O'Donoghue's Irish Pub

This was my 3rd visit in the last 10 years... It was every bit as good as my first two times! I was greeted when I walked in, seated quickly and my waitress was "on her job!" My meal came out surprisingly quick and was very hot when it arrived. Possibly the best Chicken Pot Pie I've ever had... My Key Lime Pie appeared a little small, but I have to admit, it was so rich and delicious, I couldn't have eaten any more had it been any bigger! Friendly atmosphere, friendly staff! Prices were fair for a very good meal!

Best Wings in Wisco! Polish sausage and Slaw are great too. Love this place

Cozy neighborhood spot with pretty great bar food and plenty of space. Super friendly staff. Service can be slow at times, but this place is often hopping! Two dings off of atmosphere because their ventilation system is more of a suggestion than anything else. Expect to leave this place smelling like fryer grease. We love to come here for our book club- just aim for a wash day!

What an incredible gem! We stumbled on this place kind of on accident and we’re so glad we did! As we were enjoying our delicious meal and beers, we noticed what a true neighborhood pub feel it had. Friends and family were meeting up for dinner with laughter and hugs all around. The owner, Jamie, checked on our table and we struck up a conversation. Such a warm, welcoming atmosphere! They even had a young lad from Ireland singing and playing traditional Irish songs. We’ll be back for Milwaukee Irish Fest and O’Donoghue’s will be top of the list! Thank you, Jamie, for your amazing hospitality!

The food was really good, atmosphere was okay. Our waitress was very abrupt and hardly came around, took surprisingly long to get a beer considering it didnt seem too busy. Also considering this is a very laid back bar grill setting the food was more expensive than to be expected. Not somewhere i would go out of my way for but if I were in the area and tasted up for a rueben I would go back there.

What an absolute joy! We came in from out of town and found this fantastic spot by pure chance. I felt like I stepped into a pub in Ireland with the craic (friendly conversation), the food, and the perfect pours of Guinness. There was an Irish musician playing an acoustic set that we were lucky enough to sit in on. The staff was incredibly friendly and welcoming, and the atmosphere was incredible. This is a great spot for families or just grabbing a pint at the bar. I’d come back to Milwaukee just to hang out here again!

Visited for a fairly late dinner yesterday evening. The service was spot on the food was excellent. I ordered a "traditional Rueben sandwich that was served with a generous amount of very good quality corned beef. It was as good as any I've ever had - and I've eaten a lot of Ruebens over the years.

Love the setting. Good service though our attendant didn't have any help that I could see. Clam chowder didn't have much flavor. Hate to say it but trader joes is better