Pepe's Cafe

We had an amazing dinner at Pepe’s in Key West! Out of all of the times I have been down I have never stopped here…. But I am glad we finally did!! The bustling atmosphere spoke to its popularity, and making reservations was a wise move. The staff managed the busy evening seamlessly. The dining experience was delightful, and we thoroughly enjoyed the vibrant ambiance. Looking forward to returning!

Great little spot. We came for breakfast but will probably be back for happy hour. The breakfast was delicious. Omelet and french toast special. Coffee was choc-full-o'nuts brand and was decent. It is worth stopping if for no other reason than it has been here since 1909. Prices are definitely reasonable especially for the area.

We were seated pretty quickly. Very cool vibe. It seemed there was some tension and only one employee we could see attempting to be our waitress & the bartender. We told her we were rushed for a shuttle. Asked for to go. We were still late & our patty melts were so dry they stuck to the roof of your mouth. Unfortunately flavorless :( might be better on a fully staffed day

Went here a couple of times while visiting Key West. This restaurant is definitely a hidden jewel in Key West. Christine was our server and she did an excellent job! We had a great dining experience. I like the variety of items that they have for dinner. There is something for everyone at this place. We also came here for breakfast as well and we were very pleased. We will definitely be back the next time we visit Key West! Highly recommended restaurant!

This is a difficult review to write. The serving staff was amazing...friendly & helpful...just great. However, the kitchen completely fell down on the job...very inconsistent quality. I took 22 people to dine and many found their meal sub-par. I really don't think this establishment should accept that size groups as they just can't get the job done. For a group of 4, I'm sure they are awesome.

By far the best meal we had in the island! The key lime pie was to die for! Our server was super busy with other tables it made up for it on our ticket even though we told him he didn’t have too.

The oldest restaurant in Key West and the second oldest in the state of Florida, and certainly not one to be missed. We went during Happy Hour and enjoyed steamed shrimp, oysters, and fish dip. The pink shrimp were colossal and oh so good. The Oysters Florentine were a close second. Service was great and had the typical low key yet attentive Key West vibe.

We had the fish Rueben sandwich. Excellent!!! Highly recommend. Their pulled pork was tasty but the Rueben was exceptional. We also had the smoked fish dip. Very good. The staff were friendly and helpful.