New York Bagel Cafe

I’m from Houston and I thought the prices here were really good. Lox Bagel was delicious and for $8.99 a steal. Cappuccino was good. Overall a great experience

Quality is definitely not what it once was. Today’s experience included an over cooked cinnamon roll and over cooked pecan sticky bun, coffee was the consistency of colored water. We had a chocolate milk which expired today but had already soured. The milk we had replaced with apple juice, the iced tea was fine but overall not what we hoped or expected. Disappointed and disappointing experience would not recommend.

I thought this place was really good! I got a BLT bagel and my husband got the turkey guacamole with added egg. Both had fresh flavors and plenty of meat! P We took home a French toast bagel that was yummy, I love a good maple taste and cinnamon so this paired with cookie butter cream cheese was a nice snack later. I also got an ice white chocolate coffee and it too was tasty. Service was pleasant and we eat on the go a lot so drive thru is a great option.

First, New York Bagel is a bold name for a bagel restaurant and I believe a challenge to live up to that name. Coming from the most southern Burrough of New York, otherwise known as South Florida, I have had many New York bagels, and New York Bagel lives up to the name! With all that said… What?!? Wasabi Bomb Bagel?!? OMG! I had this sandwich for the very first time today; I can’t believe I have lived this long without having wasabi cream cheese. The Everything bagel was fresh (I don’t toast mine), loaded with fresh tomatoes, red onions, cucumber, and lots of lox! But the wasabi cream cheese!!! So yummy! P.S. I ordered it open face, and by the time I remembered about a review, I had already devoured the first half.

We had 3 types of bagels to taste quality vs Einstein B. and I believe for some reason they are more tastier,a good selection of varieties of dishes and bagels. They also have if you select coffee a great selection of flavors you can pick along with creamers and sugars. Same with teas and soft drinks. Service to me was a bit dry not friendly. However, the atmosphere was pleasant.

The Yale location sucks. Every time I go there my order is wrong, the food tastes old, and for some reason, they don’t believe in putting any kind of sauce on their sandwiches, despite what’s depicted on the menu. I’ve been there around 5 or so times since they opened the Yale location and its always the same bad experience. Dry sandwiches, not toasted or heated as I requested, the completely wrong sandwich (which is bizarre because it’s not a one-time mistake—it’s happened 3 times), long wait times, bagels and cookies taste old and dry, etc. An old bagel with no sauce of any kind makes for an unpleasant experience. Make sure to get a drink..you’ll need it! And strangely, the location on Peoria is absolutely lovely! Everything is fresh, I always get the sandwich I ordered AND it’s made according to the description! The sandwich is always hot or toasted, as I requested, and the bagels and cookies are perfection. I’m not sure why the discrepancy between the 2 locations, but if you’re out South, it’s worth the extra few miles to go to the Peoria store.

I usually don’t do reviews but I felt the need to this morning. I waited 20 minutes for my bagel sandwich that was cold by the time I got it. I went up to the register to ask if my food was almost ready and it had just been sitting there on the back counter. My egg was dry and overcooked. I paid for 2 eggs and got something that looked like a processed egg patty from McDonalds. The bagel was good but the bacon was raw and the sandwich was dry. On the other hand, I did get a delicious looking cinnamon roll that will hopefully make up for the lack of the cold bagel and egg sandwich.

As a lox 🥯 connoisseur I’m very excited to have e this place in Tulsa. Goes to show how diverse Tulsa food is for a smaller city. Amazing decor and the place is huuuuuuge! Great place to work from or have a casual business meeting. Plenty of seating for large groups as well. Now onto the 🥯: The bagel itself was great, fresh and had that outside bite. I got a customized lox bagel with cucumbers for crunch, toasted on garlic with onion and chives. My only small complain was how little lox they put and if you’ve had a bagel on 🗽 you already know how much lox they add. Either way it hits the spot and the place has an awesome atmosphere.