Penza's Pies at the Red Barn

New Jersey Farm fresh, old school charm! All the pies are extremely delicious. Love having them adorn our thanksgiving dessert table. The ricotta pumpkin pie a favorite, it’s luscious treat! Have enjoyed a good breakfast in a unique, warm and welcoming setting.

Cozy with down to earth people . I has asparagus omelet with tomatoes cheese sourdough bread and wonderful fruit cup made from apples and cranberries. Evelyn is very nice. The server also. I'm set for the day.

On par with the food is the service, which is Excellent. Blueberry and ricotta pie was something I never experienced before and was DELICIOUS! Please indulge yourself with a pie fit for royalty!

Lovely placer for homemade pies, jams, breakfast and lunch! The staff is so friendly, feels like home! Warm and welcoming . Spinach feta omelet was phenomenal

I finally found this place again after I randomly stopped once 2 years ago to buy pie for a friend who said it was the best they've ever had. Evelyn is so, so sweet and the 5 fruit pie was even sweeter. The fruit flavor is sweet but not sugary and the buttery crust is so tasty. Can't wait to go back again!

A mystical experience that feels like true farmer hospitality. Great service that feels wholesome! Came early in the morning and wonderful/calming way to start the day before work. -Portions are smaller than usual but all of it is quality!

Penza's Pies at the red barn is like no other! The sit down country breakfast, the orange juice and the coffee is ALWAYS fresh! We've been coming here since I was a little girl and Evelyn welcomes us like family, every single time. Visit her today, and DON'T forget your pie! My personal fave is and always has been the five fruit!

I went back and forth about writing a review but I am so disappointed. We pre ordered 4 pies (pumpkin, pumpkin ricotta, double crust Apple, and apple cranberry). Upon arriving they were so beautiful we asked for an additional five fruit. My family and I were literally so excited to go home and try them we didn’t even wait till thanksgiving we all tried a slice Wednesday night. To our utter dismay we were all so sad to find out the fruit pies had almost no flavor and to really make the matter worse the pies were so undercooked. It was doughy, quite soggy, and disgusting in the center. I would NOT only HIGHLY not recommend this place I will go out of my way to let people know they should absolutely not order from here. I mean come on if you have “Pies” in your name you should at least know how to cook a pie… get it together.

SO stinking cute. The vibes here are lovely. It's in a cute barn and everything is made from scratch. We had the liberty of sitting down with Mrs. Penza and hearing her story. Do you know she closes around 2pm, to start baking pies for the next day!!!! She's then there at 5am with the finishing touches. She's amazing! Just like her pies. You can truly Taste the love in them. Would highly recommend the frittata for a nice breakfast (: then head over to all The farm stands in the area... which is where her ingredients are sourced from!!! FARM FRESH!

This is a cute, quaint little home owned place in the country. The atmosphere is the best reason to go. It is just calm and cute. I had peach pancakes and they were delicious. They sell a lot of pies and frozen pot pies and the person who took us said they were delicious. She bought one to take home. Warning the chicken pot pie was $35 though frozen. They are known for their award winning pie. We were served a sample of the blueberry pie for free. It was unique tasting and even though it wasn't my taste the others at our table loved it because of its unique taste.

$40 pie w/ tart berries & mushy. Three of us tried it and felt sick. The fruit was turning & mealy. They were very apologetic and refunded our money.

I was approached by an employee in front of my family of five with their rules for the sunflower field.OK.I did pick a sunflower without the correct color wrist band. I was not asked to pay for it although I offered. Upon hearing $3 for one tiny sunflower I handed it back. I was wrong. We were told. Thing is, as we were wrapping up our pictures in front of the sunflower field (surprisingly there was no charge for pics), and after spending at least $175 for their maze and ( slow, rude food service, we were approached AGAIN, a SECOND time, this time by a the manager and lectured on how they're there to make money, and that it may not be the place for us if we couldn't spend it on their hayride which included a free sunflower. It's not what he said but how we were angrily confronted. Well we left, telling him we didn't need the lecture on a beautiful Sunday, and, skipping our stop in their bakery, went merrily on our way. This IS the place for you if you enjoy throwing money away.Looking at prior reviews, glad we avoided the bakery.

The pies here are stunning and delicious. The chef knows what they are doing when it zones to these delightful pies. I stopped in for quiche and the staff even gave me a free slice of multiple berry pie. I will be back for a whole pie for my next family event.

Stopped here because of their pie signs and pretty red barn only to be extremely offended and disappointed. Harassed by an employee for asking to use the bathroom after ordering pie and coffee for breakfast. Was asked if we were there for soccer, said yes, then proceeded to rudely tell me that they aren't there to cater to soccer players. Told me to use the porta potties...seriously?! I'm a PAYING customer that was admiring the facilites. How about a thank you for business. Ignorant employee. Can't really enjoy the pie after such a negative experience. Walked in with a big smile, left with disbelief. Feel bad for the owners.

Some of the best pie my wife and I have had anywhere in the world. Fresh and made from scratch, worth the price. Lots of haters on here, drive on, this is a hidden gem. Ms. Penza is a good soul and has a great eye as well, I guess some don't see it. We have had the fruit pie, peach pie, apple pie and ricotta pie, all absolutely exceptional fresh, great fillings and crust, perfectly cooked, like something you would get at the Waldorf in NYC, and by the way, these guys have been in The NY Times and on Food Network. Enjoy!

Stopped off to get some pies. But first I had breakfast. Ham and eggs and home fries. Absolutely horrible. Seriously, this could be, no it is the worst breakfast I've ever had. Asked for over easy, they were hard, no yoke. Potatoes Had lots of skin on them, ugh, ham was dry and served with a plastic spoon. Good luck cutting them. Bread was skimpy and cold. Just keep on driving by. Oh , I didn't get the pies. I was afraid to after that breakfast.

We took home a blueberry pie. Very fresh, not too sweet, more on the tart side. Crust was good but not superb. Service was wonderful, we came to late for sit down/food (after 1:30p can only purchase pies, no food). The price was a bit steep, $35 for the blueberry pie, but it was delicious! Takes cash and Venmo.

Stopped here yesterday to check the place out. Met the owner she was very nice and helpful. All the pies looked great and it was hard to pick one. So I picked the peach pie. When I got home we tried the peach pie. I have to say it was one of the best peach pies I have had in a long time. I'll be back next week to try a different pie. Might try the blueberry pie.

The five berry pie I bought at Penza Pies was incredible!!!!! Definitely worth the drive!

I had the strawberry and Rhubarb pie and it was delicious!! Not too sweet and not a lot of dough. The crumbs on top were made very well. All ingredients used were definitely fresh. It was a bit expensive at $25 and cash only.

Pies here are absolutely gorgeous and appealing to the eye, colorful and intriguing in flavor - Five-fruit pies probably being the most curiosity-arousing. I found blueberry, apple, cherry, peach, and... cranberry! Yet despite the delicious combination, it was an absolute mess of a creation. The crust was raw and soft, the topping crumbling everywhere, and the fruit wasn't soft enough to where the pie could be enjoyable.

I've been here a handful of times now but I'm not going to able to anymore. The pies are really good but the prices are insane. $35 for a blueberry pie is really too much.

My boyfriend bought us the Very Berry pie & it was absolutely delicious! We'll definitely be back!!

I was reluctant to buy a pie for $30 but I have no regrets. I got a blueberry pie and I live pretty far away but I'm already thinking about when I can take the drive and get another pie. So good. Worth it.

I've lived in the area for nearly a decade and I'm just really exploring my local spots. This mixed berry pie was incredible and the wonderful young lady who makes them was incredibly welcoming. Also they take venmo which I didn't see in the info here.

Love Elizabeth Penza's pies! Nothing compares to her delicious mixed berry pies! I love eating there for brunch. Quiche is awesome!

Delicious home made food and fruit and savory pies in an adorable country setting. We came here for a fruit pie and ended up leaving with a five fruit pie, two chicken pot pies, and two full bellies from a delicious home cooked breakfast. I had the tomato pie which was a perfect serving and came accompanied by roasted potatoes and the sweetest watermelon I have ever eaten. My husband had delicious peach pancakes. We left with a savory chicken pot pie which was the most delicious hearty pot pie. The five fruit pie had a delicious crumb topping. The owner and staff were so friendly and grateful to have the business during the pandemic. You definitely felt appreciated. The food was a bit pricey but well worth it as everything was made from scratch with quality ingredients. Be sure to bring cash as they only accept cash or Venmo. This makes for the perfect stop during a Sunday drive. We will most certainly return sooner rather then later.

I used to go to Penza's a lot years ago when I had a client in Hammonton. Always got a pie and all of them were excellent. Recently went back and the quality is still there. All home made, using local ingredients where possible. We took home a chicken pot pie - it was wonderful! So was a peach ricotta pie. Delicious quiche for lunch while there - generous portion comes with potatoes, toast and fruit. Definitely worth a long drive. Dropped a star because there were flies buzzing around our lunch. Next time we'll go in the colder weather, that should take care of the problem.

Big let down! I was advised by family this was a special place To go have breakfast and make sure you get one of their delicious pies It was a 45 minute drive and I was in anticipation of a memorable experience The people are nice the resturant is quaint The ham & egg and good potatoes were very good So now the disappointment The pies were all out. Not in a pie display cabinet Open air on a table in the resturant the disgusting thing is the register is behind the pie table, so people have to reach over the pies to pay and since they don't take credit cards it's dirty cash. Bottom line pies should be covered with a clear plastic shield ,Thats just common sense! Not to impressive We wanted an apple pie but no full crusted version was there we got there at 1030am However we were offered a uncooked so we decided to take it Well it smelled great when baking and I was salivating However very disappointing flavor nothing special at all actually quite ordinary mediocre ! Pies looked great & Apples were nice cut but flavor was way off Business can't keep a reputation on past glory They need to step up their game! For $25 for a pie it should have knocked your socks off. It was extremely overpriced! Lots of awards on the wall but I would never go here again for a pie Wegmans and whole foods sells beter pies and at A more realistic price Only 2 stars for me for the breakfast

The most delicious homemade food! Service is always kind and attentive--5 stars all around!

Passed the Red Door Barn a few times when visiting the area and kept saying to myself that I really needed to stop one day and check it out when it was open. Every time I passed it was late and it was closed. This past Saturday my husband and I were in the area visiting his family and we were able to catch it open a few minutes before closing. They were actually cleaning up for the day so we were truly in luck. The Red Door Barn is beautiful outside and even moreso inside. The pies are laid out throughout the restaurant/store on various tables, displayed openly for you to view up close. They are absolutely GORGEOUS to look at. They had everything from apple pies to peach pies to pies that were made with five different fruits. I ended up choosing two small pies. One apple and one five fruit. The only reason I took one star away is because the pies are definitely pricey. Living on Long Island, I'm blessed to live close to a famous pie place called Briermere Farms. Their pies are shipped across the world and are delicious. Their pies go for about $16 for a standard size. The two small pies came to $45 at Red Door Barn. Definitely steep but I admit the pies are more "pretty" than the place I live near. And everyone raved about the pies when we brought them to a family dinner that evening. The woman who helped ring me up was very friendly and didn't rush me even though they were closing up soon. She introduced herself and asked my name. I didn't realize they did not accept debit or credit and the ATM machine was currently being serviced so I had to wait until the gentleman was done before I can take cash out. I'll remember next time to have cash on me as I definitely plan on going back. I don't mind paying more for quality and quality is what you get at the Red Door Barn.

This is only my second time to ever leave a review but just had to do it on this one! My wife and I stopped in yesterday for some produce and things. Didn't really see much to purchase at the "Farm Market" but we did see the pies and purchased a pie and a pint of berries. My wife asked to use the restroom, we were told that "it wasn't working". Seriously, it's actually a restaurant, and the women there told us that the restroom was broken! Called later asked if the restaurant was open. " of course the restaurants open" was the response!

Had a great experience here went there early morning on a Monday had the Quiche it was filled with veggies but it didn't impress me what did was my husbands asparagus omelet super delicious came with home fries and rye toast and their peach pancakes I'm not a pancake person but I absolutely felt the love they put in those. I'm going back there for their pies and pancakes

We purchased 3 pies last thanksgiving and we were very disappointed. The pies were very expensive and most importantly lacked flavor. I gave an extra star because the people at the business were so nice. I hate to say it but you're better off at a bakery or even supermarket.

Best quiche I've ever had! Asparagus, roasted red peppers, ripe tomatoes and ooey, gooey cheesy goodness!! Everything on the plate was beyond good. The pies are solid fruit, no filler, just fruit. Nicest people ever and the place is shabby-chic adorable.

We come here for pies whenever we are in the area. It is cash only but they have an atm on the premises. Their pies are not to be missed. The pies are 5 stars but the service is not. I was checking in to yelp while my husband ordered the pie and the lady snapped at me for using my phone. Apparently she wanted one of us to reach into the case and hand her the pie (ew!) And we didn't react quickly enough. I told her I was checking into yelp and she immediately changed her tone. Ugh.

Wow, now this is a shame that I'm the first reviewer of this place. Maybe it's a local 'secret' but then again this place was already on the food network. For good reason too, this place does probably the single best stop for homemade pies. Now before this review starts sounding like too much an advertisement, I'll say the staff here always seems aloof, pies are a little pricey, and have these weird unplaceable accents. But that's not a bad thing as they can make great pies. I'm a huge fan of the Little Pie Company in New York, especially for the apple sour cream walnut, the best pie in the world (pretty much that's it, other pies there are okay but that's a different review) but this place make a cranberry apple pie that's completely on par with them. I was shocked. I know they're different flavors and all, but wow finally a match. On top of that, all the pies here are fantastic. They're very big on rigot cheesecakes here, and all the fruit pies come from local fruit. And no, I'm not one of those "buy local" hippies, but I say that because the produce is generally better from this area. So next time you're in the absolute middle of nowhere and need a pie, go there.

Wow, hubby and I had pancakes and coffee and the bill was $36.00. No bacon or juice. Ridiculously over priced! Oh, $28.00 for a pie? Outrageous!

My family and I love eating here for breakfast, it reminds me of my best friends house where her mom made homemade pies and wonderful breakfast items for us. The fruit pies are over flowing with fruit and a fresh blueberry pie in June or July cant be beat.

Ricotta pie? WHY YES! Delicious. Ricotta and pumpkin? Super. Blueberry? Yup, that too, delish!! Very friendly staff. Quality pies.

Heard a lot about the great pies here. So I drove about an hour to pick up a apple cranberry pie. They only accept cash which no one told us on the phone. So I had to spend $2 at their ATM machine to pay for the pie. Overall cost $26 for a 8 inch apple cranberry pie. The pies look impressive but I wasn't impressed. It was a good pie but not for that price. I'll stay local and pay less for my next pie.

LEGENDARY! Most drive by for years without stopping. I cant drive by without stopping! Best ever, traditional homemade pies. Gotta go!

I tried the apple pie and really enjoyed it. This was recommended to me by a friend and now I would recommend this to others. The price is $20 per pie. The apple pie has lots of apples and not so much dough, so you won't feel guilty eating this. I want to try the apple and blueberry pie next time.

I agree with Robert L. that given the price of the pies they dont even take debit/credit. Oh but how convenient they have an ATM machine right there! Insulting. Every other small business in the Hammonton area will take the cards. The location of the place on Rt.206 South attracts people from out of the area mostly going to the shore. They have no idea how much a pie costs till they get inside. Then probably feel too embarrassed to leave without a purchase. I bet you would find that 3/4+ of the Hammontonians dont even go there. I'll keep buying Mrs. Smith's pies at ShopRite cause Mrs. Penza needs to be a little more "local friendly"

The pies are expensive but worth it, much denser than what you can buy at most bakeries and supermarkets and way tastier. Cash-only which is annoying in 2019 in America but can't find better fruit based pies anywhere. The breakfast is ok but when we dined there there were small flies all over and it ruined the experience. Reluctant to eat there again but have bought pies from them several times.

This is a fun stop if you are driving through Hammonton. It's a cafe and pie shop in a very cute 120-year-old red barn. The farm was originally settled by a Sicilian immigrant. Keep in mind, it is cash only, so be prepared. As you walk in, there is a table of pies to your left and a counter to your right. We got seated in the dining area for brunch. Brunch was good, not amazing. We wanted to get slices of pie but were told we couldn't order slices. There was a blueberry dessert available, so we got that. It was delicious. The pies were available for purchase, and they want you to purchase them separately from your dining bill. It was a little confusing to check out, but all the ladies who work there are friendly and cute. We bought a blueberry pie for the road.

This is a hidden gem! It's a must try in South Jersey, they have the most incredible pies and serve a spectacular country Homestyle meal. The pies are hands down second to none!

Easy to get to long time family of HAMMONTON and can they cook and bake well the pies are kissed by the heavens when ever I'm near there daily I must stop and grab pies hell I think they should go full commercial on the pies and let the world know of the heavenly pies they make but I buy a few at a time and make it a fan tradition at holiday dinner that I've got pie and they always try to eat first. This is a true gem in South Jerseys Crown Keep up the great work Thank you Dennis of Ideal Blend Antiques

Once again had a delightful breakfast in soothing farm-like surroundings. From the minute you walk through the door, the aroma of pies, muffins and country breakfast fills the air! My asparagus omelet was delicious along with the order of blueberry pancakes my husband and I split.. mouthwateringly light and fluffy. The only pitfall if they don't accept credit/debit cards, however they do have a debit machine on premises, so not to worry they have it covered! On your way out pic up a freshly baked pie to take home. You won't regret it!!!

Ate here for the first time on Labor Day with my triathlon club. We biked in from Medford and arrived with our appetites. We were seated right away in the outdoor patio area, (I imagine they didn't want us cyclists stinking up the dining room!) which was nice. We did venture indoors to use the restroom, which is almost located in the kitchen, which was a little weird, but clean and private. Walking through the restaurant gives one the opportunity to see all of the amazing pies and other desserts on display. OMG, the pies looked so good, they actually looked fake! During my entire breakfast, I was trying to think of a way to transport a pie 16 miles back to Medford on my bike. Unfortunately, I was not able to figure out a viable solution to my problem. However, much to my delight, one of my teammates in our party bought a whole pie for the group to celebrate some birthdays. It was a mixed berry with a crumb top. Most definitely the best pie I've ever had in my life. As far as our breakfast itself went, our server was quick to delivery water to everyone, and then coffee and other drinks that we ordered. Upon being seated, everyone is given a lemon biscotti - delicious! Our food came out pretty quickly. I got the spinach mushroom quiche, which came with home fries. Both were really good and fresh, and had a nice presentation. The portion of home fries was a little on the small side, but my slice of pie made up for it. Everyone seemed very happy with their meals, and most importantly, the pie! :) On the way out I got some corn, even though it was obviously not local since it's way too early for Jersey corn, and a couple of apple cider donuts, which my husband and I ate later at home. The donuts were OK, but nowhere near as good as Springdale Farm's apple cider donuts. Obviously, pie is where this place excels! I plan to return again (in a car!) and get a whole pie, and hope my tri team plans another ride out there soon!

Saw this quaint little store on the side of Rt 206 and stopped for a break...went inside and saw a plethora of amazing fruit pies...got the five fruits pie and it was out of this world...one of the best pies I've had in this country...suggest to go there if you are ever driving by...

Went here for the first time for easter brunch and it was great. The food was delicious (the potatoes to die for) and the pies looked like works of art (and the 1 I tasted was also amazing. A great little place for breakfast or lunch or ... pie of course!

Stopped in for breakfast today after getting lost. Ate outside/inside as it was a nice day out, very comfy I had the NJ asparagus omelette with jersey tomatoes very tasty served with fresh watermelon and potato hash, enjoyed everything. Was given a small piece of peach-ricotta pie for dessert complimentary also very good. I would recommend this place for breakfast although it was a small menu.

I don't know if it was because my gf and I were the only two getting breakfast at the time, but the service here is great. We both ordered the quiche with spinach and mushroom for $6 and added a coffee for $2 each. Next thing you know the quiche comes with sliced potatoes and the waitress later brings fluffy, fresh bread. She later brings two pieces of berry crumble pie without us even asking. Not bad for $18 total. Don't know if all the extras are normal, but it was definitely a nice touch this time around. The ricotta with blueberry and peach was good, but I wouldn't say it was amazing. I do love the fresh fruit and how the filling wasn't overly sweet. However, the texture of the ricotta and depth of flavor doesn't compare to the ricotta cheesecakes I've had in this area and in New York/ Brooklyn.

Pretty good pies, very homey food, hot dogs, hamburgers, etc. Great pasta salad and they serve fresh ears of corn rather than a bread basket. The pies are good but they are pricey, glad we stopped by, very friendly service.

I stopped into the place while on the way to Wharton State Forest. I was setting out for a day of hiking and had not appropriately eaten. Furthermore, I knew that I hadn't packed substantial snacks for the day. I figured this place would be a nice little roadside bakery in order to get a quick snack. I was immediately shocked by the menu... $10 omelets and breakfast sandwiches. I guessed, correctly, that this place wasn't going to accept credit and I only have a few bucks on me. Because I didn't even enough cash for the, very expensive, 5 dollar muffin, I used the ATM. I really was looking for a sandwich but there was no way I was about to shell out $10 for a sandwich I shouldn't have had to purchase anyway (I should have prepared and packed smarter.) I really don't like using a restroom without patronizing a small business so because of the fact that I knew I'd be buying something anyway I waited until after I purchased the muffin to ask her about the restroom. It was at this moment, this moment after accepting the ATM surcharge, after purchasing this inanely priced muffin that the woman had the absolute nerve to tell me that THE RESTROOM IS FOR 'DINE-IN' CUSTOMER'S ONLY. Unbelievable! I had already made my purchase! I had already paid $2.50 for no other reason that the establishment didn't accept credit! I don't know if it was some kind of gamble to woo me into spending even more money but at that point I just turned and left in disgust. Wharton State Forest isn't much further ahead so I was more than happy to get out of there and hold out for the trail head. A note on the muffin. It wasn't bad, it truly was not a bad muffin; it was okay. It was a pretty run of the mill muffin. It wasn't great; it certainly wasn't $5 good. From beginning to end, this place is just a complete trap.

Just happened to be passing along a familiar route, visiting family when this place caught my attention. I typically don't pay much attention to prominent signs for businesses, however, when I saw the 'ricotta' pie sign, I figured why not check it out. The selection of homemade pies was excellent, and despite paying more than I normally would for a modest size pie, the taste was not disappointing at all! The staff that morning was attentive and the cafe looked to be a really pleasant place to stop for a snack on a future visit.