Pepperoni Grill

Needed a hearty hot dinner that was close by. It had been a while since having a pepperoni grill dinner. So we made haste to fill up. The service was good, but a little spotty. The food was good, but there was way too much. I understand wanting to get more bang for your buck, but this is a little too much. You get plenty of bread with your meal, so I recommend not ordering an appetizer. Enjoy!

Food was great! Drinks are good and strong and the bread they bring out first is amazing! Also their sweet tea is so refreshing

Wonderful experience here before going to see a movie. Great chicken parm & shrimp Alfredo with a nicely curated wine selection. Staff was wonderful and very insightful, will be back!

We always have consistently great food here. The staff was very friendly. I wish they had some music on but that's just me. Hubby got the spicy pesto chicken and pasta and it was great. They always serve bread with cheese cooked in the middle with olive oil and balsamic vinegar, so good. I usually get the cheese tortellini with mixed sauce, its so yummy. I went out of my zone and got the fettuccine Alfredo. Homemade is the best. Theirs wasn't great. Lacked flavor and the sauce got thick and hard fast. I just won't get that again because my Alfredo standards are high. The trio appetizer was delicious. Italian nachos, artichoke dip and mozzarella sticks. The red sauce was delicious and the toast points for the dip were on point.

I’ve been here a few times and always thought the food was good, however it will be my last. Took my mother here to dine in for lunch. Host and waiter was good, food seemed good and towards the end there was roaches crawling on the table into the wall. I could not believe my eyes. I instantly started gagging. Crazy part is as it was crawling in the walls I immediately notified our water that was walking by. I could tell he felt so embarrassed. He said he would be right back and came and explained they recently sprayed the day before and that they are “starting to come out”. Also, that his manager would come by. While waiting on the manager she came by immediately apologized and covered our tab. What grossed me out was her admitting that this is an ongoing issue in there establishment and due to being inside a mall it’s hard to prevent. They spray often and it is an issue. Me and my mom was stunned. I could not believe I immediately gagged and felt like throwing up. To think y’all got roaches coming out the seats and crawling on tables is wild. If it’s such an issue close the establishment and open your own building. This is gross. Made me think how it must be really bad in the kitchen then. I tried to snap a pic of the 3 roaches that was crawling along with there baby sacks, but they crawled away before I could snap a picture. I felt bad for the waiter I know it wasn’t his fault and we did leave a $10 tip, because he was sweet. However, me personally I would have done left. Most customers take there frustration out on a waiter and he could do better somewhere else.

Great food with generous portions. Very professional and courteous staff.

Went here the other night for dinner and had an amazing time. Our waitress was very personable and helpful. The food came out quickly and was fresh and hot. Love their bread appetizer, it has unmelted cheese, wish I knew what kind it was, and you dip it in balsamic oil and olive oil and it's just lovely. Their menu has a large variety so definitely something for everyone I feel. Will definitely be coming back!

We’re familiar with Pepperoni Grill because I take my wife to the one in Edmond all the time, sometimes with the kids too. Regardless, we had chosen this location as a last resort, Penn Square, on Mother’s Day since we were planning on going somewhere else but wait was over an hour and a half. We figured, heck we’re familiar and we all enjoy Pepperoni Grill. Well, to be fair I haven’t been to this location since I was in college and I’m mid forties now. The atmosphere was fine and familiar, clean. However the meals were either not up to par or something was off. First, we ordered calamari. This looked like an old batch and chewed like cold mozzarella sticks. We took one bite and sent it back. No way that thing was calamari else it was old and decrepit leftovers. The lasagna was salty and overpowered the flavor, though we ate it. I ended up vomiting it up in bathroom, no joke. My Caesar chicken salad was fine, really good actually…even though I had to ask for more dressing. Pizza and pasta were fine too. We ordered tiramisu and what we got was a cheesecake form of it, not traditional. We truly never ordered that there before so we don’t know if it’s standard for pepperoni grill. Upon receiving the check, we had to remind them to take off the calamari we sent back - no one in their right mind would have ate that or accepted paying for it. In the end it was fine, but seriously disappointing experience. Still left a nice 20% tip but never going back to that location. Edmond is the spot, maybe one day we’ll try the one on memorial though.

It's been a while since we have visited Pepperoni Grill, and we had a great meal. We tried a variety of entrees, and everyone really enjoyed their selection. We started with the Italian Nachos, which were just ok. The complementary bread was good. The space, just inside the west entrance of Penn Square Mall, is spacious and lovely. The servers were friendly and helpful. We will be back soon!

Nice Pepperoni Grill location in Penn Square Mall - they have bomb and healthy seafood offerings in addition to their Italian fare, so check that out for sure!

Enjoyed the wine pairing dinner Thursday at Pepperoni Grill located in Penn Square Mall. This is our 2nd wine paring dinner there, and both events have been lovely. Tonight, the featured wines were two Italian wines and two California wines. Two whites, and two reds. I'm not into whites, and I have very little experience with Italian wines, but overall, I thought the paired wines were good. The first two courses definitely stretched my culinary experience, as I would have never ordered either items off of a dinner menu. The next two courses perfectly aligned with my tastes. First course: Watermelon gazpacho with feta crema and cilantro. I have never liked cold soups but I must say that I enjoyed this one. It was interesting, in a good way, with a cornucopia of flavors perfectly blended and beautifully presented. It was paired with an Italian White, Poderi, Lugia Einaudi. A nice wine, a good pairing. Second course: The second course was a baby wedge with buttermilk vinaigrette, bacon, heirloom tomatoes, shaved red onion, parmesano reggiano, feta, panko crumbs, with chicken and dill. This was my first edge ever, and it was excellent. The syngery of the ingredients was delectable. The wedge was paired with a California Chardonnay; Submission. I was not impressed with it, It lacked character and was flat on the palate, but I drank every drop. The wedge was bold and daring and needed a more robust wine paring. An Willamette Valley Pinot would have been my choice. Third course: The third course was a veal franchise. Very nice! I enjoy veal, and I particularly liked this serving. It was served with roasted broccoli that was excellent. The sauce on the veal was a lemon butter sauce with roasted romanesco, pistachio crumbs, and fried Caper vinaigrette. EXCELLENT! Fourth course: Chili chocolate carmel tart topped with chocolate pearls. This was a chocolate lovers delight. I thoroughly enjoyed it. It was paired with Marietta Arme Cabernet Sauvignon. It's a nice pairing and enjoyable wine. It was a very good evening, a very enjoyable dinner. The wine pours were generous. The wait staff did a nice job. The wine host spent time with the patrons, which made the evening that much better.

I won a table for two event to this location, and had a wonderful experience. The owners were inviting and accommodating. The servers were fast and efficient, and the wine and food pairing was good!

It's a good thing this place closed. I've only been there twice, but both times were disastrous. The first time, cockroaches were crawling all over the place.. The second time the food was just terrible. We ordered the Italian nachos and the cheese was like three days old and tasted like Velveeta cheese. I told him we would never be back again. The other two in Edmond and Oklahoma City are great clean and good food

I was craving Chicken Piccata and rather than driving a half hour to my usual location, I searched for somewhere closer. I hadn't been to Pepperoni Grill in forever so I looked them up and thought I'd give them another go. I ordered Chicken Piccata. My ticket says I ordered Chicken Piccata. What I got was lightly buttered noodles with a half dozen capers thrown in and some bland chicken. It completely left out the defining flavors of lemon and garlic that make a piccata what it is in the tiny bit of sauce that was on the mostly dry pasta and completely dry chicken that I received in my order.

We were out at Penn Square Mall last week for a quick errand and stopped here for a quick lunch just a few minutes before midday. This is my second visit since 2018 and I remember it being a smart looking restaurant with great service and, on this occasion, the staff are exceptionally efficient, professional, and attentive, just as I remembered. Both of us had a pasta dish and the husband ordered his obligatory house salad with ranch dressing. My spicy sausage rigatoni was delicious and satisfying. I know pasta connoisseurs are finicky about al dente pasta, but I prefer mine cooked a little beyond that point, which my rigatoni was and that made it perfect for me. The husband said his cheese ravioli was also delicious but the sauce was a touch too sweet for him. The serving size here is generous. Even though I didn't order an appetiser or a salad I still managed to take home my left over pasta!

This was our first time at Pepperoni Grill and everything we ordered was delicious. Even the kids loved their meals. Prices are decent. Our waiter, Travis was amazing. Very fast and attentive, super friendly. The food did not take long at all and tasted fresh. We will definitely be back. We ordered 4 different pasta dishes, pizza, coffee and a tea.

Service is 5 stars and the food and wine prefix was great and seamless. Food was great with the pairing of wine at a great value. I should come eat here more but for some reason I forget about this location at Penn Square, Mall. I will come back and thank you again for the wonderful meal experience.

A weeknight dinner with a party of 10 that turned into 16. The staff was friendly, accommodating, and had good humor about the increased party. The service was fast, accurate, and generous. Someone was routinely filling our water and tea glasses, and we never ran out of the complementary bread. The dinner Caesar salad was generous in size and generous with the shaved Parmesan cheese. My rigatoni was served hot, the serving was generous, and the spicy vodka sauce was rich and thick. Expect to pay about $30 per person,it will be satisfying meal, and you will probably even take some of it home.

Nice presentation but the salmon was overcooked (after I ordered it medium). Service was good and the restaurant is in decent shape after all these years in business.

Pepperoni Grill does a really good job! Despite it being a restaurant at the mall (which may deter people who don't want to go to the mall lol), their food and service are great. We've been a couple times recently and had excellent experiences. Their pizzas are bomb and have unique toppings like the goat cheese one. It's so good! I've gotten the tortellini and risotto during my past two visits and loved them both. Their grilled chicken is moist and flavorful. They are attentive to your drinks as well, and the complimentary bread with the oil and vinegar really just sets it off. So if you are going to the movies at the mall or want an elevated mall dining experience, Pepperoni Grill makes it worth every penny. The staff is on top of it and so is the kitchen.

I want to like this location but I've given it to many try and the consistency had remained- constantly bad. The serves has always been a major downer. Most seem like they don't want to be there and sure don't want to help out. The food never wows, just upsets. The fact that it's in a mall and you have random passerby's staring at you doesn't help. Do yourself a favor and go to a different location!

Didn't want to order food after getting our drinks because as we were waiting for the bartender/ server to come back and take our order, 5 little bugs invaded the bar top. It was as if we were being invaded! Literally we were drinking and reading the menu and out of the corner of my eye these little tiny " spider- like" bugs began crawling all over the bar and my silverware on the bar. They were quick and fast and we saw more coming after them! Scared the crap out of me. We looked for our server but he was helping at the host stand. Manager ( female Asian lady) came out and said, " oh, we have a pest service, I'll call them"; she turned around and left us there; And made us pay for our drinks. We left immediately! Lackadaisical attitude. Creepy infestation.

We were looking for a light late lunch and this was the perfect stop. Although we were admiring the pizza snd pasta options, I chose the pear and apple salad. It was huge! And loaded with fruits and nuts with a wonderful vinaigrette. The big chunks of bread were nice to dip in the EVOO and balsamic. Yum!

Sara was our server and she was great. The restaurant is conveniently located on the mall, so after a few hours of shopping a nice place to grab a bite to eat. The shrimp fettuccine Alfredo was good on the garlic and not super heavy with the sauce and the shrimp was seasoned well. The shrimp Caesar salad was also delicious. Every table gets bread with oil and balsamic it was delicious as well!! Also recommend the crispy ravioli. Would definitely come back to this place again.

For a mall restaurant, this is a decent place to park it. I once had the very best Arrabbiata pasta dish there (which is no longer on their menu). The bread is delicious. Service has always been great. The only drawback this time is that I kept hearing a microwave door being closed and opened. How much is really homemade? The white sangria was really good---very mimosa-like. My pasta dish this time was OK. It's really the convenience of this location when I'm in OKC.

We were seated right away. We were brought warm cheesy bread. It was yummy. I ordered the chicken pasta salad on the suggestion of the waitress. It was very good. I would order it again. It was flavorful, refreshing, and light. Another person ordered the bison burger. They didn't ask how he wanted it cooked which was odd and it came out well done. The fries that accompanied it were lukewarm. The other person ordered a half sandwich. They said it was good and filling. The only real issue was in the bathroom. There was no soap and the one stall was clogged and toilet paper was everywhere. I told the manager, but later when someone else in my party went they said there still was no soap. Service was alright, not spectacular, but good enough.

We came in today for the wonderful lasagne. We haven't been in a while and we're very excited. Our server was very pleasant. Brought us bread, drinks, and took our order. Everything was fine. I drank my iced tea. Our server was good about waiting on the tables in hour area, but for some reason never offered me a refill. I noticed that 20 minutes had gone by, and she was taking care of all 4 of her tables except ours. I finally had to get her attention and ask for a refill. When she brought it she slammed it down on my table very hard. I asked if that was necessary as it was obviously loud. She ignored me. I then noticed she gave me the wrong drink. I was unable to get her attention after that. As we left I attempted to speak to the manager. Didn't appear like the manager cared at all. I was so disappointed in our experience. We love Pepperoni Grill, but not sure I ever want to experience the treatment again. Is this normal? Have others dealt with this type of rudeness? I'm frustrated. Ps: the options at the top of the comment section weren't letting me choose what needed improving, so I will state it here. Food: excellent Ambiance: very good Service: scale between 1-10? I give it a 8 up until she ignored our table, then a 2 afterwards. Management also didn't seem too concerned as I felt like we were just another table. Pepperoni Grill, do better!!

Came here to try something new. Customer service was great. The building seemed clean. I ordered the soup and salad, the waitress didn't know what the daily soup was. When she told me it was beef chipotle, we both seemed confused, but hey let's try it. It was very spicy and salty. I also orders the house salad with no croutons and no onions. It arrived at my table with both. My son enjoyed his pizza. I started to eat my salad and realized it had alot of brown pieces I was removing. The cheese chunk on top was hard to spread throughout my salad, so I ate it like a piece of bread. You also get complimentary loaf of bread with oil and vinegar while you wait for food. They ended up messing up the tickets due to server error. They gave my bill to another customer who had left and wanted me to pay her bill. I was told by a manager it was $1.00 cheaper than my bill, but how my server messed up. I didn't like how she wanted to seem like she was helping me out, when in actuality she was just trying to fix a possible register error at the end of the night, while embarrassing my nice server. The manager also honored my military I.D. It was an experience for sure. The bread at the beginning was better than my soup and salad.

Perfect service and food for a wedding. From the entre tasting appointment to narrowing down what we wanted to fit out budget, they were so easy and pleasant to work with. And ALL of my guests LOVED the food. No yucky wedding food. It was my sister that suggested Pepperoni Grill after she experienced it at a few weddings herself. Told me best wedding food hands down. They even catered one meal for a guest that was gluten free. Thank you Pepperoni Grill for making diner great and giving our guests enough energy to dance the night away.

Costumer service is amazing really professional! The food was brought out fast and it was great. Definitely trying them out next time I'm in the city!

The food was so good. We really liked the starter bread they give you while you wait for the food. Everything was clean and well decorated. Our waitress was very helpful and nice. We'll keep coming back next time we're in OKC.

This restaurant is tucked away inside of Penn Square Mall and has a cozy vibe inside. I've been going to this location since I was in college for one thing and that's their stuffed ravioli in pesto cream sauce! A friend of mine introduced me to this creation since it's not offered on the regular menu. The pesto cream sauce is so tasty and each ravioli pillow is stuffed to the max with various cheeses. My husband got the chicken risotto which was just okay. The chicken could have been cooked better and the risotto was not very tasty. I ordered 'The Perfect Margarita' and it was delicious!

the service was fine. the chicken piccata was incredibly bland - no flavor on chicken or pasta

Good food but smaller portions. Fried ravioli is good as well as the burger. Overall a great experience

We love eating at this restaurant. The food is really good. The prices are fair. Everything tastes fresh. Our waiter, Eddy was really good. We got our food fast and fresh.

The service was subpar and we had to send a panini back because it was ice cold in the middle.

I went in for a quick bite and bevies while I was getting screwed over on an alleged jewelry/watch fix, and oh my goodness was it GOOD! I had calamari and it was piping hot to the table.......I ordered a Stoli/tonic/lemon/splash simple syrup....the bartender came to table to ENSURE my order was correct! I always enjoy my visits and food and libations here!

Excellent service delicious menu changes periodically love that excellent location inside high end mall called Penn Square in Oklahoma City!

Years ago I really hated this place. Average uninteresting Italian that was over priced. For some reason I got talked into going back there this past year, and boy oh boy I'm I glad. Whether it's under new management, or competent cooks Pepperoni grill is hitting home runs. It's now gone from an afterthought to one of the better Italian restaurants on the north side. Located at Penn Square mall next to Dillard's on the west side. There's the usual fare of pasta's, pizza, and other Italian cuisine plus stakes, seafood, burgers, and wood fired chicken. Skip the Olive garden across the street. Better food, better service, better price, and no long lines to wait in. You won't be sorry.

We had dinner at Pepperoni Grill while visiting Oklahoma City. Our server, Tyler was great! He deserves 5 stars. The food on the other hand was just ok. We were here several years ago and loved it. We were kind of let down tonight. The bread was good but did not have hardly any cheese like it had before. We had the calamari. It was not bad, and the marinara was yummy. I had the apple walnut salad with chicken. The dressing was good, but the chicken was so dry, I could barely swallow. I finished less than half. My husband had the Caesar salad and spaghetti. The salad was just ok. The dressing had an odd flavor. He enjoyed the spaghetti, but it was nothing really special. I did enjoy my chocolate martini. The food definitely wasn't worth $100.

First time trying pepperoni grill and I'm impressed. The bread they give complimentary has cheese in the middle. It's very good! And the meal I ordered was the chicken avocado pasta salad. It was delicious with a yummy creamy Italian dressing. Very good restaurant inside the penn square mall.

Got the same dish I've gotten there for years. Grilled salmon with artichoke risotto. It was as good as I remembered. Quiet atmosphere even with being in a mall.

Their food is just as great as it was when I visited 20 years ago. The portions are large and I didn't even have to have a side salad, and still took leftovers home. I did order an appetizer which was also proportioned liberally. Our waiter was on top of his game and pleasant. And don't even get me started on the free bread. As far as taste and service, these guys are awesome. The only drawback is that it is located at the mall, so parking can be complicated.

One of my family's favorite restaurants. We've been coming here for years. I've tried nearly every dish and enjoyed them. My favorites include the chicken spinach artichoke pizza, the pesto tortellini, the ravioli, and the turkey pesto chicken sandwich. Warm bread with olive oil and balsamic vinegar are served with each meal. Soup and salad lunch special is delicious too. The staff are always friendly, quick, attentive, and professional. Very well trained. Recently went to happy hour a few times. I highly recommend ordering the sliders and the fried mozzarella with a sangria. The tables are comfortable and the environment is casual. Bathrooms are kept clean. Great spot for lunch/brunch and then shopping afterward in the mall. My only critique is that they used to put more cheese in the bread loaves.

Not the greatest. Spotted a hair on the bowl that the server brought out with lemon wedges in it as soon as we sat down and ordered drinks. To be fair, the server took it away and brought out a hairless bowl. Food wasn't that great either. Chicken was dried out and risotto was too sticky. Bread wasn't really that fresh because the cheese(?) in the middle was solidified. Don't think I'll be back. I would rather go to Olive Garden and I'm not a fan of them either.

I really like this place. The atmosphere is nice and service has always been good. I do agree with some of the comments about the tea being weak. They could work on that. They do have some really great menu items though: first, the bread. Then I would recommend: 1. the chicken avocado pasta salad ( but you must get it with the homemade honey mustard dressing)! It tastes like a completely different and better dish! 2. The california club sandwich 3. the pizza with the goat cheese (Ive forgotten the name lol)4. The bread pudding!! Oh, and go for the monthly wine dinners! Great price for a 4 course meal and wine and the food is always great!

I've said many times that I'm not a huge fan of the mall, but if I'm going to the mall, and I decide I'm going to eat a meal there, I'm probably going to Pepperoni Grill. The food court at Penn Square Mall doesn't really do much for me, but Pepperoni Grill has never disappointed. They also have this bread that comes out before the meal that has cheese baked into the middle of it...... mmmmm not bad at all. I generally stick to the Italian classics when I come here, and I've had pretty good ravioli, solid chicken parmesan, and always leave happy. I wouldn't recommend going here just for the food, as there are many places in that part of the city with better Italian food, but it's way better than any other food at the mall and is consistent tasty.

During COVID-19, all staff wore masks. Ordered the spinach artichoke dip and maghrertia pizza. I love love the cheese bread that they serve while you wait for your food. I don't know if that's a good idea because I love bread and by the time entre comes out. I'm full. Haha. Pizza and dip were great!

Well, another take out disaster. I ordered Chicken Picatta. It arrived with a mountain of spaghetti and 2 large chicken breasts. Talk about a dish that tasted like "nothing" this was it. A few capers with oil poured over the spaghetti. I add some pictures. Not a taste of lemon, butter or white wine...all used to make this dish. It was pure oil. I tried to salvage it, but ended up throwing it out. Chicken was lightly breaded and drenched in oil as well. 1st picture is how it arrived, 2nd picture me trying to extract the oil and the 3rd is the oil still left over in the take out carton. It is ridiculous that this dish is so hard for Oklahoma City. It is simple: Butter, white wine/lemon and capers. Oh the cheese, perhaps a tsp melted on top.

Best Chicken Parmigiana I have had in a good while. I ordered both red and white sauce. Large portion of greatness. Hope to try again soon

My family and I went to this place to eat dinner and there was a roach on our booth, the manager came and removed the roach but, what bothers me is she acted as if the roach was ours when we don't have roaches in either of our homes, The restaurant has been going downhill these last few years.

Went there for birthday lunch and enjoyed a very pleasant, very tasty lunch. Good service. Generous portions. Be aware that when you order blue cheese dressing for your salad you get a wedge of blue cheese with it! Which is good. The cheese bread with olive oil and balsamic vinegar was great as usual. We ordered chicken Parmesan, which we shared and still had left overs! The birthday person was gifted with his choice of desert. He chose crème brulée which was creamy smooth. Birthday person left very happy. It was almost a surprise lunch.

I would say this is "ok". Nothing stood out as delicious, but my chicken breading was soggy. I ate about 2 bites before I pushed it away. I would have tried something else, but server never asked why I didn't eat my meal and by the time she came by, my husband was done eating. My husband enjoyed his seafood medley meal. He said it was cooked well and had good flavor. Our salads were acceptable and fresh. We will go elsewhere for Italian for the same price.

The servers were very friendly and efficient. We were surprised at how fast the food was ready. The nachos and lasagna were very good. I was disappointed with the chicken picatta. It was previously the best in town, but not now. The breading on the chicken was soggy.

Really surprised to see Pepperoni Grill not have at least 4 stars. I haven't been here in forever (when did they remove peppercorns from the comp bread? And why? I loved it!) I'm dining solo tonight, it's a busy Friday, and sitting at the bar and honestly everything has been fantastic! I got a $4 glass on champagne and the chopped salad with salmon. What I love most about the salad is greens are spinach leaves and there's big juicy grape halves and mandarin orange slices that pair perfectly with the tangy feta and smoky salmon. And the salmon was cooked perfect. It's the first time I've ever been asked how I wanted my salmon prepared at a restaurant. I asked for medium and it was just perfect - flaky and tender.

We loved this restaurant! We visited yesterday primarily because we were famished from shopping. What a delight. My husband ordered eggplant parmesan and it was the best we'd ever tasted. I had the tortellini and it was rich and tasty. The bread was warm and soft. The service was good. We will definitely be back!

The bread is unique and delicious, the olive oil is perfect and high quality. Everyone is nice and knowledgeable, and they are always accommodating to special menu requests. Our favorite local Italian restaurant in OKC! Nice atmosphere.