Chow Y.
Yelp
The first thing you think upon entering Nan Lian is that someone really wanted to make a Japanese Garden in Hong Kong but wasn't allowed to. So they went with this instead.
Now...the history of even Japanese gardens goes back to China where places such as Nan Lian were supposed to represent what heaven might look like. And what an improvement over the western conception of heaven with all it's boring-ass whiteness, which would drive anyone mad.
There are many stunning gardens all over China (check out Suzhou) but to be perfectly honest, none can compare to what the Japanese have accomplished in this art. And China should take credit since Japanese culture is just an outgrowth of Chinese.
And so without being hyper obvious about it, the creators of this space really created a hybrid Japanese-Chinese and by not following the best methods of either, the result is an aesthetic failure.
If it was me...I would have created an elaborate ostentatious Hong Kong style garden right out of the 50's-60's with the color and energy of Old Hong Kong. And pay homage to the history of the city. Perhaps have included a vintage street with remakes of some of the famous shops and restaurants that once existed.
What we have instead is a very polished, very NEW...and I mean super NEW looking...old looking wannabe Japanese garden.
And it is trying way too hard, with WAY too much to see in every inch. Jesus. How can you contemplate a rock with another rock and another and another and a waterfall and a pagoda and a bridge and another bridge and BONSAI! (poorly cared for I might add).
It's just so much, so cramped in such a small space. While the garden is a nice size, there is enough here to fill 100's of gardens around the world.
Back to the Bonsai...yellow leaves, dying grass beneath, very poor maintenance with growth ALL over the place -- no trimming...I mean, if you're going to bring in 1000's of dollars worth of trees, hire someone who knows how to take care of them. And again...a very Japanese looking display even though the art started in China...
Lastly, so many of the nicest spots are BLOCKED OFF because of bad behavior of previous tourists. In fact, when I was there, I noticed an idiot Asian-American yanking on the trees to see if "they were real". These fools ruin it for everyone but instead of blocking the garden off, why not just fine these morons?
I think for western eyes, this place will be an incredible experience but whereas the Emperor's Garden in Tokyo is a once in a lifetime experience, this is not. It's worth seeing because yes, there is beauty here but it's artificial. You're better off just walking through the more local Hong Kong parks and streets to get that same feeling of majesty that you are expecting here.