Peggy Sue's Maui

We wanted something quick and simple. I had a pineapple milkshake which was the best milkshake I have ever had hands down. And the two young men serving is were so polite and pleasant. Food came out really quick, less than 15 min. I will be back to try another milkshake before I leave the island.

The food was amazing, expensive but large portions. Service was excellent, and we enjoyed the music and atmosphere.

I checked the online menu and noticed that they had a cup of chili for $5.99. being a chilli lover, I stopped in for a cup to go. I get there and now they are charging 9.99 so with tax came to roughly $12.00 for a cup of chilli. That's equivalent to $2.00 a bite. I had to ask for a spoon and it didn't even come with crackers. After I ate it I went back on to let them know about error on their website. Very overpriced for a small cup of chilli that was about a 5 on a scale of 1-10. She didn't offer a partial refund. On top of that the place looks really ran down and a bit dirty. I won't be back

Ordered the Good Golly Miss Molly burger on a gluten free bun. The gluten free bun had good texture and was not dry. The patty seemed a bit dry. The sandwich overall was mehhh. I’ve had better for a cheaper price elsewhere. Cute atmosphere. I had heard Steven Tyler is a regular customer at Peggy Sue’s, which is half the reason why I visited.

Peggy Sues is the best restaurant I've ever been to. Everything was perfect, from the old fashion to the food. The burgers are big and delicious, making them hard to finish in one sitting, but that's great because you can take the leftovers home. The fries are superb and honestly, I can't think of a single flaw. My grandparents renewed their wedding vows, and the restaurant gave us a free sundae to celebrate. If I could give a better rating than 5 stars, I absolutely would.

I've eaten here three times already... I can honestly say that the burgers and shakes tasted better each time I came... If you're from Maui, then you know... But if you're visiting, Peggy Sue's is a must... Stay safe and blessed everyone... 🤙🏾🤙🏾🤙🏾

Stopped by around 7:00 for burgers and a shake with my wife. Great service. Delicious milkshakes and big burgers. I was barely able to finish my burger and the shakes come with the extra bit that gives you a little more when you think you are done. My wife even wanted to use a restroom to wash her hands but in the absence of a restroom the manager provided a warm wet hand towel for her. Would recommend!

Food was good diner food. Burger freshly made from local beef. The peanut butter banana milkshake was amazing. Sweet potato fries were good. Very friendly server, and fast. Nostalgic diner look, but needs a little tlc.