New York Pizzeria

2.3 stars. A rip-off. $12.95 for a slice of “gourmet” pizza. Um, nope. Service was nothing special. Atmosphere is essentially a loud mall food court. It is easy to see why and how people are choosing other places to vacation as Vegas keeps squeezing tourists for everything they can.

This pizza was MID. I expected to have a more realistic New York pizza experience. The sauce wasn’t great, decent amount of cheese was good but overall the pizza was gummy. Not great. However we ate across the street at MGM and the Pizza there was amazing. Skip NY NY for pizza

We got 2 slices of pizza n a meatball cup on the side. This right here total of $23 which is pretty crazy for the both the quality n the quantities of value u get for that price. Flavors is alright it tastes like pizza, a bit cold so it might be on the counter for a while. The slice is big enough per person but def wasnt worth it considering how many better places there r in town. Staffs r good, quick to move long lines of people at dinner hours. Is strip price so i get it. Oh well, probs not coming back. 5/10

Customer service was great and the pizza and garlic knots were very good. My wife loved her Hawaiian pizza and said it was the best pizza she had eaten. My pepperoni pizza was probably the best I have ever had as well. I am Looking forward to returning for some pizza already .

Being conscious of Vegas tax… $30 for a slice, massive jar of “buffalo sauce” and a Dr Pepper for pizza that resembles nothing of NY pizza is outrageous

Atmosphere is what you expect being a pizza place in a hotel but was clean and comfortable. The pizza was pretty good but wasn't as good as real NY style pizza. The counter service was quick and easy

Pizza looked dry and stale so i asked for a little extra sauce on it. They charged me an extra $2 for it without informing me. Horrible place and the server had an attitude 👎🏾

Pizza tasted like card board took one bite and got a refund another place where drunk people would like the food no flavor staff was nice and the vibe was bizzy hotel hurry up and buy sad that this is what Vegas New York hotel as come to

The pizzeria inside the New York Hotel on the Vegas strip is a convenient spot for a post-night-out meal, staying open late to accommodate your late-night cravings. Just a heads up that this spot is a bit pricy, where 2 slices and 2 garlic rolls were over $20. The pizza, also, isn't true New York style due to its thicker crust. Some letdowns were that the pizza was VERY greasy, had a hard crust, and minimal meat toppings, with only about three small pepperonis per slice, but it wasn't the worst pizza overall. Despite these drawbacks, the convenience and late hours make it an ok choice for a quick bite after a night out.

We stopped at this little pizzeria in the New York New York Casino for a quick snack. The slice of pepperoni pizza was just aiight. Nothing to write home about. Not bad, but not great.

I got the chicken and broccoli stromboli. They took it off the display and heated it up before packing it up in a to go box. It came with a cup of marinara sauce, fork, and knife. It was cheesy and easy to bite into.

After a disappointing pizza experience at NYNY, I walked across the bridge to the MGM and tried the NY Pizzeria located at the bottom of the escalators. I ordered one slice of peperoni with sausage and one slice combo. They put both slices into the oven and brought to my table when ready. Although just warm, the taste was good. I asked them to put one slice back in so I can eat it hot. They grabbed me a new slice without issue. I like my cheese melted and stringy. The tastes were spot on though. 2 min in the oven seems to have done it. Thank you to the young lady that served me. This place has the typical pay by the slice look. Bright and clean but open to self seating.

The Stromboli was awesome! It was cheesy and pretty tasty, but 3 stars bc they have such little options. You can't order a slice of what you want. You can order a whole pizza of what you like, but if you want to be fast, then you're limited to their options. Cheese, pepperoni, and maybe one or 2 veggies pizza. It also looks so thin and dry. I'm highly sad that they looked from afar they had choices, but really, there are only two pizzas out there you can choose from. It's good they at least had the bread sticks/balls thing and the Stromboli. But for 17$ Stromboli, it's def not worth it. But then again, it's vegas.

I decided to get the pepperoni and jalapeno slice. I wish there was an even amount of toppings as the slice was very jalapeno heavy. There's not much pep on there at all. To me, it seemed a little thicker than the usual NY style slice. I found it interesting that the paper plate had the logo for Bonanno's New York Pizza (which I've had in the past in Downtown Summerlin). I don't know how it's connected with this pizza joint in the NY NY casino. For almost $11 a slice, it's still good but expensive.

We got two slices of pizza for $20 plus a drink so $20 something. Way overpriced for the quality and slice. It was a good pizza but just a bit overboard on the price but we were hungry. Once was pepperoni and the other Hawaiian.

It's a simple concept that's in every Las Vegas casino, and this is the third one I tried this week. The pizza here was good, not outstanding. It certainly hit the spot for those hunger pains. I am just so amazed that a slice of pizza costs $12.

TL;DR: decent food. Counter service. Will repeat. It is a bit on the pricey side. That is to be expected being inside the mandalay bay food court. I got the Stromboli + beer combo for $30. Stromboli was served warmed and tasted good and the beer (can) was cold. Service was fast and efficient. The food court was clean and modern with charging ports and power outlets at each table!

The worst pizza I've ever had. It was dripping with grease with every bite and the texture was awful. The crust was so hard to chew. Never again.

Just wanted to eat something quick to balance out all the alcohol and was definitely worth it. Their pizza was not greasy and had a nice crunch to it. Their garlic bread was everything! It's was very tasty and made to perfection. Definitely on the pricey side but that's Vegas and worth it. Service was a normal fast food station. We had to go back twice tho

Decent pizza available in the late hours. I appreciate the convenience and rapid service!

My kids loved the pizza. Big slices and quick service. Nice location right by our elevators.

What a treat! Nothing like visiting Vegas! There is something for all ages, gender, ethnicity JUST EVERYBODY! Sooooooo here we are early morning (before noon) in New York, New York, drinking and playing slots. The smell of pizza was in the air! After playing a little and winning a little and sipping a little, we decided to get some pizza before heading back to the room for somebody to take a napnot me! So, getting pizza was easy. They have ready slices of cheese, pepperoni and meat pepperoni and sausage slices. They heat them for in in the oven. I had to get two because thats what I do. No drinks, just M life water! Pizza was quick, thin, crispy and good!!! Always a go to spot. Loved it and will be back for the New York style slice! Thanks!

Pizza was good, we ordered a whole not slices, took about 30 minutes, line can get long pretty quickly, staff was nice and accommodating. We ordered Pepperoni with jalapeños on it, was all together about $35-40 pricy but when it's the only thing open at 3am ‍ and you're hungry you eat it, located in New York New York hotel ambiance was cool plenty places to sit and eat.

Little overpriced, but delicious!! Super crispy and thin! I recommend coming the taste is great

Get the pepperoni stromboli. It looks even better than the pictures they show. You're welcome

The pepperoni Stromboli was really good. However, the prices were steep for pizza. It wasn't spectacular. Especially since they had to reheat it. For the price I wouldve liked a guaranteed hot off the press Stromboli. There are other places in the hotel with better prices and are the same quality .

Cafeteria style fast food NY style, pick a slice any slice! They also serve up pasta, salads, desserts, and drinks. Came here for a quick dinner inside New York New York casino with a friend and we each got our slices on. I knocked off a star for the greasiness, but its goodness is so worth it and well they have napkins! There was a long line upon arrival, but it moved and there's plenty of seats in the square. Staff was friendly and served us well. Also, side note we got a side of meatballs and they were amazing!

Stumbled upon this place walking home one evening. It's in a great location amongst other food spots. Since I was craving pizza, I tried out the white sauce cheese pizza. For one slice and no toppings, it was a little on the pricey side and very greasy. The great part is, if you are super hungry, you pick your slice of pizza and it goes through the oven quickly. Plenty of seating all around. Just be sure to grab a ton of napkins!

Late night pizza cravings on the strip? Head to the New York Hotel and Casino for a slice of pizza or Stromboli! The prices are decent for Vegas and service was very quick. I was able to take it back to my hotel and enjoy my Stromboli with the marinara sauce!

Very disappointed, I experienced far more. Not even close to true NY pizza, plus at $11.33 a slice with mushrooms it's ridiculous. I get a much better 1 topping slice at home for $2.65. I understand charging a bit more in a casino but this is overboard.

I came on 7/14/24 at 9:33 pm. My son and I ordered 4 slices of pizza. I ordered 2 cheese, 1 mushroom and 1 thick pepperoni slice. The latina lady told me to go pay at cash register. I did pay, but when I sat down to eat, the thick pepperoni slice wasn't there instead there were 3 cheese and 1 mushroom, so my husband decided to order another slice, no big deal. But as my son and I were watching my husband go order, he kept being ignored. A man with a mustache kept ignoring him, finally a latina lady came to help him, the same tall man with mustache told him he had to order from cash register. Like what! Rude. My husband said, never mind. Meanwhile a large group of people came and ordered where my husband was first waiting, they weren't ignored. Will not order again, plus pizza wasn't that good.

I was in the mood for a slice of New York style pizza and New York Pizzeria filled that craving. It wasn't phenomenal pizza, but it was definitely good and will hit the spot if you are in the mood for pizza. I recommend New York Pizzeria if you are visiting The New York New York Hotel and Casino.

This wannabe pizza place is in the basement of the MGM Grand hotel. It needs to stay in the basement. I ordered two slices of pizza with toppings and they are nine dollars apiece. Yes, nine dollars per slice of pizza. They then asked me if I wanted to make it a combo with a beer that added $14 and I actually laughed at them. I understand this is a Vegas strip hotel but when you have mediocre food at exorbitant prices, you have to expect these kind of reviews to. I would rather not on my own foot off and then eat at New York pizzeria again

3 stars Just under $9 for a big slice. Slightly pricey for what you get. The pizza was good, but it tasted like it had sat out for some time. Like a longer time than it should've. Like it air cooled at room temperature. On the bright side at least they threw it back in the oven. Overall it was ok. Not bad but not great. It was edible. Not as good as other NY Style pizza places Vegas has to offer. Would probably not come back. The To go box for one slice is huge. Maybe that's why one slice is so expensive.

The pizza here was delicious. I ordered a whole pepperoni pizza and it exceeded my expectations. The pizza tasted exactly the way a NY thin crust pizza should taste like. The sauce had a nice tangy flavor. The crust had a nice crispy crust, that wasn't oily. The cheese and pepperoni were both spread evenly and tasted of good quality. The place was busy, but my pizza was ready in about 15 minutes. For having a steady flow of customers, the place was well kept and tables were wiped down. The customer service wasn't the best, very rushed . Also, The prices are a little steep for pizza. You're looking at upwards of $9 for a one topping slice and $46 for a whole one topping pizza. If you can look past the price and lackluster customer service. You will enjoy NY pizzeria.

Zero stars. Oregano in pizza sauce is blasphemous. $10 for an inedible slice. Also, blend your sauce, we shouldn't be catching whole pieces of onion.

Delicious and quick and easy. After walking the strip we wanted a bite to eat and a nice huge slice of Pizza Hut the spot. They also gave us a side of ranch for no extra charge.

This place offers great service but the pizza is good but not exceptional. It's worth trying!

Fairly good pepperoni pizza by the slice. It's New York-style pizza, which is thin crust. I hate pizza place that skimp on the tomato sauce to the point where it's nothing but cheese. But here the sauce was plentiful on the two slices I had with plenty of pepperonis. The Stromboli was great also with plenty of filling. The minus 1-star is due to the prices. One-topping slice is around $9 and the Stromboli was $12. A whole box of pizza will run over $40! I know this is Las Vegas but still, that a lot of money. If you can overlook the high prices, give this place a shot whenever you're in the New York New York Hotel/Casino.

The pizza here was delicious and they had a good variety of pizzas. I went for a slice of the supreme with a garlic knot and some dipping sauce. It was very good but if I had to choose between this spot and the other pizza spot at NYNY I would say Sirricos is slightly better. Still deserving of 5 stars.

Decent tasting pizza. But for the price, a little smaller than I'd expect. Warm, and still great after a few hours of drinking

As fast food pizza goes, giving it high marks for food but could be cleaner But I guess if this is supposed to be like New York Street food then it's perfect

Perfect for late night after the concert. Just cheese is excellent! We all devoured it and it was very satisfying. We will try others later. We will be back.

Great for a late night slice of pie after walking around the Linq Promenade in Las Vegas!

Right at the entrance from MGM into NYNY at the Mezzanine level We got Ian a 4 cheese Pizza slice, and the Mrs. got a Stuffed Slice. Total with tax came to $16.18 Pros: None. Cons: Weird set up to pay at the counter. I am used to the Metal tag at Blaze pizza etc. so the heat up process on the ready made pizza was a little bit confusing. Tasted nothing like a New York Pizza. Mrs. threw the Stuffed Slice away after taking a couple of bites. (-2)

Recommend. Quick and easy spot to grab a bite (sober or less so) on the strip. Even when the line is long, the employees move it quickly. I tried the pizza, salad, and garlic knots. The slices are great. I would recommend asking they keep it in the oven a little longer than normal, cuz sometimes the slices might not be fully warmed through. The salad was good, maybe a little heavy on the dressing - I would recommend asking for light dressing and maybe some on the side so you don't get too much. The garlic knot was good, but with the slice and salad it was a little too much food so I gave up on it. Overall - would return again as it was so convenient and good enough.

Pizza place inside New York New York. Large slices with a great taste. Cafeteria style where you walk up to the line and state what you like. Nothing fancy but great tasting pizza. Small sitting area right outside the shop and a few tables inside but still a small tight space. Best to grab and go.

New York Pizzeria has been a go to for me every time I've stayed at NYNY. This last time around, I was actually pretty sober when I ordered up a couple slices. This was a much different experience! The flavor was bland and the crust was consistent with a wet paper towel. The service was good, the pizza fell short this time around.

Tried this place while having a beer at Pour 24! Had a stuffed slice with Ricotta, Spinach, and Broccoli! I thought it a bit pricey, however the stuffed slices are quite large, and mine was delicious! There are regularNY Style slices as well, but they are only $1.00 les than a stuffed slice and rather small for the cost! I think the SS is the way to go! The marina was tasty as well! They have salads, rather small Strombolis, and Garlic Knots as well! Definitely worth a stop if your in NYNY!

Great for a slice and one of the few fast grab food places open right now in Vegas. The pizza is okay not great not bad. Nice staff.

this is just an average slice of pizza. Is It worth $8? Definitely NO. Very expensive place you could eat many things with this price in las vegas.

Roaming around, hungry and sort of buzzed in Vegas. I wanted something hot, fast and cheesy. Somehow ended up here and hey, it did the job. NYP provided me a cheese pizza fast, easy, and hot. Lots of cheese on a thin crust. Unfortunately it wasn't crispy like I thought it would be but not bad for a slice of pizza on a late night. The staff is alright, I did have to repeat my order a few times to the worker. Maybe he couldn't hear me?? The person at the register was a bit slow too. We were charging our pizza to the room and for some reason she couldnt figure out how to do it. We ended up just paying for it and took our receipt later to get our points.

Somehow the most incredible NY style pizza outside NYC. Advertising genuine San Marzano tomatoes, the sauce was definitely next-level, and the dough made right there was flavorful and crispy. Seating is limited, so get there early to grab a good table.

Average Pizza place slightly expensive per slice otherwise decent enough pizza and garlic knots. Pizza taste was fine and everything was crisp and warm. Pepperoni were low quality and pizza needed more sauce. Garlic knot was above average and marinara was good. It dripped garlic which was nice. Overall acceptable fast pizza joint.

The pizza here was decent. The hubby and I shared a slice of cheese pizza. He also got two garlic knots with marinara sauce. We washed everything down with a Dr. Brown's root beer. For $5.45, the slice wasn't that huge and it was thin crust. Since it was thin crust, I was hoping that it would be crispy, but it wasn't. The pizza wasn't overly salty. The sauce had a nice seasoning to it. The garlic knots were awesome. They were just buttery, garlicky, and soft. I dipped it into the marinara sauce and stuffed it into my mouth. It made my tastebuds happy. The guy working there was cool. They were having this promotion with this mug. It was $10 but you could get free refills at any of their restaurants with a purchase. Without a purchase, it was $1 or something like that. He wasn't trying to sell it to me or anything. I noticed it and asked him about it. He took his time explaining it to me.

Too much cheese, too much crust and too much money. At $7 a slice, I thought maybe they would have flown in one of the Italian guys from Arthur Ave in the Bronx to make the pizza. The only reason we ended up here is because of my kids. They are not hard to please. Side note, I asked for two regular slices and the people behind the counter had no idea what I wanted. So then I said two plain slices. Still no idea. They asked me if I meant cheese slices. Uhhhh yea. That's how we say it in New York.

This was not for me. I got the meat lovers stuffed slice. Pizza was still cool in the middle. Had some kind of sausage that was not the best texture or taste. Way too much dough for a stuffed pizza. The service was fine I was just expecting more from a NY style pizza place. Perhaps the slices are better, but from the look of it I don't know.