Pels Pie Co.

Cafe · Prospect-Lefferts Gardens

Pels Pie Co.

Cafe · Prospect-Lefferts Gardens

4

446 Rogers Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11225

Photos

Pels Pie Co. by null
Pels Pie Co. by null
Pels Pie Co. by null
Pels Pie Co. by null
Pels Pie Co. by null
Pels Pie Co. by null
Pels Pie Co. by null
Pels Pie Co. by null
Pels Pie Co. by null
Pels Pie Co. by null
Pels Pie Co. by null
Pels Pie Co. by null
Pels Pie Co. by null
Pels Pie Co. by null
Pels Pie Co. by null
Pels Pie Co. by null
Pels Pie Co. by null
Pels Pie Co. by null
Pels Pie Co. by null
Pels Pie Co. by null

Highlights

Rotating menu of sweet & savory pies, pastries, coffee  

Featured in The Infatuation
Featured in Eater
Placeholder

446 Rogers Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11225 Get directions

$

Information

Static Map

446 Rogers Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11225 Get directions

pelspieco

$

Features

alcohol
beer
coffee
wine
dinner
dessert
brunch
wheelchair accessible seating

Last updated

Aug 12, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@onthegrid

On the Grid : Pel's Pie Co.

"This adorable pie shop, bar and coffee house just opened its doors in March 2015. Owner Allison Pels lives right upstairs, and her menu features a mouth-watering selection of fresh-baked butter crust pies that changes daily. They make everything from scratch here with the best produce from local farms. The decor is bright and inviting, and if it's nice out, the backyard is a real gem. Oh yeah, and did we mention it's around the corner from our apartment? We're smitten." - Erin Mercurio & Jak Horner

https://onthegrid.city/brooklyn/prospect-lefferts-gardens/pels-pie-co
View Postcard for Pels Pie Co.
@infatuation

Pels Pie Co. - Review - New York - The Infatuation

"Maybe it’s your cat’s birthday or maybe you just need something sweet and round to make you feel whole again. Either way, this neighborhood pastry shop has $30 pies available for pick-up and local delivery - call 917-562-9604 to order. We haven’t been here yet, but want you to know this spot exists." - Team Infatuation

https://www.theinfatuation.com/new-york/reviews/pels-pie-co
View Postcard for Pels Pie Co.
@eater

Coronavirus in NYC: Restaurants That Have Closed Permanently Due to the Pandemic - Eater NY

"Beloved neighborhood pie shop Pels Pie Co. is closing after six years. The owner announced on Instagram that they were closing the physical location of the business on Rogers Ave., but will continue baking for pick up and delivery from a private kitchen. The pie shop may reopen in a new location at some point in the future." - Eater Staff

https://ny.eater.com/2020/5/8/21248604/nyc-restaurant-closings-coronavirus
View Postcard for Pels Pie Co.
@infatuation

The Brooklyn Delivery & Takeout Directory - New York - The Infatuation

"Maybe it’s your cat’s birthday or maybe you just need something sweet and round to make you feel whole again. Either way, this neighborhood pastry shop has $30 pies available for pick-up and local delivery - call 917-562-9604 to order." - Hannah Albertine, Nikko Duren, Bryan Kim, Arden Shore, Matt Tervooren

https://www.theinfatuation.com/new-york/guides/the-brooklyn-delivery-takeout-directory
View Postcard for Pels Pie Co.

jay dez

Google
I can appreciate a low key spot so much goodness to offer. The staff is super polite, the the menu left offers a variety of goodies from savory to sweetness. Pels Pie has a good thing going on

July Monday

Google
Incredibly disorganized. One cashier, while other employees just stand there. Half the line walked out. Avoid.

Melissa “ML” Louidor

Google
Love coming here to study/get light work done. Bright, cozy space, delicious lemonade, good coffee and they serve wine! I've only had the pie once, buy wasn't impressed. Nonetheless, this place is a gem with friendly staff and patronage.

evolvng

Google
My wife and I absolutely love this place. Her and I came to a baking class here and enjoyed every second of it. Alison is amazing, funny and just a beautiful human being. Fantastic established with great pies, coffee and now serving brunch. We will return soon. Thank you!!!!

Rachel Brooke Leswing

Google
I love Pels for a place to meet friends, work, and enjoy a nice cup of coffee. Their pies are pretty good but other pastries are hit or miss (hard pass on the lavender scones but cheddar biscuits are amazing). It seems like there is a high turnover rate for the staff, and as a result my experiences with them have been really mixed--I've had great conversations with really sweet people but have also waited 10 or 15 minutes to be helped when there's no line. Overall a nice neighborhood spot.

Liz Schofield

Google
Good neighborhood coffee shop. They do have pie, but only like 5 kinds. I think there was a larger beer selection than pie list. Not a problem for us, but I was surprised. Lots of people there just hanging out, working on laptops (read: taking up the tables). A cool place if you live in the neighborhood, but probably not the place to go if you're just passing through and looking for a dessert spot.

Zoe Kennedy

Google
A great place to go do work, waste time, or have a drink. The space is really great, tons of plants and hipster-y items. The backyard is awesome as well. Service is good too. I prefer Pels to PLG.. I've never had the pie though, I would love more vegan pie options.

Brian McDonald

Google
I live close to Pels so I will occasionally pop in for some treats. Their menu changes a bit with the seasons, so all of my recommendations may not be available. In any case, it's hard to go wrong as I've always been happy with my pie or quiche. So far I have enjoyed the coconut custard, the fig buttermilk, the plum crumble, and the bacon biscuits. Also, if you prefer gluten free items, they have a very nice brownie. Everyone is super friendly and you'll find yourself wanting to stay and hang out while having some coffee or getting classy with some bubbly. When the weather is nice you have an outdoor option as well.