Marian L.
Yelp
My disappointment with Nick's Nest probably is largely the result of too-high expectations -- I'd heard it was THE place for hot dogs and baked beans in the area, and that it was a must-visit.
So visit I did. The place itself is definitely worth a peek -- old-school look and feel, with a big ol' popcorn machine, counter seating and a front door that opens remotely via pulley.
Got a hot dog with mustard, a serving of baked beans, and a Nick's Nest bottled lemonade.
Alright, I am not the biggest hot dog fan. When I say my dog was bland and rather nondescript flavorwise, you may or may not want to take that as a positive.
But I do love baked beans. Little plaques in the counter area advise patrons to try their famous homemade baked beans. The plaques are spaced 2 or 3 seats apart, such that you'd have to have 20/400 vision to not receive the message as you dine.
I did try the baked beans. More salty than sweet or smoky, they just weren't my cup of tea (or beans). Also, the serving included a few rather large hunks of pork fat. To be honest, I didn't identify the smooth, rectangular white blobs -- my husband did. And his reward -- which he appreciated -- was the placement of said blobs into his cup.
Definitely not the ideal spot for vegetarians (although scooping out the fat made me wax a bit nostalgic for my own meat-free years of yore).
But most disappointing was the Nick's Nest bottled lemonade, which turned out to be a beverage produced elsewhere, consisting mainly of high fructose corn syrup. I was seduced by the branding, and didn't read the label before buying. I was doubly disappointed when I realized the Nest also serves delicious Rollie's root beer, which is made in Holyoke.
They've also got a few other menu items and a soft-serve window (the latter a must 'round these parts). Probably worth a stop when in town -- for the ambiance alone -- but probably not worth a drive (unlike the White Hut in West Springfield -- for that place, believe the hype!).
Three stars instead of two because (a) my husband loved his food, and (b) it's a local landmark.