Nightmare Hayrides
Permanently Closed

Nightmare Hayrides

Permanently Closed

Phobia-themed attraction with hayride, maze, and haunted barn

Nightmare Hayrides by null
Nightmare Hayrides by null
Nightmare Hayrides by null
Nightmare Hayrides by null
Nightmare Hayrides by null
Nightmare Hayrides by null
Nightmare Hayrides by null
Nightmare Hayrides by null
Nightmare Hayrides by null
Nightmare Hayrides by null
Nightmare Hayrides by null
Nightmare Hayrides by null
Nightmare Hayrides by null
Nightmare Hayrides by null
Nightmare Hayrides by null
Nightmare Hayrides by null
Nightmare Hayrides by null
Nightmare Hayrides by null
Nightmare Hayrides by null
Nightmare Hayrides by null
Nightmare Hayrides by null

Information

6319 Sommerville Valley Rd, Ellicottville, NY 14731 Get directions

Information

Static Map

6319 Sommerville Valley Rd, Ellicottville, NY 14731 Get directions

+1 716 699 4839
nightmarehayride.com

Features

restroom
wheelchair accessible parking lot

Last updated

Dec 1, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@grubstreet
13,506 Postcards · 1,478 Cities

The Best 2018 NYC Halloween Parties

"A phobia-themed Instagram walk-through featuring a slaughter room and creepy-crawlies." - Vanita Salisbury

https://www.grubstreet.com/2018/10/nyc-halloween-parties-parades-2018.html
Nightmare Hayrides

Henry F.

Google
Went here 2 years ago and was very impressed with how scary and well thought out it was. The actors did a fantastic job being realistically scary. You take a hayride, corn maze, and haunted barn one after another which helped things move fast and efficiently. Can’t wait to come back again!

Mary V.

Google
We experienced “nightmare hayride”. This weekend. I wasn’t sure what to expect. But it was a very memorable event. All the staff we met were very courteous and friendly very fair prices for all the screams and laughs you will have. We thoroughly enjoyed our visit and would love to go again. I highly recommend this event

Journey M.

Google
Holy cow it was more expensive than we thought, which gave me a sour mood to start, but it overcame it by being awesome. The hayride was nice, but you get the haunted house after which really makes it. The actors were phenomenal. I brought my elementary age kids and they gave them an extraordinary experience. The snack bar after was meh I probably wouldn't go there again. But I'll definitely be back next year.

Bryan & Libby D.

Google
We visited Nightmare Hayrides on Sommerville Street for the first time this week. We really enjoyed being scared by their wonderful and friendly staff. We screamed and laughed at the same time.

Jennifer W.

Google
Not worth the $30.00 a ticket. Short hay ride with very little going on. The barn and maze also pretty boring. . My husband scares more people than the workers. Not very haunted or scary definitely would not go again.

Henry F.

Google
I went here last year it was so scary when you are riding through the woods the actors make sudden noises out of nowhere which was really scary. The barn was really long but super good, I would definitely recommend nightmare hayrides on Somerville street to any one except little kids.😱

JoJo O.

Google
ABSOLUTELY WORTH THE HOUR DRIVE FROM WHERE WE LIVE! Such a great time and the taco in a bag was delicious too! Would highly recommend this for anyone wanting to have a genuinely spooky time! I’d say great for individuals, couples and families with or without children! Bundle up it gets cold on the hayride but the laughing and screaming tends to warm the body up! Definitely a great great time! *mother in law approved* haha

Newark P.

Google
Was 15 minute ride not 25. Was pretty much a dark hayride where occasionally masked characters jumped out and onto wagon. The maze was slightly better but so dark you couldn’t see where you were going and bumped into several walls. Wasn’t worth the money!!
google avatar

Sara K.

Yelp
Just went this evening with a group of 8 adults and we had an absolute riot! The line is long but it moves incredibly fast. We had a solid hour of fun there. The hayride and the haunted barn are filled with actors to scare you and I found both to be very high quality. There is a stand for I think food and beverages but we didn't go there so I can't tell you what's available. There's also a stand selling tshirts, hoodies, blankets, etc. $30 per ticket and it is worth the experience for sure!