NY Slice Pizza Big Bay

There is only one pizza and that's the pepperoni New York style. Puts Blue Peter to sleep. Great pizza and service, the only reason for the atmosphere low score is due to renovations. Class.

This New York slice joint is a real find! The atmosphere is always buzzing with good vibes thanks to the super friendly staff – they genuinely make the place feel welcoming. And the pizza? Seriously delicious. That sourdough crust is a game-changer – it's always fresh, hot, and has that perfect sourdough tang. Whether I'm grabbing a slice in person or ordering online (which is super quick, by the way!), the quality is consistent. My go-to is their big 50cm pizza with pepperoni (I call it the Big Kahuna!) – it’s a proper, foldable NY slice loaded with flavor. If you're after an authentic New York pizza experience with awesome people and fantastic sourdough, look no further. Highly recommended! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ PS, Thanks guys, will be back again!

I drove to Bloubergstrand yesterday morning and ordered a pizza from I love NY Slice Pizza Big Bay. The pizza was so oily and the few pieces of meat were swimming in it and the dough was still raw in the center. It was really not pleasant to eat, and later that evening at home, I was terribly sick. The area inside behind the counter where they assemble the pizza and take meat out of the plastic boxes/containers was very dirty. The outside tables were in a terrible state of dirty. Empty boxes on the table and flies everywhere. It was so unpleasant to try and sit and eat at the table, cleaning the chairs and table top myself to the best of my ability. It was one of the most unpleasant experiences of eating at a restaurant. The morning of trying to relax, looking at the sea, eating some food, just down the drain. I am very sorry, but would not be able to recommend this place to anyone.

Worst and most unreliable. I have treid to order from Big Bay branch 8 times on UBER EATS. They always cancel orders at the last minute aftere waiting 30 mins. PLACE SUCKS

Joe is AMAZING! very helpful, amazing pizza, great chats, favorite place ever. Even offered to stay a couple minutes overtime to let us finish our pizza

This specific branch is so bad, they short all the toppings even when I added on extra toppings. There is also no cheese on the pizzas, they really don’t know how to make it well. The staff also really stare at you do no reason and aren’t very friendly. This was so disappointing as I was really craving this pizza. Next time I’m going back to the branch in Woodstock on Victoria Rd. Their pizza is actually tastes great. Unlike this one, such a disappointment!

My best friend and I went for a relaxed intimate atmosphere. She enjoyed her delicious slice of pizza. I discovered a hair in my food and had to wait for a replacement of one slice after 17 clients received service. I sat and waited and just enjoyed the happy faces.Next time, please also treat me with the same respect you treat the regulars. We used to go on our monthly date as girls. But this one was our first bad service. 27/12/24.

Staff was amazing love the guy so much thank you ,lots of love🩷 Kian,Sophia and Emma