Pentagoet Inn & Pub

Pentagoet Inn|Have you ever wished you could go back in time? It was our privilege to spend several days at this unique and beautiful Inn. The antique furnishings and wall hangings brought history to life making us wonder in which room, perhaps, some of those famous Americans (Adams, Madison, Hamilton) rested their heads. We slept really well. Our hosts and staff, not to be forgotten, were warm and gracious and treated everyone like family. In addition, the food and preparation were exceptional and brought happiness to our heart and tummy. Castine itself is a lovely little town with scenic views in every direction and a must see. We definitely suggest you visit. Thanks from your Seattle friends!

Returning to Castine for the first time since the sale of our family home, I was prepared for a somewhat bittersweet experience. But our stay at The Pentagoet erased all that, it was both a comfort and an inspiration. The innkeepers (just since 2022!) have revived a true historic seaside hotel, (think EM Forster meets EB White), while authentically rooting themselves and their establishment in the community as family. It is quite a thing. The wraparound porch and return of the original porch staircase to the street is an unmistakable hallmark of welcome and hospitality. The art and interior design, much of which is bespoke, handmade, and custom, is delightful. The hotel staff (owners, manager, cooks, and servers) were warm, lovely to chat with, and genuine. It was also obvious the sense of family extends to everyone. Dinner was outstanding, the lobster pot pie which I suspected would be a one-bite-and-that's-enough sort of thing, managed to be light, subtly spicy, and was served with a tangle of tartly dressed local mustard greens. The smoked trout pate with preserved lemon was standout, and I hope the crab cakes never leave the menu. The room we stayed in had wonderful character, but never sacrificed comfort. My only hesitation now is to be so honest in my review that I jeapordize our ability to think of The Pentagoet as our little secret. This is the kind of hotel that should be (at least) an annual pilgramage on everyone's list.

I stayed in room 7 at The Pentagoet for 4 nights in mid-October. Room 7 is the BEST! The bed is so comfortable and the view is outstanding! In my hubris, I went to bed with the blinds open and woke up to the most AMAZING sunrise over the ocean, however, as it rose higher it became blinding.. but it was worth it. The room got cool at night and I LOVED it. I think it helped me sleep so cozy. I didn't notice a thermometer so I'm not sure if there's a way to change the temperature in the room (it has an old steam radiator). There is a heat fan in the bathroom that I appreciated when I took my shower, it really warmed the bathroom up. The inn itself is really lovely. The food at the restaurant was fantastic. Matt, one of the owners, was so friendly and helpful. The art and decor was beautiful and fitting for the historic hotel. I appreciated the convivial nature of the pub before dinner. I met and conversed with several lovely individuals both locals and guests.

Stayed here with friends for a girls trip. Charming place to stay. Slept like a baby on a very comfortable bed. I enjoyed having coffee ready for us every morning out in the hallway. Room 3 is a great room and the whole B&B is clean. The breakfast was a highlight, fresh delicious food. The staff was friendly. The restaurant was wonderful. Make sure and order the short ribs. Matt and George made everyone feel like this was there home. I can't recommend this place enough and will definitely return!

We stayed at the Inn for our first anniversary and were delighted with the attention we received as a newly married couple. The owners were warm and welcoming. The breakfast was delicious, being homemade every morning. We stayed for dinner, while listening to a jazz trio. Our meal was delicious and we were served a complimentary glass of champagne to celebrate our anniversary. We highly recommend this Inn with its classic old world charm.

Amazing service from the start, as we were greeted by the owners and shown around. Comfortable and cozy accommodations with an awesome view overlooking the docks and river. Great coffee service and breakfast each morning to fuel up for adventuring nearby. Truly delightful dinner in the Mister's Pub (the shrimp scampi was easily one of the best I've ever had). Lovely experience all around. Will definitely be returning again soon!!!

My husband and I were recently guests at the Pentagoet Inn and Pub. If we can give it more than 5 stars we would! Our room was comfortable and tastefully decorated. The Inn has been restored to its original, historical grandness of the mid 1800's. George and Matt, the Innkeepers, make sure you are treated like family. The entire atmosphere takes you back to a simpler time. It is so relaxing. The beautiful antiques and decor is breathtakingly gorgeous. The breakfast and dinner menus are exquisite. George and Matt have created delicious entrees and deserts. Their attention to detail is evident in everything they do. If you are traveling to Maine, you must visit this charming, historical gem. You may come as strangers, but you'll leave as family. We will definitely be back!

This review is waaaay overdue, but this place is so special and deserves every star I can give it and more. My sister, cousin, and I stayed at the Pentagoet Inn in June and boy was it memorable, in the best possible way. We absolutely fell in love with Matt and George; it's damn near impossible not to! They carry such pride for the Inn and they should, because it's a precious jewel. I cannot understate how perfect the stay was. The beds, the food, the decor, the view, obviously Matt and George...everything was just...correct. The featured while we were there contained lilac straight from their garden and it was SO GOOD. They could've wheeled in a keg with that drink and I would've kicked it. The dessert was a chocolate tart and I can't believe I managed to get a picture of it before we inhaled it. They allowed us to use a table in the dining room to play cards, talked with us like we've been friends forever, and even brought us champagne while we played...I mean, seriously. No offense to any other reviewers who complained about the stairs--and I'll try not to be rude--but, what did you expect??? It's a 3 floor building, are they supposed to magic you upstairs? I wish I could write a review that would do them justice, but that's a fool's errand. Thank you, Matt and George, for sharing your beloved gem and we can't wait to come back! XOXOXO

Excellent everything across the board. Food is superb. Fresh selections of Maine seafood. For me, vegetarian options. Yay! Ambiance is off the charts. Quaint and nostalgic. Staff is top notch. Make this a stop on your travels.

My stay at the Pentagoet Inn was incredible! It felt like a fairytale. I stayed in room 9, which for an inn that is more than 200 years, was huge. The bed was comfortable and the shower pressure was incredible! The breakfast was delicious and we also ate dinner at the hotel! The lobster pot pie will haunt me in my dreams because it was that good! Finally, the best part of the Inn are the two owners Matt and George. They made us feel like guests in their house. And if you're a history nerd ask Matt to share with you the history of the inn. It's truly remarkable. I can't wait to return.

We had the pleasure of staying at the Pentagoet Inn while visiting our son at MMA. Such a great place with the most hospitable owners. The atmosphere and vibe were welcoming and felt like home. We had the pleasure of sitting for drinks at the pub. They had a variety of cocktails to choose from and a delicious spread of food items. We'll definitely be back again. This might be our go to home when we come out to MMA!

Stayed here for 2 nights. Accommodations were cozy and nice. We stayed in the main house and had our 2 preteens in the other house. Breakfast was delicious and dinner was great as well. The owners are lovely and the grounds are beautiful.

Amazing inn, the rooms are beautiful and comfortable. The ambiance is excellent! The restaurant's food is absolutely delicious! George and Matt run an immaculate inn with impeccable attention to detail. Their service to their guests is top notch! 10/10 a highly recommend..

Nice and classy place with good food and ambiance. Their crab cake is the best. We like their lobster Linguini as well. We also ordered white bean dip, eggs and salad and oysters.

Don't expect the restaurant to execute the promise of their menu. VERY slow & careless service. It took over 30 minutes to be served raw oysters with mignonette and and an order of veggie polenta. The entrees took a LONG time too. The "lobster bouillabaisse" was long awaited and then featured 5 PEI mussels that were cleaned & cooked properly, 2 nicely cooked scallops, a chunk of slightly overdone haddock and a VERY overcooked 1/2 lobster tail in a tasty broth. I approached the lobster with my fork & knew it was trouble when it bounded off the crustaceans flesh. I tasted a small bite. Rubbery. I alerted the waitress & after another wait was brought another 1/2 tail. Rubbery. Never mind. I was disappointed that the star of the show was so meager & poorly treated. Honestly the dish succeeded without the lobster. They should not include the lobster and call the dish "Maine Bouillabaisse" to make success simpler. Even better...poach the lobster in champagne butter sauce,separate from the bouillabaisse, and serve it atop the dish as I do at home? I didn't ask for any discount but to their credit, they offered a $10 reduction in the bill followed by removing the $30 charge altogether. We didn't stay for dessert as nearly 2 hours had already elapsed for appetizers & entrees. The decor of the restaurant is comfortable enough. The room we dined in was painted dark coral & white chair rail with paintings and prints of roses on every wall. The pickings are thin in Castine. Be prepared to drop significant time and coin if you dine at the Pentagoet Restaurant.

Tapas portions but wonderfully prepared. Lovely jazz music on Tuesday nights during the summer. I highly recommend this place off the beaten path in Castile, Maine

Where to begin?! At the beginning, of course! Upon arrival, new owners Matt and George greeted us with smiles. Funny thing, they never stopped smiling. More on that later. Matt and George have created a welcoming, warm and cozy environment. Their Inn is reminiscent of a by gone era. Time slows down at the Inn. Read a book, tour the quaint little town, take a leisurely drive to Bar Harbor or play a game of Castineopoly. Windows are open to the crisp clean salt air as they are only a block from the waterfront. Breakfast is presently a pick up and go but don't be fooled by the presentation. The daily breakfast specials are something to wake up for!! Likewise, dinner (seated) is amazing. Our server, Justin, was the proper combo of professional and fun. The food and beverages were 10/10 delicious!!! Note: We were fortunate to score a table on Jazz Night. We were told Tuesday jazz is very popular. It wasn't hard to see why. The music was NYC quality. Make your resies early! Now, back to the smiles, Matt and George truly love their jobs and it shows. They treat their staff and guests with kindness and respect. They aim to please! Whether giving out tour suggestions or sharing their vision moving forward for the inn, the smiles never stop! Can't wait to go back!!!

What a wonderful and beautiful B&B. First time in Castine, Maine and I will definitely be back with family and friends. With this being my first small town visit I was impressed. A+ for location of this Inn. The staff was friendly and so personable. I even met the owners who were so welcoming and happy to have me as guest. They are young and full of energy. I could tell they love what they do. The rooms are gorgeous and are all so different. There are bikes available to take stroll around the town too. My favorite is the pub and the wrap around porch which has live Jazz on Tuesday. Piano night is on Thursday. The food was outstanding. Pork Lollipops and crab cakes are a must. Wedge salad was the best I've ever had especially because it was easy to eat. I enjoy the small plates because they give you a chance to try more food. Cocktails were delicious! Another bonus about the location is it's about a 2 minute walk to the pier which you can rent a boat for yourself, kayak, or take a tour on boat.

This is a wonderfully charming place in the absolutely beautiful mid-coast area of Castine, Maine. The owner, Jack Burke, a former Foreign Service Officer, typically holds court in the bar just off the bar/fine dining area (the restaurant is not just for breakfast, it's a very fine restaurant (and we live in the Washington DC area, where most restaurants are excellent). As you would imagine, Mr Burke has many stories to tell, and most of them are borderline classified! The rooms have gorgeous views of the working harbor, which is about half a block away. We booked the Inn for one night, but were so pleased that we extended another night! Really, the Patagoet Inn is truly a great place to stay. You won't be disappointed! Murray Mack

Review is only of restaurant and wine bar. We did not stay at the inn. The wine list is well curated and fairly priced. I love me some Provence rose. The small plates are made with fresh local ingredients and oh so good. Top it off with and jazz on the porch and you can have yourself the perfect little night. Love this place!

Pub was full so we ate in the dining room. The menu is fairly small but they did offer some specials. I ordered an Old Fashioned from the bar which was quite tasty but in a very small glass. The bouilliabase (sp) was very tasty, the farm salad with goat cheese and beets delicious, and the chocolate molten cake for dessert scrumptious. Our waitress took great care of us. My husband has celiac disease and when the broiled oysters came out of the kitchen with bread crumbs she turned right around and had them make it again. She was attentive without being intrusive. All in all, a lovely and charming place for a special dinner.

They never served us drinks at the pub even though they took our order there before our dinner reservation. The food took FOREVER to come out and was not good (burnt, flavorless, etc). It was loud inside and stuffy like your great aunt's living room.

This may be the only nice restaurant in Castine, ME, but the restaurant is anything but fine. The service was slow to say the least, and the bartender/owner was seemed to be bothered when we rang the bell at the bar to get a drink as we waited for our table. I was ready to leave at this point, but my family decided to stay and see how the rest of the service was. It was a disappointment to say the least. They had lobster on two entrees in their menu, and after we ordered the entree, the waitress returned to let us know they were out of lobster! This would make perfect sense if the restaurant was located in Las Vegas, but in Maine-- 3 blocks from the harbor --seems to be probably the most ridiculous excuse I have ever heard. Then the wait for food was another problem. We waited 1 hour for okish appetizers, and another hour for burnt scallops, and a plate of what was called quinoa, but resembled the bowl of mush you serve to prisoners. The last issue was the noise; it was like sitting next to an engine and trying to talk to the person next to you. I finally gave up and say quietly til I got the bill so I could escape and have peace and quiet once again.The bottom line is, if you have 2-3 hours, love yelling across a table, and don't mind poorly cooked food, then this is the place for you!

What a lovely establishment! Fine dining in scenic Castine gets no better than Pentagoet. The menu is fairly small but diverse for its size, and the food is beyond compare. Portion sizes are appropriate - none of the terribly small and overpriced portions you receive at other fine dining establishments. The atmosphere is quite cozy, but the dining rooms have a nice ambiance. Particularly interesting to me was the decor of the pub area which evades proper description. Food was delicious, the drinks were well-made but I found to be slightly lacking in flavor. They had a distinctive and consistent style to them however, which deserves credit.

The pub in this place is soooo amazing. Sip some scotch and just take in the room. It'll leave you feeling worldly and intrigued.

We did not make a reservation on a Monday evening and were told we could not be seated for dinner for 45 minutes. No offer to serve us cocktails or appetizers at the empty tables on the porch. It was a beautiful evening to sit outside. Not a very warm and friendly hostess. Will not return here.

My second visit to Pentagoet and I couldn't be happier: the place is beautiful, the PUB, amazing, the service, impeccable and the food just delicious. Can't wait to come back next summer!

Crab cakes excellent, truly taste of fresh crab, Russian salad nice, light, lamb chop special was fabulous--about 4-5 lamb chops surrounding a Close Encounters pile of delicious mashed potatoes. Bouillabaisse fine, but nothing special (and lobster rubbery!). Desserts nice--blueberry crumble, chocolate gelato & cherries a nice finish. Ask to sit in the bar, surrounded by an eclectic collection of paintings & photos of heads of state and anyone of interest. You can spend dinner challenging your visual & historical memory. Educational, delicious & fun.

Had dinner in the pub (could have eaten in the main room, but the pub called to us) surrounded by pictures of world leaders collected from the owners own travels. Quite impressive and sets a fantastic mood. I thoroughly enjoyed the bouillabaisses (lead with a locally grown salad with smoked motz!) and my husband had several options to choose from as a vegetarian. The chef is to be toasted!

This was the highlight of our trip to Maine. Delicious clever localvore dinner choices paired with a very nice wine list in a charming atmosphere. We had a really delightful evening there. I look forward to returning in the future.

The Pentagoet Inn Restaurant offers skillfully prepared dishes in a tiny town that the masses don't know about. Thank goodness. We had the Taste of the Pentagoet. Loved each bite. The pre-dinner cocktails on the front porch were delightful as well. Get away from the masses and enjoy one of Maine's full of character and off the beaten path places. Delish!