but allowed ample sunlight and viewing to the outside, but not in. Although, we did not eat in the other dining section, which seemed to be the main dining area for the restaurant; it was audible that there is an echo from crowd noise. Those that prefer a quite meal, consider this. The entire facility seemed great for a date or family dining. We would definitely return to the restaurant if in the area.

Tyla Kells

Google
Excellent food. Menu has a lot to offer. Parking lot has plenty of room to park. Have always gotten a seat without any wait time. Food comes out quite quickly. Staff incredibly nice and attentive. Inside main dining room lighting is a little dim. Have also been there for a baby shower and the staff were wonderful. They work with the WNY Alzheimer's Chapter and have donated proceeds from sales to their campaign annually.

Karin Rogers

Google
The broiled fish was way too salty, and I could not eat it. The french fries were plain, they did not have a coating. Coleslaw was good. Overpriced compared to other places that have great fish fries in the area.