Jennifer P.
Yelp
My husband and I stopped here for a very late lunch on our way to Liverpool, Nova Scotia. Overall, the food was really good.
We got into Mahone Bay a bit later than planned due to construction on the 103, and we were scheduled to have dinner at my husband's uncle and aunt's place in Liverpool a few hours later, so we shared the Fish Tacos ($15.25) and a bowl of the soup of the day ($9) which was a pureed carrot, pear and beet soup.
There were 2 fish tacos per order, so we had one each. We opted for the cod, but the other option was haddock. I asked for the chipotle sauce on the side. The tacos also came with fries. The taco shell was a soft flour tortilla and the filling was some red cabbage slaw and fresh arugula along with a large piece of battered and deep-fried cod. The fish was delicious, really crispy on the outside, and soft and flakey on the inside. I liked the crunch of the slaw and the peppery zing of the arugula. I added the tiniest bit of chipotle sauce and it was perfect.
The fries were excellent. They were skin on and really crispy. Maybe a bit too salty, but otherwise great.
Unfortunately, I did not enjoy the soup at all, so my husband ended up having practically all of it. I didn't like the grittiness, which was probably due to the pears. I also felt that the flavours didn't go well together. However, my husband loved it, so it depends on your tastes.
Service was quick and efficient. We were surprised at how busy the restaurant was at 3pm on a weekday. I think everyone was a tourist like us though ;)
They sell ice cream too, but we didn't have any.
They only have 1 single unisex and accessible bathroom, so there was always a line up. I'm glad I wasn't sitting at the table right by the bathroom!
They have their own parking lot to the right and behind the restaurant but it was packed, not paved, and down a steep slope, so we ended up parking on the street (I think it was free, we didn't pay and didn't get ticketed, lol). FYI: The parking lot to the left which is paved, with painted lines, and looks very nice belongs to BMO, and is reserved for their customers only.
I love puns, so I was first drawn to this restaurant because of the name, but I ended up really enjoying the fish tacos. The soup was not to my liking, but I'd say that's due to personal preferences, because the hubby loved it.
Mahone Bay is super touristy, so it was much busier than I expected for a small town. We were lucky to find street parking across the street, but I can see how parking can be tricky during high tourist season. We were there mid-July. Also, there were a lot of people just milling about, talking and/or eating ice cream on the streets, completely oblivious to cars trying to get by. This is obviously not the restaurant's fault, so this fact does not affect the rating, but I'm just writing it here, so you are aware of the possible terrain you will have to traverse to get to the restaurant, lol.