Brian W.
Yelp
We dine out quite often, having relocated from Manhattan, basically not a food group or type that we have not experienced, and have tried restaurants across the food type and price point spectrum from small suspect "holes in the wall" that ended up being spectacular finds" to some crazy price point restaurants that we'd never dine at again. Attention to detail from the moment the dining experience starts until leaving is key to us, and meal is just 50% of the dining equation.
First time, made reservation via Open Table following an unsuccessful bid on the phone direct.
Arrived on time, taken to our table, one among a wall of many open tables. However, this specific table was just outside the kitchen. Meaning, high traffic area and one of us would be facing the kitchen (swinging bar saloon type door). Asked to be moved to one of the other many empty tables for 2, and what should have been a quick hostess empowered decision became a lengthy wait as we stood. Told they needed to speak with the manager. Okay, what were we do other than possibly leave, which was our option of course. Finally the hostess came back, told us the he hardship making the change--- TMI, not interested. Was I supposed to be grateful???? After the story telling which had me still wondering our fate, she told us they'd accommodate the table change request.
Now seated at a much better, more enjoyable location, the hostess came to the table and thanked her and engaged her with a question on the menu as it was our first time. Nery, our server for the evening came next, we started to ask both food and wine questions.
We asked for a taste of a red (don't recall the wine), unfortunately the wine had separated and spoiled, so we sent that bottle away and asked if they'd open another which they did. While waiting for Nery to return I could see the head bartender pouring and smelling and looking at the bottle we just turned back, he was shaking his head to his colleagues "yes" and put poured the glass out... didn't even need to taste it and he knew. Not surprisingly the second bottle of the same wine was also spoiled..... so important that wines are stored in proper temperatures/conditions. Send that back and asked for the Querciolina Montecuco a Sangiovese, this was fresh, had the expected flavor and body.
During this time a serving of fresh bread and humus was brought to the table, lovely presentation but the bread was cold. That humus was fantastic, would have been a better complement had the bread been warm.
After some more Q&A with Nery we ordered the Roasted Squash Soup with Andouille which they split into two for us to share. We love squash soups, this was one if not the top tasting ones to date. The andouille gave the soup that much needed accent to complement the squash flavor. From an aesthetics perspective, was beautiful presentation as well.
After some final pondering, I ordered the organic salmon with sautéed spinach, roasted squash & cippolini onions..... first off, again a beautifully plated presentation, the aroma was fantastic as was the meal itself. I've never had salmon complemented with squash prepared like this before. Their preparation was fabulous... my only (personal critique-- would have liked a bit more of the squash as I coupled it with each bite of fish; finished the squash before finishing the fish). The fish was plated atop steamed spinach which was so fresh. Again was a fabulous meal. (see photo of my dish)
My wife ordered the beef bourguignon, she said the meet was extremely tender, the mix of ingredients as fresh as could be. She loved her dish all but one key aspect, the sauce that it was in. She felt the sauce fell flat, too light, didn't complement the short rib as she would have expected or liked. It is winter, the dish is a very heavy dish and you'd expect the sauce to dazzle the meat. (Dancing with a partner that doesn't have the suave moves)
We passed on dessert as we were full.
We discussed our experience on the way home and agreed we'd try One 53 again after another trip to the area. I rate it a 3 upon this trip for the reasons detailed. Should our next experience surpass this one, I will of course update with a follow up review at such time.