Nagle’s Bagels

On the Grid : Nagle's Bagels

"Boasting the same owners as beautiful neighborhood coffee shop Little Zelda, Nagle's Bagels serves up some super tasty bagels plenty of schmear and fixins. Their menu consists of the classic lox to the Elvis PB&J (bacon, honey, peanut butter, and jam). Take a moment to shop around while you wait on your bagel—they also sell jams, sauces, and cookbooks that make great gifts. This place gets pretty slammed on the weekends with people trying to rectify last night's mistakes, so get in early if you want to snag your favorite type of bagel." - Kyle & Annie Turman

"Around 9:30, I walked down to Nagle’s Bagels on Tompkins, and ordered the Veggie Nagle: eggs, baby arugula, feta, and chili jam on a salt bagel and then punched in my reward card. Their bagels are good, they’re filling, they’re all that stuff, but I was really coming for the chili jam. The chili jam is fantastic."

"I looked at a breakfast sandwich from Nagle’s Bagels, which is a bagel spot near my apartment, but then I realized that what I actually wanted was a bodega sandwich: a deli sandwich, a kombucha, and a bag of chips is one of my favorite meals."

Author Kyle Chayka’s Grub Street Diet

"A neighborhood bagel counter producing classic New York morning fare—everything bagel with cream cheese and tomato—ideal for a quick Super Bowl–day breakfast pick-up." - Paula Aceves, Margalit Cutler

Author Sarah Thankam Mathews’s Grub Street Diet

"A shop where the author bought a bagel sandwich for a visiting friend — a quick, neighborhood source for a bagel sando." - Rima Parikh, Adam Mazur