Park Street Pizza

Stopped by for an early dinner on Memorial Day. Overall not a bad experience. The best part was the pizza, it was loaded, tasted great and had some leftover to snack in later. The second best part is we didn’t even need to be hungry when we got there, since the wait was so long, we were starving by the time it showed up. We ordered 2 small pizzas at the register and were given a number. First one came about 37 minutes in and second one an impressive 50 minutes later. That in and of itself was inconvenient, but you pay upfront and they have the audacity to recommend a 15-25% tip at the time of purchase. Overall the place is cozy with a modern feel and the staff were friendly. Would go again if I’m in the area (mainly become they seem to be the only ones open Sunday), but I’ll probably be ordering ahead next time.

I had multiple friends tell me to check this place out and am so glad we finally got to because this is probably the best pizza we've ever ate. The crust is so soft and airy, and sauce is very unique tasting, and the cheese just tops it off to make it the perfect pizza! The cheese bread is absolutely amazing as well. The wait was a little bit but to be expected for great pizza. Nice place with very friendly staff. We can't wait to go again next time we're in the Sugarcreek area!

This was some of the best pizza I have had in years. I would highly recommend as well as I would go back for sure. The pizza sauce is extremely good as well as the overall pizza. Price was right as well. Very clean.

We discovered this place on a recent trip. It was our first time here and it will not be our last. We ordered a Farmhouse salad, an order of Southwest Rolls, and a Cowboy Chicken pizza. Every bit of it was delicious! From placing our order over the phone to picking up our order, every single staff member we encountered was friendly and helpful. If you're in the mood for some delicious pizza, this is the place. Go check it out. It's worth the trip!

Came here after it was recommended and I know why now! The whole vibe of the restaurant is just cool. The pizza was delicious, my son ate 4 slices! 🍕 The cheesy bread was really good too. You could just tell the pizza is made fresh. We will definitely be returning!

Great Italian food in the heart of Amish country! We were told all the ingredients were local and we could tell, the cheese and pesto were amazing! Great environment and service. Very popular place for a Sunday night.

We come here often and I have literally never been disappointed. The food is amazing and fun always consistent, wait time isn’t long, staff are always friendly, high quality local ingredients, atmosphere is wonderful, very family friendly. I love that they offer plenty of outdoor seating as well as indoor. The pizza is some of the best, but also the wings and salads are fantastic. They also offer local made dessert that are great. I recommend this place to everyone.

We waited literally 45 minutes for 2 small pizzas to come out on a Wednesday evening. The pesto pizza was cold…it’s not a place i would want to come back to.

Excellent service, unhurried atmosphere, great veggie options, overall a fantastic experience. Definite must go if in the area. Well done Park Street Pizza!

Park Street is efficient. I walked into a long and wide waiting area to the registers where I was greeted by smiling and friendly staff against a backdrop of busy, hardworking staff making pizzas and other menu items. As I briefly observed the staff work as I placed my order they appeared to work well as a team, enjoy what they were doing, and efficient and orderly in their work. After I placed my order I was given a pager and cups with my drink order. One drink that is available for free that got me so excited is sparking water. On the drink counter there is a water/sparkling water dispenser that is free for patrons. They have booth and table seating. The wooden booths are oversized and very comfortable. The interior is a mix of industrial, modern, and country that is typical of the area. Light comes through the many windows on the wall and vaulted ceiling. Plenty of seating. Indoor seating can accommodate about 50 people and their patio seats around 60. Their largest table seats 6 but I imagine they would combine some tables if you had a larger party. I ordered a large Deluxe pizza. The crust light, airy, and crispy. The red sauce was sweet and mild. The cheese had a creamy taste and was stingy. It was delicious. I recommend it heartily.

Visiting the area for the weekend and had the opportunity to eat here. The pizza was great! We built our own with old world pep, sausage and mush. The place was hopping and was told it might be a 35 minute wait and it turned out to be much much shorter. Service at the counter was good and very friendly as well as helpful. Restaurant was clean and well kept. They actually kept tables clean too. Two unisex bathrooms bother my wife a little and I certainly prefer Pepsi product but neither is a show stopper. Would definitely come back here again.

Friendly staff and the rustic chicken pesto pizza is phenomenal, as are the boneless bbq wings.

Husband and I live around 2 hours away and while we don't make the drive just for food of any kind; we absolutely include Park Street Pizza in our list of stops when in the area! Great salads, great pizza! Good amount of seating inside and outside and adorable bathrooms.

Heard about all the hype in Berlin about this place and guess what...IT WAS SO GOOD! This was one of the best pizzas i've ever eaten. Customer service was great, even with the long line. If i'm ever in the area i will definitely be going back for round two!

Easy online ordering the pizza was fantastic. The wings were delicious. Highly recommend trying Park St., pizza.

Small family owned business that is environmentally friendly & uses local produce & cheese!! Pizza is the best around, they have vegetarian and gluten free options too! Service is always with a smile!

This was our 2nd visit to Park Street and it confirmed that you can absolutely find a top notch pizza shop right in the heart of Amish Country! Yelpers know best so trust them when they rate this place a 4.8! Everything about Park Street is high quality!! The staff is friendly and helpful & their service is 2nd to none!! The dining area is spotless! But the star of the show is the pizza, it's simply the best!! We will always make Park Street a must visit when we are in the area!

By far the best pizza, breadsticks and salads in the area. The service is impeccable on phone orders as well as in person. They have a beautiful dining area, which is always spotless! The kitchen is visible and just as neat and clean as the dining area. Employees are always dressed appropriately. Rating is definitely a 10+.

Pricey but worth it Very good quality, clean, awesome staff, and love option to split pizza ...even if little extra Love support of local farmers for fresh ingredients Excellent bathrooms

Food is always superb! Service excellent! Somewhat noisy during peak times, but that is because everyone loves the place!!

I basically never miss stopping here while on a visit to Amish country I take everyone and they all become fans Excellent salads and pizza. We tried the Brussel sprouts this time too and loved those as well. (Of course) Just found out you can get a take and bake! That's a game changer to taking pizza the hour home!

All time best pizza in the area! Never had a bad experience. The service is great and the food is always consistently amazing.

First time here. Wasn't expecting such a nice new well decorated building. Great parking & outdoor seating. We loved everything about the place and the food! Service was very friendly and helpful. We had the deluxe pizza, pepperoni pizza, and mozzarella sticks.

Very nice atmosphere. I loved the decor and look of the interior and exterior. The open kitchen concept was nice. The staff was very welcoming, helpful and friendly! The staff works so well together. They are like a well oiled machine. The food was wonderful! I had a salad and my hubby had wings to start. The wings were pretty amazing! The salad was good and fresh. We then had the pepperoni pizza. Oh my goodness! It checked all the boxes. The sauce is so good. We went on a Saturday at 5 pm. It was pretty busy. We did wait about 45 minutes for a table. It was worth the wait. Food didn't take that long. I would definitely go back when I'm in town.

The staff was friendly and the pizza was fantastic! We ordered the rustic chicken pizza and it was delicious. Will definitely come back whenever we are in the area.

Loved the pizza! Adorable little pizza shop too!! Stays open late!! That's a rare find around here!!

We stopped by here yesterday while in the area and it was truly amazing. The restaurant was clean, staff was friendly, and the food was amazing! We ordered two small pizzas (deluxe and modern Margherita) and we got bbq wings. Everything was so good. The deluxe had good quality toppings! The wings were seasoned well! I will also add the bathrooms were exceptionally nice and super clean. Always a plus for us when traveling and eating at new places with a toddler!

we have been coming to Park St., Pizza for several years when traveling to Ohio. I think they have the best pizza in the world. The toppings are always fresh and delicious. My order has always been ready at the exact time I asked. The staff is always friendly and courteous.

The food was amazing definitely fresh. Service was great. Staff was super friendly. I traveled from out of state and I would recommend everyone check this place out. Best salad me and my Wife had tasted like from our garden. The basil vinaigrette is so good. Pizza sauce is one of a kind.. Park pizza you all nailed it.. I would drive all the way from Indiana again just to eat at this restaurant.

Great Service. Great food. Very clean and friendly atmosphere. We will differntly be back .

Good pizza just wish they still delivered there wings are banging fr though and if you get a chance the seasonal item brussel sprouts delicious

First time here at Park Street after several recommendations as (best pizza around). We were not disappointed. The pizza was delicious, the salads fresh and delicious and the bread sticks buttery, cheesy and delicious. Park Street Pizza was well staffed and very busy for a Wednesday night. I liked the vib of the place. It had the look of a well taken care of pizza parlor, the feel of a place people wanted to be at. The staff was very accommodating which makes the patrons happy especially when the product they are consuming is so good. Give Park Street a try you won't be disappointed.

Best food and service. Worth the wait. Best ingredients are used. Always taste fresh. ..........................................................................................................................

Usually when we're down that way I only eat at Der Dutchman. This place was recommended to us by friends a few years ago and we finally tried it today. I've been missing out! The place was hopping on a Saturday afternoon. We got a table quickly and the food came out reasonably fast as well. Pizza, salad and breadsticks were great. We're in the area a few times per year and will be back for sure.

The only place we will get pizza when in the Sugarcreek, Walnut Creek, Berlin area. The pizza is amazing and staff is usually professional and clean. Very polite.

Food tasted fantastic. Got the veggie pizza and cheesy breadsticks. Best pizza I've ever had. Would definitely return.

Order gluten free Deluxe pizza and gluten free garlic bread. Very good! I've tried different gluten free and this is top notch!

This was our second time getting pizza from Park Street after the first visit my husband and I contemplated making a 3 hour trip just for pizza. It's delicious, the best pizza I've had in a very long time. We highly recommend trying their pizza and salads. Both are excellent! The service was great also.

This is the place to eat!! I am not a big pizza lover but I LOVE Park Street Pizza. I take the 40 minute drive to get their food whenever I get a chance. Their desserts are so delicious and their salads and sandwiches are always amazing. I recommend the margarita pizza and the heartbreak cake. Also anything on the menu with the hot honey is AWESOME!

Phenomenal house made gluten free crust! Tho medium, still plenty to feed two of us. Chicken bacon ranch recommended and did not disappoint! Outdoor seating on a lovely night just added to the experience.

This is such a great place. Our gluten free pizza was so good !! Great friendly service.

Excellent service! Extremely Clean! Fabulously Friendly! Perfect Primo Pepperoni Pizza!!!! Our first time in but not our last!

This is probably the best pizza I have had in a really long time. Came in to town for a weekend getaway. The owner of the place we stayed recommended Park Street pizza. They also have great flat bread subs. We even brought a pizza home, 3 hours away just so we could have some for the next day. Definitely recommend you swing by if you get a chance.

One of the best pizzas ever! Amazing sauce and so fresh!! Salad was amazing too! Wish we had one of these in my part of Texas!

Came to Amish Country on a Sunday evening. This was one of a few restaurants open on a Sunday. This pizza place was very busy, but service was fast and friendly. The pizza was extremely good and reasonably priced. As a pizza connoisseur I find that most locally owned pizza places provide a far better pizza than most pizza chains. It was definitely the case with this pizza. If you are ever in Ohio's Amish Country give this place a try. It is also only 5 minutes away from the World's Largest Cuckoo Clock.

The quality of their pizza is second to none. Top notch food with great customer service. Always a must when we visit Holmes County.

Delish! Friendly. Clean. We've visited twice and both times were very pleased with our experience.

Excellent margarita pizza!!!!! Service with a smile. They delivered quickly. Ambiance unknown.

We live about 1-1/2 hours away in Weirton WV but always stop at Park Street when we come up to Chestnut Ridge Sewing and actually plan our trip around stopping at Park Street. We always have a couple Park Street salads and breadsticks they are always perfect, we haven't been up for awhile and stopped in Saturday January 21st. As usual, the salads were perfect, but they don't have the honey vinaigrette anymore, it was my favorite, but worse they changed their breadsticks. They are not as thick or soft as they used to be but more of a crunchy and thinner dough. I ask about them changing the recipe and was told they switched from 16oz to 8oz of dough, completely changes them. We will definitely still come but we will have to find something new to go with our salads. Still love the place, my wife not so much.

I have had all items on the menu minus vegan options. These I can speak to flavorful l, fresh ingredients that make this product awesome. Go to pizza shop any time in area. Family members went to Amish community for weekend getaway and ate here both nights they were so impressed. Give it a try you will be satisfied with the quality and flavors. Salads are always great, look forward to seasonal offerings.

Awesome place to stop an get pizza. They have indoor and outdoor seating. The pizzas are all unique and freshly made. We got the deluxe and the BBQ chicken pizza. It was delish, hot and had extra to take home for left overs! The boneless garlic park wings were bomb. I'd eat those everyday if I could! Everyone was very nice and they had so many options to choose from. Even vegan pizzas! Every time an employee walked past they asked how everything was and smiled and made you feel like they really cared that your experience there was important to their business. So definitely stop in and eat this yummy food! Lot parking.

Always excellent food! Eaten there on visits home for about 8 years. Friendly staff and very clean.

First timer traveling in the area! This place was HIGHLY recommended. Absolutely delicious food!! Would recommend for anyone to try. Both Carry out & dine in options available!

I will never not eat here lol. Blessed to live nearby, I treat my family as the one meal per week i dont cook myself! In almost two decades, it's the only place in the area I've yet to tire of. I wanted to show my continued appreciation by leaving this review. They serve the BEST food prepared with so much care! It's more than an obsession for me, lol its love! And the atmosphere is welcoming with a team of the kindest people you could imagine. There is a reason this place is award winning and it's more than just great food... It has warmth and heart you will not find anywhere else! See ya next week! ~Forever a Parkstreeter

We drove to Amish Country Sunday afternoon to stay the night and spend Labor Day showing the kids around. Once we got checked in to the hotel in Walnut Creek, we ordered pizza from Park Street. I had read such great reviews and the menu looked great. We ordered a large half cheese/half pepperoni, bread sticks, small tomato, onion and spinach and the farmhouse salad. We had wanted to try the street corn salad! But they were sold out. Next time! The food was amazing!! $9 for the bread sticks was a steal. It was huge. The pizza was a more hand tossed crust, which we don't normally get. But we loved it. The tomatoes on the spinach, onion tomato pizza were multi colored and seemed really fresh. The salad also had different colored carrots which my kids loved. My wife picked up the order and said that the parking lot was full but they were still able to keep six feet distance and all were required to wear masks. We will for sure be coming back here every time we are in the area!

Probably my favorite all time pizza place. We come every time we visit this area. We are about three hours away and love to visit this area from time to time. Amazing, delicious, and high quality ingredients. No short cuts on the food quality and flavor here. Highly recommend!

It's been a few years since was over here and had Park St. It hasn't change a bit - still extremely good, and made with pride. Drove the mild distance from Berlin to Sugarcreek to get it. I don't think there is better pizza in the area, and if you visit, I highly recommend!