Olde Waterville Pizza

First trip to Waterville Valley and the town/resort are absolute gems. Awesome trails and genuinely kind, knowledgeable staff everywhere. After skiing I was craving a sandwich and a slice, so I hit Olde Waterville Pizza. As a longtime vegetarian, my options at most pizza places are basically pizza or an eggplant/veggie sandwich, so seeing mock meat options on the menu absolutely made my night. The veggie chicken parm sandwich was honestly the best I’ve ever had, and the pizza was delicious too (jalapeño poppers and fries also didn’t last long… skiing does that). Pickup was quick and easy, the place is super charming, and it fits the Town Square vibe perfectly. Kudos to Bill and the team for a great meal and for giving vegetarians real options. TAKE MY MONEY!

I've eaten there a few times, it's pretty standard fare, but wow, the pork taco that's on the menu right now (can't find it on any of their menus online) is unreal it's gotta be the best taco I've ever had. The lime creme (like hint of lime thin sour cream) was so good and whatever the sauce was. The pork was super tender and juicy. Got it take away and ate it back at our campsite near by. I need to know the ingredients in the other sauces! Was it a type of slaw? I'm obsessed and need to have them again soon.

I’ve been coming to Olde Waterville Pizza for a couple of years now, and it’s easily one of my go-to spots in town. On our most recent visit we had the Buffalo wings, smashed burger, fries, and a Buffalo chicken sandwich — everything came out hot, flavorful, and perfectly cooked. The fries were fresh and crispy, just how they should be, and the wings had that perfect balance of spice and flavor. The burger was juicy and well-seasoned, and the Buffalo chicken sandwich had a great kick without being overpowering. Wait time was about average, but definitely worth it. The food always tastes best when you eat in rather than take out — you get that fresh-off-the-grill quality and a relaxed local vibe that’s hard to beat. After many visits over the last two years, I can honestly say Olde Waterville Pizza is consistently great. Highly recommend if you’re in the area and craving solid comfort food done right.

Stopped by for dinner with 2 kids. The place appeared busy. The lady behind the counter suggested we order to go and wasn't friendly nor welcoming. We asked if we can wait for the next available table, she agreed but wouldn't assist when one became available and someone else took it who didn't even wait in line saying that at this restaurant the customer is responsible for securing his own table which is absurd. We didn't want to argue with the other party so we just left.

The chicken parm sandwich was definitely a frozen patty. I couldn’t finish it. I will say that the people that work there are very nice and the atmosphere was great, they really need to work on their food, though.

Pizza is almost always cold when you pick it up. Ordered again while up here and picked up before the estimated time and the pizza was cold and so are the mozzarella sticks . Place is so expensive too for basically microwaved food

We got takeout but the place seemed really nice. It was a little tricky finding them once I parked but the food came out right as I got to the cashier so it all worked out great. Everyone loved the pizza.

Came in for lunch, but did not want a whole pizza... They sell by the slice! Cozy and warm! And a good selection of draft craft beer.