Paulie's Kitchen + Pizza

A good no-frill place for quick lunch grab. Free street parking in front and a few tables inside for dine-in. The deli now only offers sandwich and although service was a bit stiff, overall it was fine, and the sandwich is good value size and tasty. We ordered a mambo (chicken parm & fresh mozzarella on a toasted roll) and a chicken bacon sandwich with avocado (a la carte). Appreciate the cashier taking time to ask if we want more sauce, lettuce, tomato, etc to make sure they get our sandwich right vs assuming. Would come back again for lunch.

Please don’t trust this place. I ordered chicken and waffles, the chicken is re-heated or refried. And the waffles are not golden or brown. The waffle looks white. When I bit into it, and it’s it’s still cold and gewy. I called the restaurant, The lady had an attitude with me basically saying that she makes waffles more than 20 times a day, which has nothing to do with my waffle or chicken ordered I placed. On top of that, the restaurant had a different name on the DoorDash app compared to the true restaurant name which is Paulies kitchen on Tuckahoe Road in Yonkers, New York. I tried to avoid this place as much as possible, but I did not think they would be called tuckahoe bagels and Café as a disguise. I don’t recommend anyone to eat at this nasty place. The food quality is poor, which is again the reason why I do not go to this place, but I was tricked because they changed their name on DoorDash.

This place is awful. I ordered delivery from Uber and the restaurant delivers its own food and they delivered the food to the WRONG apartment in a locked area we don’t have access to. They deliver their food themselves not through the app so the delivery guy left the food texted me a picture and took off. The restaurant wouldn’t redeliver me the food and I have to wait for a refund because Uber eats just takes the payment and isn’t responsible for the delivery itself.

Ordered breakfast here from door dash. It was amazing! Had the Nutella pancakes and chorizo sandwiches. So yummy

My first slice flying into NY. Let me tell you, these slices were amazing. The place is very clean and great food. We will be coming back.

I order from Paulie’s all the time and it’s always amazing!! The service is wonderful as well. I accidentally placed an order for pickup and they delivered it to me anyway when I called. Lovely staff and great food. Highly recommend!!!

First time ordering from here. I got the chipotle chicken wrap and french fries. The wrap was delicious, the french fries were amazing and properly salted and they poked a hole in the cap to let the steam out during delivery so that they didn’t arrive soggy and gross… smartest people ever for doing that. The pizza looks really good in the pictures I’ll be definitely trying that next.

Hands down the best place for food. Flavorful, fresh, hot (unless the delivery driver from Uber or whoever delivers takes forever, then it might be room temperature 🙄) but the service is amazing and the chef is great. They are so kind and accommodating. So damn delicious every time literally anything I’ve gotten. Just order, for real.

I've ordered here several times since they've opened and it's a very hit or miss place. Either the food will be GREAT or pretty bland/mediocre. Initially when I first discovered them (around their opening) they were AMAZING. Like they immediately became my go-to deli. As time has gone on, the quality has dwindled; Portions inconsistent, missing add-ons, not reading instructions. It's almost as if there's two cooks; one that actually cares and one that does the bare minimum and doesn't read or follow directions. I've literally tried almost the entire menu. The sandwiches and the pizza are the most consistent or at least relatively consistent. Breakfast & Dinner are the unpredictable wild cards. You can order the same breakfast sandwich 3 times and you will get it in 3 different ways lol.

Oh MY GOD!!! This pizza is freaking AMAZING!!!!! I am a pizza connoisseur. I can literally live off this pizza Bc it's so damn good. I have tried basically every Italian pizza joint Yonkers has to offer. From Dunwoodie, to the Pizza Place, Pizza Barn, Giovanni's. You get the drift, and this is HANDS DOWN. THEE BEST PIZZA IN YONKERS!!!!!

Ordered food online. It never came. When I called the restaurant for assistance they ignored me. total scam.

placed order and never received food after waiting for 2 hours. owner said they don't have a driver and told me to call another number which did not answer. canceled order and trying to get refund. bad experience!

Oh my goodness! We stopped in Yonkers in the middle of a road trip. We were tired and not too picky so we just hopped on Door Dash and found Paulie's. This restaurant blew my expectations out of the water! The Margherita pizza was one of the absolute best I've had (and I've been to the restaurant in Naples that invented it)! Penne a la Vodka was also solid. Huge portions for the price as well. This is one of the best unexpected finds I've had on a road trip.

Ordered avocado toast for breakfast one day- this place is on point!! Crispy marbled rye topped with avocado smash that is super flavorful, topped off with pea shoots and sea salt - wow! So good! Can't wait to try their other items!!