Panatieri's Pizza & Pasta- Bedminster

Ordered a whole plain pizza and 4 mixed slices to eat there. Pre-made slices were ready immediately, and the plain pizza came out in about 10 minutes later. This was on Superbowl Sunday. Pretty quick!! Pizza was made perfectly and delicious.

A Hidden Gem for Unique Pizza Lovers If you're looking for something out of the ordinary in the pizza world, Panatieri's is the place to be. They show their creativity and willingness to experiment with unique flavor combinations. From the mac and cheese pizza to the various vegetarian options, it's clear that Panatieri's isn't afraid to step outside the box. The quality of the ingredients and the presentation of the pizzas look top-notch. If you're in the area and looking for a memorable pizza experience, I highly recommend giving Panatieri's a try. Just be prepared to step outside your comfort zone and explore some exciting new flavors!

I had made a mistake ordering on doordash and had no option to change my order to a delivery. The guys were really understanding and helped to cancel my order when I called so I can reorder it correctly! Great pizza of course, but very thankful they helped correct my order

Great pizza, I got the sausage slice and mushroom slice, both equally great. amazing service as well as being very friendly. I also got the chicken picatta last week, which was very good as well. they deserve 5 stars all down the line.

I have tested them! About 15 times in 2 months lol. Food is average. My issue is pricing. They do not follow any of their posted prices. Last week a 1 topping was 23.00.. Yesterday 11/24/25 was 26.15 cash.

Love this place. Traveling from West Virginia to New York and we wanted pasta and this place came up. Really nice people, very clean and great prices. Big portions for the price.

Paid 26.00 for a Jersey Pie that I asked for it to be well done. I get the pizza home and it's a pile of mush barely cooked. I called up and told them and I get no response. I have eaten here in the past but never again.

Love their elote pizza! Everything else is good too but you hav3 to try elote pizza if you want the flavor bomb