Paddy's Loft

Stumbled upon this spot in Massapequa to grab a quick drink and a crisp glass of beer. My server Andrew was very attentive, nice, and provided great service. He was knowledgeable about the menu and answered all our questions. The Reuben was my favorite menu item. It came out hot and the meat was cooked very well. There’s a reason this place holds the #1 Guinness pour. The Guinness was creamy and transported me back to Ireland.

Great local, irish cottage pub that features some rather good food and drinks. Been here a few times and always pleased with everything. The French onion soup aswell as the potato soup is very good. Their wings and burgers are also very good, as is the Ruben. They have a bar side and a restaurant side, both of which is nice. The service has always been fast and friendly.

We had my father's celebration of life lunch here after his funeral in early January 2026. The process of picking the menu was simple and June was very helpful. We opted for the buffet lunch The staff was excellent and June kept the lunch moving along at a nice pace without rushing anyone and addressed our needs well. It was a 3 hour event and the price per person made this a great value. Everyone enjoyed the excellent food quality and atmosphere of this cozy warm restaurant. I would recommend Paddy's Loft for any get together or event.

Was there for the second time and wasn't disappointed. First had the Pretzel and it was accompanied by a tasty cheese sauce - was delish. For my main I had the Full Irish Breakfast and was semi-close to being in Ireland again. The only thing I was taken a little aback by was the music that was being played - American Country, but oh well.

Had lunch here with friends. Service was slow although place not crowded. Food tasted good but the burger which I ordered medium well was mostly raw. Guess I should have said well done. My friends ordered the loin of pork and seemed satisfied. The place is larger than it looks from outside and could accommodate a larger party.

We had 5:00 reservation.. was rushed through the whole dinner. Never got the bread like everyone else did. Understanding its new years but . asked several times. Got our food.. very good. Asking if we were done several times because they had lines waiting for tables. Never received the check as quick as we did.. then asked you dont want coffee do you.. really.. not my first time there.. this is the first time being treated like that.

Step dance on over to Paddy's Loft for delicious Irish fare as well as many time-honored favorites. Their corned beef and cabbage egg rolls are tasty. Their Shepherd's Pie is rich and the gravy and potatoes make this again a win-win for diners. Their salads are fresh, crisp, and beautifully plated. The fish is perfectly seasoned and seared. We each had doggy bags so the desert was skipped. Next time maybe we will start there and work our way back. The staff was pleasant and attentive.

I wanted a proper Irish meal for my birthday. Paddy's Loft definitely delivered with great food, service, and atmosphere. One daughter proclaimed her burger was one of the best she's ever had. The other said Paddy's has the best fried. They both loved the Irish Nachos, too. For me, the fish and chips was top notch; flaky, great batter, and fresh. For dessert, the blueberry bread pudding was so good! This is a restaurant I will return to many times over.

I had a celebration of life luncheon for more than eighty people. The food, beverages and service were outstanding. The comforting staff were wonderful. Thank you to June, Noel, Nora and the entire crew who worked so hard to make a tough day much easier. It was better then expected.

Great local, irish cottage pub that features some rather good food and drinks. Been here a few times and always pleased with everything. The French onion soup aswell as the potato soup is very good. Their wings and burgers are also very good, as is the Ruben. They have a bar side and a restaurant side, both of which is nice. The service has always been fast and friendly.

The food was very tasty! I ordered wonton soup a combination shrimp and lobster sauce and a large order of spare ribs. They are the best around!!! The soup was tasty with plenty of scallions. The shrimp were large and not over cooked. The spare ribs were cooked not burnt large and very tasty. HIGHLY RECOMMEND FOR TAKE OU

Tons of delicious and fun nights spent here. Cara, June, Theresa & Sully are the absolute best! We split a burger tonight with Swiss, fried egg, lettuce, tomato and onion. The fries are so so good here and can't be beat! I don't order burgers often but was in the mood for it tonight and was so so happy we got it. Delicious! We love the French onion soup, hot wing zings and fried pickles. We've enjoyed the pre-fixe dinners - I love loved the lamb. I tried my friend's salmon (pictured below) and my jaw dropped. The Reuben egg rolls are to die for, and the truffle fries someone else got smelled sooo good I can't wait to try next time! (This is really a few visits in one review but the food is awesome) must try place! Such a relaxing atmosphere with excellent service. Can't wait for our next visit! And I'll try to post more pics of the food next time.

Best pub food around! Love coming here with my girls and getting a french onion soup, a Guinness, and share a ton of apps. Cozy dining room for good times!

We really enjoyed our dinner tonight at Paddy's Loft. Great Irish music, amazing staff, delicious food and nice hospitality. Our server Megan was awesome! Highly recommend. Perfect local restaurant!

Wing Zings are fantastic. Paul is an excellent bartender. All of the staff are friendly.

I would just like to say how disgusted l am how me and my wife were treated tonight. I am a retired police chief, who is in a sling post surgery. i was waiting at a table to order dinner with my wife. The next thing i knew we were getting kicked out by someone with white hair- Not only were we verbally assaulted inside the restaurant by him, we were then followed into the parking lot by this man. We left the restaurant quietly after being asked to leave, although still confused. As we walked out quietly, we were followed out by a him. He was yelling verbal accusations at us as we walked away from the restaurant. I am disgusted I will be posting this on every social media outlet that you have! We were treated like common criminals. We did nothing wrong. Some Irish establishment! We are Irish and from a very big cop family!!!!!!! Please see other reviews he seems to have a history of this kind of conduct.

This was my first time trying Irish food. The interior was designed to be more of a homey feeling. The male host greeted us and was very friendly. I liked the jumbo pretzel as it wasn't overly seasoned with salt. The jalapeño poppers were pretty spicy, but it was okay. My partner ordered the shepherd's pie, which is considered a traditional Irish dish. It had a lot of flavor, trying it for the first time. We liked how comforting it tasted, but it was hot, so be careful when trying the first bite. As a main dish, I ordered the codfish with mash potato as a base. I loved how you can actually taste the fish for what it was and it wasn't over saturated with too much flavor that would disguise the natural taste. My main dish definitely exceeded my expectations. The desserts were huge. We felt stuffed at the end, but overall we had a great meal and experience!

Paddy's Loft -- never again. We've been loyal customers for years and have hosted multiple family parties here, but after our most recent experience, we will not be returning. We were seated by the bartender, placed our order, and had just taken a sip of our drinks when the owner abruptly told us he needed the table and that we had to move--without another table available. This came after we saw him arguing with another table that ended up leaving. When we explained we had already ordered, he became agitated and raised his voice. We chose to leave, and shockingly, he asked us to pay for drinks we barely touched. A simple apology and offering to pay for our drinks for the inconvenience would have changed everything. It's unfortunate, because the staff--especially June, the manager--works hard and knows how to treat customers. Unfortunately, we won't return to Paddy's Loft or Smugglers Jack's. Recommendations for a friendly spot near Seaford are welcome.

I've been going here for years, close to home and friendly staff. The Sheppards Pie is soo good. Anytime I'm in the mood for one, I either go in or have it delivered. A nice Irish Restaurant with a cozy feel at home feeling. I'd recommend this establishment and I'm definitely going back.

Great fish and chips! Nice atmosphere, clean restrooms and its own parking lot what more can you ask for. Service was a little slow but nothing bad.

Great place to meet and greet! We were a group of 10+ people and everything was great! Great atmosphere and the appetizers and drinks were also very good. The only negative was the parking situation.

The Guinness pour is spot on! The secret to this place is their Burgers, Best I've had on Long Island. Never had a bad meal here, but the Burgers are special. I like to cut my burger in half to make it easier to eat. The juices literally flew across the table when I did it, lesson learned now I cover it when I cut it

Very happy with the buffalo wings I ordered online. An order of wings is a 1 lb. and can range from 8-10 wings in a tin. Show up and go to the bar to pick up your order from the bartender. The wings are not breaded, and the mild wings were wet and had a little bit of kick which I loved! The mild really surprised me - I didn't even take pictures (my bad). I will be ordering again. Good: -Mild Buffalo Wings -Garlic Parmesan Wings Bad: -None

First time at The Paddy Loft. Food was excellent. Prices were reasonable. And staff and owner really terrific!

They are so professional. They one best Shepherd pie. There service great. They have two prices on there menu one of paying by cash and one paying by credit card.

We had a fabulous meal at Paddy's Loft. The fixed meal was excellent!! Prime Rib w mashed potatoes broccoli stuffed mushrooms & salad & cheese cake for dessert. Kelly is quite a treat as our waitress. She's the best!!

Food was cold and salty: since they changed everything, food not the same, used to be very good

Have been to Paddy's Loft a few times. It's a nice cozy Irish pub with delicious food. Order the wonderful potato soup. Service has been good. Very pleased overall. Highly recommend.

It's a great local Irish pub! I went there week before St. paddy's and it did not disappoint. I had the fish sandwich and it was DELISH!!! Service was great and I sat in the bar area which was a vibe. Def GO!

I never received any free meals as compensation; I had to use Grubhub because Paddy's Loft doesn't do delivery itself; regardless, what I got from delivery to wrong delivery address certainly wasn't worth the money and again I stand by my assessment of their corned beef and cabbage! I'm 76 years old and only moved to massapequa less than a month ago! nothing more to say!!

Where to begin, we were a party of almost 40 we were seated in the room in the back which is delightful To start the owner Noel Took care of our reservations for 40 People with care and our servers were excellent! We had 30 Adults and 10 children ages from 5 to 16! Everyone had a variety of foods, most of the adults had corn beef dinners, rubens all excellent! Love Paddy's Loft and the sister restaurant Smugglers Jack! Both places have excellent service and excellent food! TY again for a wonderful cousins brunch

Ok..I was there 2 months ago and it was great. However, I was there on Sunday. Not good..I ordered the Irish Breakfast.. The only thing that was hot were the sausages..which were actually pretty good..the rest of it was cold..everything served on a cold plate. Total joke..I'll never go back there again.

I loved paddy's loft the service was great and the food was cooked perfectly I got the boneless chicken wing with blue cheese and my mom got Guinness and she said it is the best in Long Island. The decor was beautiful an every time I ran out of blue cheese the server's were so fast to ask and get more. I recommend this place if you are Irish like me and you want some good Irish food or if you just want to try Irish food this place is amazing and I definitely recommend this place

Yelp send me an email I told them I didn't think it was right to call me fat he's lucky he didnt do it to my friend who just had surgery to reduce his weight

My family and I came here to celebrate my nephew's birthday. We opted for the Restaurant Week menu and had a fabulous time! Our server's name was Margaret. She did not miss a beat and provided excellent service. The ambiance was so quaint and tranquil. They played authentic Irish music and the decor was very cozy. We were served warm Irish Soda bread and rolls with butter. The Irish Soda bread was delicious, to say the least. Next came the soup. Half of us ordered the onion soup which had gobs of mozzarella oozing all over. They loved it! I ordered the Irish Potato Soup. I think I could have ordered a large soup and called it a day. It was absolutely mouth watering. Very savory and had so much bacon in it. It was very well made. Next came the entrees. We ordered the roast beef platter. I ordered the meatloaf. The gravy was perfect and had a nice consistency. Extra gravy was brought out for the creamy mashed potatoes. They were good! They also served buttery sweet carrots and broccoli. The whole meal was so satisfying, especially on a drizzly cold Saturday. Dessert consisted of a brownie or rice pudding. They were homemade and of course, delicious. Overall, this place is the next best thing to eating at home. There is even a back room for parties. I really enjoyed everything about my dining experience. Parking is limited in the front but plenty in the back. I will be back. This place is a hidden gem!

Live in the area and never go here, but last night was so nice. Our Irish waiter was friendly, lovely, grand, and a class act! He made sure we had all we needed and the food was great. Will be coming back.

On Saturday August the 9th , at approximately 3:30, I arrived at Paddys Loft with my wheelchair bound boyfriend. Prior to our arrival I had called and asked if the restaurant was wheelchair accessible . I was told that there was a door that would allow ground floor entry into the dining area .​ Upon our arrival, We rang the bell numerous times to gain entry thru this door. Finally a waiter opened the door and let us in. we sat at a booth and ordered 2 Iced teas. My boyfriend needed to use the bathroom so I asked the waiter if there was one on that level and he stated there was not . I requested that he activate the lift to access the bathroom on the main floor and he then told me the lift was not working ​. He offered to help my boyfriend up the steps but that was not feasible as he is a recent amputee and cannot navigate steps . At that point we decided to leave the restaurant. This restaurant is not fully compatible for handicap people.

Random find while hungry in massapequa. Reviews looked good & my SO & I were in the mood for some bar food. Classic American Irish Bar layout inside. We came thru their rare entrance which lead us to the bar area & not the actual dine in area. Which was fine by us. We were greeted by the bartender (nice guy) & then shortly after the waitress came & gave us menus. Loved the ambience of the bar. It was well kept. Cleanliness was well above. Decor was fitting & plenty of spirits to choose from. I ordered the shepherds pie & my SO got the Irish breakfast. Waitress recommended these & we were not disappointed. Appetizer: Irish Spring Rolls - just get it. Cabbage & Corned beef inside a spring roll pastry. Yum! Shepherds Pie: Looked exactly as advertised! Beautiful Crust on the Mashed Potatoes. The Guinness sauce was delicious. The ground beef was seasoned well. I was overly joyed! A top 1 contender for any shepherds pie I've had. It was not overly rich & more than enough to fill you up. I devoured it all! Irish Breakfast: This was a huge plate & it came with fries! Those were so tasty - crispy & moist on the inside. A beautiful baked tomato. The Black Puddin' was yummy! The white was good. The sausage were good but a bit rich. Beans were delish. My wife was extremely happy with this dish. Drinks. Standard bar things. Ordered a Stella & Magners Cider. My SO ordered Tea & she said it was up to par(she's a tea snob) Parking: there's a decent amount. Side Note: on this day they got slammed with a huge party. Looked like 20+ people at like 12pm. They handled it well. Our food & drinks came promptly. We were never neglected. Props to the 2 waitress & bartender. Will be back!

We came here last Sunday because our daughter was at the skating rink next-door. This was our first visit here . The menu was extensive, and one thing stood out . After asking what the black and white pudding was found out that it was a sausage. With that information, we ordered the Irish breakfast . The presentation was beautiful and the portion was large Delicious delicious. Delicious. Our waitress checked in on us regularly, and we felt like this was outstanding place to just unwind and enjoy. Would definitely drive 30 minutes and come here again to try out the rest of the menu .

If a locally owned place could be run by a chain, this would be it. No buybacks. Nothing special on the menu. Prices just a bit higher than they should be. Like a number of places, some like the place. I didn't.

Food was very good , service was slow , not to many people when we were there . Was there on Sunday around 630 and we were the second table , took 10 minutes to for someone to come and get our drink order, and also our app order , had the booth set up for 2 , we were four, never gave us any setups had to ask twice for knives and fork. I never bash a place for food , everything we ate was great

Great time! Had a seat at the bar and the bartenders Paulie and Colleen were great!! Great service. Food was delicious. Had the chicken tidbits as well as meatball special and soup special. All amazing. 5/5!

The food is always great and the people are wonderful. The bar area is really beautiful and the bartenders are good fun.

I had my daughter's Bridal Shower in the private room. The staff was attentive and lovely. The room was charming. The food was delicious, and everybody had a great time. It was also very reasonably priced. I will come back for my daughter's baby shower (someday) and just for dinner.

I have dined in Paddys Loft in the past for years, havent been there in a lonnnnnng time so I decided to stop in with my kids. We ordered wings, they were undercooked so my Sons was sent back and some others came out, the nerve to even charge me for undercooked wings I couldn't even finish my wings, let alone you get 8 wings for $14. The waiter tells us 25% was taken off the bill. 1 word Horrible experience for such a nice place and come to find out Noel the owner was out sick, no wonder such slack on the food.

Paddy's is always consistent. Good food , good drink, clean. Hard to ask for more . Been going for many, many years. Will be going for many more.

Best corn beef in town! Honestly I would recommend anything off the menu. Drinks are nice pour always. We also have had private parties in their back room. If you haven't gone it is a must try.

We had brunch there today and it was for a 75th birthday party and the food and service was nothing but Great - the price was great - I had the chicken Killarney and it was to die for - we live out East and was well worth a trip. I will return there. Nothing but great things.

Wonderful food ,atmosphere., Fantastic staff& Owner.Paddy's Loft makes you feel as if you're at a friendly pub restaurant in Ireland

Amazing food, great service, friendly staff... definitely recommend to everyone. I've had them cater a few dinners as well and the pricing is fair as well. Always a big hit with guests too

Spent Christmas Eve with my family in Paddy's Loft. The service was great, the restaurant is beautifully decorated for the holidays. We were warmly welcomed by the owner. The menu is extensive, great variety and generous portions. Shepherds pie or Bangers and Mash are our favorites and delicious but everything looked and tasted great. Highly recommend.

Never had a bad meal, or bad service! My family and I have been going here for as long as I can recall. Let's just say there's a table with my families name on it (not really but that would be nice!) every year gift cards are given out for the holidays and Paddy's loft is on the list! This year I bought it so looking forward to updating some new pics and reviews soon!

Went to a wake last night at a nearby funeral home and ended up here afterwards to commiserate with a fellow mourner. I had an order of wings (dry, with the sauce on the side) and a pint (or three) of Guinness. Both (or all four) were on point.

Great place for corn beef and Irish food love the service and people that run place great place for parties

Thankful that Paddy's Loft offered curb side pick up for St. Patrick's Day during these hard quarantined times! Phew! We got the soft pretzel and it came in a huge tin which was awesome by itself. But tasting the pretzel - we were WOWed. I have to say it was the best pretzel appetizer I've ever had from a bar. The chicken pot pie was really good too. Flaky crust but the chicken pieces were a little too big for me. My mom loved the Ruben and my dad said the shepherds pie was delicious too!

We stopped in for a late lunch/early dinner. My wife had the Reuben sandwich and I had the Angus beef one. Both were delicious. The service was excellent. She checked in several times to see if we needed anything and how our meals were.

Paddy's is still an old reliable for so many years now. And last evening Paddy's was a perfect choice for a table for two next to the fireplace. Service was perfect, Thank You AnnaLisa! I enjoyed the LI Duck, my other half enjoyed the Pork Ossobucco, both were perfectly prepared and delicious. We managed to have room to share a dessert, a warm brownie with ice cream, just enough to share. And I can't forget the perfectly made Irish Coffee, where else to have one besides Paddy's? Always a good choice, make reservations or arrive early, it does get crowded.