Craig B.
Yelp
"Appearances Are Deceiving"
When making lodging reservations two months in advance of a trip to Yellowstone, this was one of very few options left so I took it for our stay on the night of June 23, 2011. On Xanterra's website, the lodge looks very upscale and comfortable, and when we arrived it still looked that way, though a bit contrived in an attempt to fit in with the environment and other historic buildings in the area.
Check in was easy and fast, though it was immediately apparent that the building was a hot box, even in late June when the outside temperature tends to be moderate. The building was several degrees warmer than outside.
Our room on the second floor, 2014, was spacious, with an obstructed view of the geyser area (the lodge is set back a bit from it and ours was as good as the view gets). The lodge itself, as are all in Yellowstone, is run by Xanterra, and has no air conditioning, supposedly to keep in the spirit of the rustic park, no TVs, refrigerators that are unplugged upon arrival "to conserve energy" (translation: to pad profits), and all bathroom amenities boldly proclaim how good they and their packaging are for the environment (the Green Natura soap and shampoo were both excellent and I would actually purchase them for home use based on performance). I suppose that philosophy of environmental stewardship doesn't extend to the silly Keurig coffee maker with the one-serving coffee pods. To me, the environmental shtick seems meant more to impress than to actually help the environment.
On our stay, after dinner in the Old Faithful Lodge Dining Room and an evening viewing of Old Faithful and a walk around the geyser area, we returned to our room around 8:45 to be welcomed by extremely upstairs neighbors, who were stomping, running around (one would hope a kid was in their party), and dropping or throwing things on their floor. We endured it until 10 PM, when I called the front desk and spoke with K____ (Katie?), who told me she would send security to conduct a "courtesy check." I don't know if that actually happened or not, but the noise only got worse and I called the front desk again at 11. This time K___ exhaled a very loud sigh and in a sarcastic, world-weary voice told me she'd already sent security up once and would do so again, indicating that doing so was just to make me feel better. A few minutes later she called the room and told me that security was busy with another problem and it would be a while before someone could go back upstairs. I told her to have security come to my room to listen to what we were putting up with. Of course, that visit never happened and the noise continued until after midnight - and resumed promptly at 6:30 AM.
The Old Faithful Snow Lodge may have been built to impress, but it was also built on the cheap, as evidenced by the lack of soundproofing between the thin floors. If you dare to stay here, I recommend staying on the third (top) floor to avoid noise. If you have children, please stay on the ground floor for convenience and courtesy.
Would I stay here again? Perhaps, if no other lodging options were available. But if and when I return to Yellowstone I will (1) make my reservations much earlier for more lodging options, and (2) only stay on the top floor of any lodging I book.
Hopefully helpful hint: The Old Faithful area is a zoo - cars, RVs, and buses everywhere, as well as hoards of people. We found that visiting the geysers in the evening and early morning afforded a more peaceful experience than doing so when so many people were around the area.