Peggy Sue's Maui

Ordered the Good Golly Miss Molly burger on a gluten free bun. The gluten free bun had good texture and was not dry. The patty seemed a bit dry. The sandwich overall was mehhh. I’ve had better for a cheaper price elsewhere. Cute atmosphere. I had heard Steven Tyler is a regular customer at Peggy Sue’s, which is half the reason why I visited.

I’ve come to Peggy Sue’s quite a few times over the years. My first impression after not being there in a while was this place looks really rundown. Although, the servers are always polite and welcoming. However, there’s a miscommunication between them and their cooks. I have a specific allergy that I make very clear to them every time I go. Quite a few times I have gotten my food back with the seasoning that I requested not be put on my food due to the fact that it makes me ill. Furthermore, their sign in their door doesn’t match the price at the register which I find a bait and switch. I requested my onions to be grilled, but they tried to charge me $2 more dollars for that. The server gave me the wrong drink, but luckily caught it in time. She didn’t check my food to make sure my allergy was taken care of. Lastly, the quality of the food just wasn’t great. My burger was soggy, my tomatoes were overly ripe, and my fries overly seasoned with garlic. I didn’t even finish my meal.

I've eaten here three times already... I can honestly say that the burgers and shakes tasted better each time I came... If you're from Maui, then you know... But if you're visiting, Peggy Sue's is a must... Stay safe and blessed everyone... 🤙🏾🤙🏾🤙🏾

Went there just to get ice cream and very friendly staff gave us multiple samples. Ice cream was really good and the coconut is a must. A good place to go and cool looking retro diner!

I ordered the fish mahi burger / sandwich. They said it was a mahi filet more like a fish stick in the middle of a bun … taste was horrible worse then it looked. Would not recommend my daughter said the hot dog was burnt and nasty didn’t finish it. Sad effort from the chef.

The table I sat at was kind of wobbly while I waited for my food and during my meal. I liked the portion sizes, but the meat on my burger lacked flavor and was a bit dry. The onion rings were really nice and crispy, but they still lacked flavor. The texture was good, though the batter could use more seasoning, and some of the rings were definitely overcooked.

I’m not big on burgers because to me, they all taste the same. But I have to admit, the burgers here were delicious! The fries were hot and extra crispy and the milkshakes were yummy! The ranch was okay but the fries were good enough without them. I loved the old fashioned diner theme and the music playing was great! Our server was very friendly as well. Great place to stop by

Peggy Sues is the best restaurant I've ever been to. Everything was perfect, from the old fashion to the food. The burgers are big and delicious, making them hard to finish in one sitting, but that's great because you can take the leftovers home. The fries are superb and honestly, I can't think of a single flaw. My grandparents renewed their wedding vows, and the restaurant gave us a free sundae to celebrate. If I could give a better rating than 5 stars, I absolutely would.