Michael S.
Yelp
We've been in Merida for five nights so far, and have eaten at Oliva twice already--with more to come. A year or so after our first visits, I'm happy to say that we've observed or tasted no diminution in quality of food or service. In fact, it seems to me that Oliva has gotten better since we last visited.
In every way, our food has been superb. While the menu hasn't changed substantially -- a limited number of crudos and hot and cold appetizers; about nine pastas; a risotto; and about a half dozen primis. If anything, the quality is even better than before.
On our first visit this year, I ordered a salad with beets, tomatoes, and cucumbers. It consisted of small, steamed beets; a variety of small tomatoes, halved; and small chunks of cucumber, all absolutely fresh, lightly dressed, and plated beautifully. A taste of summer, which is only a dream for us at home as I write this. This lovely salad was followed by cacio e pepe, which would not have been out of place on the table of a restaurant in Rome.
Last night my wife and I had salads and shared four appetizers: lightly fried (and delicious) calamari; octopus; a crudo; and polpettone. The food was all well-prepared -- and the polpettone in particular, tender and just lightly kissed with orange -- were wonderful. But what impressed me the most was the pacing: the dishes came up in pairs, not all at once, so we really could focus on enjoying the dishes. Just an example of how someone is paying attention to the food and to the experience of Oliva's guests.
Oh--and the panna cotta is still great. Just as I remember it.
The mix of guests is nice: some locals, both Mexicans and gingos, and tourists, again both Mexicans and gringos. The staff is excellent, friendly, and accommodating.
Hands-down my favorite place in Merida.