Peggy Sue's Maui

Got the “Good Vibrations” burger with the veggie patty for an extra two dollars. You can substitute a vegetarian patty for any of their burgers which is really nice. The burger was absolutely amazing and really big, and came with fries that were also perfect. You can tell it was made fresh and care was put into the quality. Also, the milkshakes are great and come with 2-3 full glasses worth. Server was super friendly and helped us with the vegetarian options and just added to the good atmosphere there. I don’t leave a lot of reviews but this place is perfect in atmosphere, taste, quality, service, and value (for Hawaii).

Alex is a grill master back there whipping up this very delicious, ‘Great Balls of Fire,’ burger. Already my jewels are on fire just from eating one grilled jalapeño. Katherine is the sweetest server and very easy on the eyes.😇 She is like a professional sky flying milkshake maker.

The burgers were huge and delicious, the onions rings and fries were amazing. Customer service was very good 👍

Food was good diner food. Burger freshly made from local beef. The peanut butter banana milkshake was amazing. Sweet potato fries were good. Very friendly server, and fast. Nostalgic diner look, but needs a little tlc.

Hidden gem in Kihei! Great food! So so ono! Fast, friendly servers. Took my family for dinner. Got there during their happy hour, the prices are unbeatable for the quality and taste! Milkshakes are delicious!

Very good food, milkshakes were top notch. Burger so big it almost killed Kalyn.

Best burger on Maui! The diner has an old 70’s look with (not functioning) jukeboxes, neon pink and blue decor, crossover with tropical details like fans and natural light ceiling. They use grassfed beef patties which you can see the difference from other burger places. Thick, juicy and tender. Many flavors to choose from, and named after famous old songs - a fun twist. You can ask for extra crispy fries! Their milkshakes are also amazing, but filling and a whole meal by itself. One downside is it can be very pricey. But if you’re a burger fan you can’t miss it.

The Milkshakes are amazing, the atmosphere is great, and Pablo has to be one coolest guys I've met in Maui. Favorite restaurant by far.